Law report No. GLW-1878 · filed November 15, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Boston Court Blocks Feds From Searching Seized Lawyer's Phone
Judge Allison Burroughs (D. Mass.) has enjoined the government from searching data seized from immigration lawyer Andrew Lattarulo's phone, finding the warrantless Logan Airport search likely retaliated against his Instagram speech.
By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read809 words
Holding
- On November 14, 2026, Judge Allison Burroughs (D. Mass.) granted a preliminary injunction in Lattarulo v. Mullin blocking access to seized phone data.
- CBP and HSI seized the phone without a warrant at Logan Airport on September 28, 2025, copying all data; the phone was returned eight days later.
- The search came three days into HSI's own ten-day presumption-of-compliance window following a September 25, 2025 Notice of Suspect Documents.
- Lattarulo's Instagram know-your-rights videos regularly amass hundreds of thousands of views.
- The court left open whether the border search exception covers suspected violations of 8 U.S.C. § 1324a, a domestic hiring offense.

A federal judge in Boston has barred the government from accessing data seized from an immigration lawyer's cell phone, ruling on November 14, 2026 that the warrantless border search was likely unconstitutional retaliation for his public speech.
Judge Allison Burroughs of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted a preliminary injunction in Lattarulo v. Mullin. The order "enjoin[s] Defendants from accessing the data obtained from the phone before this action is resolved."
Who is the lawyer, and what happened at Logan Airport?
Andrew Lattarulo is an immigration lawyer and part owner of Georges Cote LLP, a firm representing "thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings." He also runs a popular Instagram account posting know-your-rights videos on U.S. immigration matters. Those videos regularly "amass hundreds of thousands of views."
The backdrop is an enforcement action. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), the investigative arm of the Department of Homeland Security, was investigating the firm for employing individuals without work authorization. On September 8, 2025, HSI served Audai Cote — the firm's registered agent and the person in charge of I-9 compliance (the federal employment-eligibility verification paperwork) — with a Notice of Inspection. Cote is not an immigration attorney; he focuses on personal injury.
The firm responded on September 12. The government issued a Notice of Suspect Documents on September 25, giving the firm ten days to verify the identity and work authorization of the named employees.
Then came the weekend trip. Both partners flew from Boston to Aruba in late September 2025. Cote returned to Logan Airport on September 27 without incident. When Lattarulo landed the next day, September 28, three CBP agents and one HSI officer stopped him as he got off the plane. They seized his phone without a warrant and downloaded a complete copy of its data. The phone came back by overnight delivery eight days later.
The copied data is currently unreadable, but the government says it will convert and search it if the court permits. That data includes privileged attorney-client communications. The government said any search would use a taint team (a screen of lawyers separating privileged material) to protect confidences.
Why did the court call it retaliation?
The First Amendment analysis turned on causation — whether the search would have happened "but for" Lattarulo's protected speech. The court laid out three strands of evidence supporting pretext, and each one is worth a practitioner's attention:
- Unusual method. The government offered no evidence that phone searches are common in employment investigations. Lattarulo's evidence suggested criminal charges against employers for hiring unauthorized workers are "exceedingly rare." A "highly unusual investigative method that appears designed to inflict a maximal burden" supports an inference of pretext, the court said.
- Timing. HSI's own policy presumes employers show reasonable care if they fix problems within 10 business days of a Notice of Suspect Documents. The search came just three days in. The government had to "short-circuit its orderly investigative procedures," Burroughs wrote.
- A comparator. Cote had the same or greater access to employment records but did not speak publicly. He landed a day earlier. If speed mattered, the court reasoned, Cote "would have been a more logical target."
The court also engaged the probable-cause problem. Probable cause usually defeats retaliation claims, but the Supreme Court recognizes an exception where officers "typically exercise their discretion not to" act — like arresting a vocal police critic for jaywalking. The jaywalking analogy fit: phone searches aren't routine here, and the similarly situated partner wasn't searched.
Defendants said they hold additional evidence showing the search would have happened regardless, but withheld it to protect the ongoing investigation. That choice, the court held, left the record adequate for "limited preliminary relief."
What about the Fourth Amendment claim?
The court declined to resolve it, but its dicta are striking. Border searches of phones fall under the border search exception, which allows "routine" searches without suspicion and "non-routine" searches with reasonable suspicion, under Alasaad v. Mayorkas (1st Cir. 2021).
The open question: suspicion of what? Alasaad spoke both of "border-related crime" and of "activity in violation of the laws enforced or administered by CBP or ICE." Hiring violations under 8 U.S.C. § 1324a fit the second phrase but arguably not the first. "It appears that the government seized on a fortuitous border crossing following a weekend vacation as an opportunity to search for evidence of a domestic crime," Burroughs wrote. Given the novelty, she declined a firm conclusion.
Mary Lemay and Patrick M. Hanley of Butters Brazilian LLP represent Lattarulo.
The practical takeaway: border-search power has limits, and prosecutors who time device seizures to a target's travel risk First Amendment liability if the target has been publicly critical — especially where agency protocols were skipped and comparators went untouched.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
333 articles
Also before the court
- Judge Finds CBP Phone Seizure of Immigration Lawyer Likely Retaliatory
- Federal judge orders White House records search in ABA 'Big Law' case
- Federal Prosecutors in Washington Will Stop Defending Many Habeas Cases
- Supreme Court to Review Trump Asylum Suspension at Border
- Supreme Court to Review Trump's Asylum Suspension at Border