Law report No. GLW-7210 · filed November 17, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Federal judge orders White House records search in ABA 'Big Law' case
Judge Amir Ali has ordered the Executive Office of the President to search records tied to Karoline Leavitt's 'Big Law' remark in the ABA's First Amendment lawsuit.
By Amara Osei4 min read854 words
Holding
- Judge Amir Ali ordered the records search on November 16 in the ABA's lawsuit against the Executive Office of the President.
- The email search window runs February 13 to April 18, 2025, when Trump signed five executive orders against law firms and nine firms reached agreements.
- Parties must agree on search terms and propose a schedule by December 4.
- Ali denied dismissal in March in a 21-page opinion, citing Leavitt's 'policy team' remark.
- The ABA sued in June 2025, alleging the orders coerced firms to abandon disfavored clients and causes.

A federal judge has ordered the Executive Office of the President to search its records for documents connected to then-press secretary Karoline Leavitt's remark that the administration was holding "Big Law" accountable for its "lies." U.S. District Judge Amir Ali, sitting in the District of Columbia, issued the order on November 16 in the American Bar Association's lawsuit challenging President Donald Trump's campaign against major law firms. The White House must now turn over certain emails, memos and drafts, or formally assert privilege over them.
What did Karoline Leavitt say?
Leavitt made the statement in April 2025, as Trump imposed sanctions on law firms through executive orders and several firms negotiated deals to avoid them. "President Trump's policy team is executing on his directive to hold Big Law accountable for their weaponization of justice and their lies and the strategy has proven tremendously successful," she said at the time.
The sentence has become evidentiary currency. The ABA built one of its records demands on the remark, and Ali's order quotes it verbatim to define the scope of the White House search. The lawsuit alleges the sanctions on law firms amounted to illegal retaliation for activity protected by the First Amendment.
The remark has already earned its keep once. In March, Ali denied the government's motion to dismiss, citing Leavitt's reference to a "policy team" among the official statements pointing to a broader, coordinated effort. Takeaway: one press briefing line now shapes the discovery perimeter of a constitutional case.
What does the order require?
Ali confined the email search to the period from February 13 through April 18, 2025. He described the window as running from "twenty-one days before the first law firm order until seven days after the last alleged law firm agreement." Within that roughly nine-week span, Trump signed five executive orders against law firms and nine firms reached agreements with his administration.
The judge explained why drafts matter. They "will reveal how the language in those orders changed over time, which may shed light on the government's motivation in issuing the orders and the desired effect of the orders on the law firms," he wrote.
His reasoning on memos ran parallel. Memoranda accompanying the orders and agreements "may also articulate the government's goals and analysis," he wrote, adding that memoranda formalizing the government's objective "could establish the existence of a policy of intimidation." He also noted that records already produced in the case refer to specific memos.
The order was not a clean win for the ABA. Ali acknowledged that some, and potentially many, of the records could be privileged. The parties must agree on search terms and propose a schedule by December 4. If the government appeals, it may ask Ali to pause the order while the appeal proceeds. Takeaway: the judge opened the archive door, but the privilege lock remains on the inside.
What is the government's objection?
The administration argued that the requests would "disrupt the functioning of the Executive Branch" and raise "substantial separation-of-powers concerns," according to the order. It has also refused to identify the members of the "policy team" Leavitt referenced, invoking presidential communications privilege, which protects advice given to the president. A White House lawyer argued that naming the advisers would discourage candid advice.
The ABA's first discovery request arrived in May. It sought:
- Communications with targeted firms
- Discussions about possible executive orders or agreements
- Communications involving Steve Bannon and Boris Epshteyn, Trump's personal senior counsel
A further filing followed a hearing on the ABA's motion to compel. Ali directed the government to file a notice identifying the people who drafted the law firm orders and the custodians of certain records. The Justice Department responded that the Executive Office of the President "strongly objects" to that directive. Takeaway: the fight has shifted from whether the White House must respond to who, exactly, was on the team.
How did the ABA lawsuit begin?
The ABA sued the Executive Office of the President in June 2025, arguing that the executive orders were intended to "coerce lawyers and law firms to abandon clients, causes and policy" positions the administration disliked.
Government lawyers pressed for dismissal on two fronts: the ABA had not plausibly alleged a policy threatening its members, and any threat had passed by the time the group filed suit. Ali rejected both arguments in a 21-page opinion, finding the ABA had standing to sue on behalf of its members. He called the government's argument that its members "are lawyers, not law firms" "unsound."
The practical consequence for practitioners is straightforward. Firms that struck agreements, and those that fought the orders, now face a discovery process that could expose internal White House deliberations about both. Privilege fights over the "policy team" and the drafting record are likely to consume the coming months, with December 4 as the first marker. Takeaway: the case now turns on paper, and the White House must decide what it shields and what it surrenders.
By Amara Osei, Global Law Wire
via wonderwall.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- DOJ Calls for Sanctions on Google in Landmark Antitrust Case
- US Courts Chip Away at ICC Sanctions as First Amendment Claims Mount
- Google Appeals Landmark Search Antitrust Ruling to Federal Appeals Court
- US Judge Dismisses Publishers' Antitrust Claims Against Google Over AI Search
- Record Fines Fail to Curb AI Hallucinations in Court Filings