Law report No. GLW-9487 · filed November 18, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Federal Judge Voids Wildlife Review for First US Deep-Sea Mining Sale
Judge Jill Otake voided NMFS's Endangered Species Act review of the first US deep-sea mining lease sale, covering 31 million acres off American Samoa, three days before auction.
By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read854 words
Holding
- Judge Jill Otake ruled Monday, three days before the planned Thursday lease sale, that NMFS violated the Endangered Species Act.
- The leases cover more than 31 million acres of seabed northeast of American Samoa's Manu'a Islands.
- The fisheries service issued its informal consultation letter 10 days after determining it had enough information, in February.
- A second lease sale off the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively scheduled for December.
- The ruling does not order the Interior Department to cancel or delay Thursday's auction.

Three days before the Interior Department planned to auction the nation's first deep-sea mining leases, a federal judge threw out the wildlife review underpinning the sale. U.S. District Judge Jill Otake ruled Monday, November 3, that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act by reviewing only the lease sale itself — not the mining it could eventually produce.
"As extinction is permanent, caution and foresight before acting are necessary," Otake wrote in her 41-page order for the District of Hawaii.
What exactly did the court decide?
The case pits two environmental groups — Fa'asao Amerika Samoa and Conservation Council for Hawaii, represented by Earthjustice — against the fisheries service and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick. The groups sued in August, arguing the agency never considered what could happen after the leases were sold.
The leases cover two areas of seabed northeast of American Samoa's Manu'a Islands — more than 31 million acres. The Marine Minerals Administration, a new bureau formed this summer by merging two offshore energy offices, planned to sell them Thursday.
Otake, a Donald Trump appointee, rejected the government's narrow framing of the proposed action. She found it ignored the leases' real purpose.
"Limiting the agency action here to the lease sale and preliminary activities ignores the reality that the purpose of the leases being sold is eventually to conduct deep-sea mining," she wrote.
The leases would initially authorize only preliminary work, such as mapping and sampling the seabed. Later, they could allow companies to collect mineral-rich nodules from the ocean floor.
Why did the informal review fail?
The mechanics matter here. Under the Endangered Species Act, an informal review can end with a letter saying a project is unlikely to harm protected species. A formal review requires a more detailed assessment of whether the project could push species toward extinction or damage their habitats.
The Marine Minerals Administration requested the quicker route. In February, the fisheries service agreed — and issued its letter just 10 days after determining it had enough information to begin the consultation.
Otake called the review "cramped, expedited, informal." She said it examined only the early survey work, and she described the approach as "apparently unprecedented." At an October 30 hearing, she noted, the government effectively conceded it had no prior example of such a review.
The affected waters stretch near American Samoa, Hawaii and the West Coast. They host several dozen protected species, including blue, fin, sei and sperm whales, sea turtles and five types of coral.
How did the government defend itself?
The government argued the fisheries service only had to review the project as the Marine Minerals Administration described it. Otake disagreed. A consulting agency "may not blindly accept" another agency's description of what it plans to do, she wrote.
She also distinguished the oil and gas leasing cases the government cited. In those cases, agencies completed formal reviews that considered at least some post-sale effects.
The government's second argument: deep-sea mining is "in its nascent stages and not yet reasonably certain to occur." Otake said uncertainty was no excuse, because the law demands foresight.
She added a telling detail. The process began with an unsolicited request from mining company Impossible Metals Inc. The administration is "not leasing for leasing's sake," she wrote.
The government asked Otake to leave the approval in place while the agency redid its review. She refused, calling the error fundamental.
"NMFS needs to do the bulk of its consultation duty for the first time," she said.
What happens to Thursday's auction?
Here's the practical puzzle for practitioners. The ruling voids the fisheries service's environmental approval. But it does not order the Interior Department to cancel or delay the sale. Whether the department can proceed without that approval — or will take other steps first — remains unclear.
Otake did not address the plaintiffs' remaining arguments, including a claim that the review missed indirect effects of the early survey work.
The litigation map keeps expanding. A second lease sale, covering waters off the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam, is tentatively scheduled for December. The same Earthjustice lawyers are challenging that sale in a separate case. The groups have also filed another lawsuit attacking the administration's final leasing notice for the American Samoa sale.
Representatives for the fisheries service, the Marine Minerals Administration and Earthjustice did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
What does the ruling mean for practitioners?
The decision tightens the screws on agency consultation practice. Agencies can no longer shrink the "proposed action" to its smallest component — the sale, the permit, the survey — and hope the courts accept the framing. When a leasing program's stated endpoint is extraction, the consulting agency must analyze downstream effects from the start. Think of it as the difference between reviewing a building permit and reviewing the building. For offshore energy regulators and industry counsel, the ruling signals that informal consultations issued at speed, without formal biological assessments, face real judicial risk when the action's ultimate purpose is clear on the face of the lease itself.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
343 articles
Also before the court
- Suncor v. Boulder: A Structural Preemption Fight at the High Court
- Eleventh Circuit Weighs Reversing Chilean Sea Bass Import Ban
- Fifth Circuit Weighs Texas Fossil Fuel Boycott Law's Fate
- Alito Recuses From Climate Case as Trump Returns to Emergency Docket
- Ninth Circuit Strikes Down Part of California Climate Disclosure Laws