Law report No. GLW-7438 · filed November 18, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Federal Judges Push Back on CBP Warrantless Phone Seizures
Judges in Virginia and Massachusetts ruled against CBP over warrantless phone seizures, with one calling the government's tactics 'designed to inflict a maximal burden' on a lawyer.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read754 words
Holding
- Judge Allison D. Burroughs barred the government from decrypting lawyer Andrew Lattarulo's data during litigation, ruling the phone seizure was likely pretextual retaliation.
- Judge Leonie M. Brinkema ordered CBP to explain what it did to nurse Muhammad Numaan Imam's seized electronics and questioned its secrecy claims in a November ruling.
- Lattarulo's phone was seized by three CBP officers and a DHS agent at Boston Logan after Aruba preclearance; DHS mailed it back after downloading his data.
- CBP sought a two-day extension one day before Brinkema's deadline, citing needed coordination across DHS components.
- The Supreme Court appears interested in hearing a challenge to warrantless electronic border searches.

Two federal judges ruled against Customs and Border Protection within days of each other, and both decisions landed hard. Judge Leonie M. Brinkema of the Eastern District of Virginia found the agency was improperly hiding what it did to a nurse's electronics. Judge Allison D. Burroughs of the District of Massachusetts found CBP was likely retaliating against a lawyer by seizing his phone. The rulings arrived the week of November 10, and they signal eroding patience with warrantless device searches at the border.
For years, CBP has claimed broad authority to search travelers' electronic data at the border, where Fourth Amendment privacy protections traditionally do not apply. Travelers who refuse to hand over passwords can simply have their devices seized. The Supreme Court now appears interested in hearing a challenge to the practice, and lower courts increasingly seem annoyed with the agency's posture.
What happened to lawyer Andrew Lattarulo?
Andrew Lattarulo co-owns Georges Cote LLP, a firm handling personal injury and immigration cases. Last year, returning from vacation, he cleared CBP preclearance in Aruba, which lets travelers "cross" the U.S. border before boarding a flight home. At Boston Logan International Airport, three CBP officers and a Department of Homeland Security agent pulled him aside and seized his phone.
The DHS later mailed the phone back after downloading all of his data. Before the government could decrypt it, Lattarulo sued.
The government said the seizure was part of an investigation into the firm for illegally employing foreigners. Burroughs was not persuaded. Audai Cote, the law firm partner who actually oversees employment compliance and who had received a DHS information request three days earlier, passed through the same airport the same day without incident.
Burroughs ordered the government not to decrypt Lattarulo's data while the case proceeds. She has not yet ruled on his Fourth Amendment claims, but she signaled the government likely overstepped. The government "provided no evidence that searches of cellphones are frequently conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here," she wrote in a ruling issued Friday. The method, she wrote, "appears designed to inflict a maximal burden on Lattarulo" and "lends substantial support to an inference that its actions were pretextual."
Why was nurse Muhammad Numaan Imam's phone seized?
Muhammad Numaan Imam, a psychiatric nurse practitioner from Virginia, still has no idea why CBP seized his electronics last month. Officers at Washington-Dulles International Airport told him he had been "flagged" for unnamed reasons upon returning from a family vacation to Turkey. They demanded his passwords. Imam said he legally could not hand them over, because his phone held patient communications and case management software.
"Your lawyer cannot do anything. We are the authorities at the border," one officer told Imam before seizing all of his family's electronics, according to the lawsuit.
Imam sued. CBP immediately mailed the electronics back, without ever explaining what it was looking for. Brinkema ordered the agency to explain what it did to the devices before returning them, but the agency is now fighting to keep its answers sealed from both the public and Imam himself, citing sensitive law enforcement tactics.
"Nearly all of the information the defendants claim is privileged concerns what CBP does when it seizes electronic devices, which the government has routinely disclosed on the public record in other cases," Brinkema wrote in her Tuesday ruling. "That the government has equipment they use to attempt to access and copy the data contained on cellphones and laptops should be of no great surprise to anyone, much less to those who may have something to hide."
She gave the agency until Tuesday to show why she should not unseal most of the information. A day before the deadline, CBP asked for a two-day extension, saying the order "requires coordination across multiple components of the Department of Homeland Security regarding sensitive law enforcement matters."
What does this mean for practitioners?
The practical stakes are mounting for border search litigation. Both cases expose thin government justifications and, in Lattarulo's case, raise attorney-client privilege concerns that reach beyond the Fourth Amendment. Imam's counsel, Jenin Younes, told Reason: "In the past, the government has abused national security and law enforcement justifications to cover up corruption and dishonesty, and it's hard not to conclude that is what they are doing here."
Courts have historically deferred heavily to the government at the border. That deference now has visible limits, and the Supreme Court may soon set them definitively.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
326 articles
Also before the court
- Boston Court Blocks Feds From Searching Seized Lawyer's Phone
- Judge Finds CBP Phone Seizure of Immigration Lawyer Likely Retaliatory
- Second Circuit Backs 'Suspicionless' Border Searches of Digital Devices
- Federal judge orders White House records search in ABA 'Big Law' case
- Federal Prosecutors in Washington Will Stop Defending Many Habeas Cases