Law report No. GLW-7099 · filed November 15, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Cato Amicus Brief Urges First Circuit to Kill $100,000 H-1B Fee
Cato, Wilson Sonsini and Prof. Michael McConnell urge the First Circuit to void the $100,000 H-1B fee as an unconstitutional executive tax under Learning Resources.
By Grace Kim3 min read659 words
Holding
- Cato Institute filed an amicus brief on Thursday, November 12, 2026, in the First Circuit H-1B fee case.
- The fee at issue is $100,000 per H-1B visa application.
- Two federal district courts have already invalidated the fee, one relying on Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 607 U.S. 229 (2026).
- Prof. Michael McConnell, a former federal judge, co-authored the brief with Wilson Sonsini lawyers Deno Hemonas and Philip Wilkinson.
- No President in over a century has used INA Sections 212(f) or 215(a) to raise revenue, the brief argues.

A $100,000 fee on H-1B visa applications faces a new constitutional challenge at the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. On Thursday, November 12, 2026, the Cato Institute filed an amicus brief supporting California and other states that sued to block the Trump Administration's exaction. Tech firms, research institutions and other employers use H-1B visas to hire immigrant workers and researchers with specialized skills.
Two federal district courts have already struck the fee down. The first ruling invalidated the charge because, the court held, the executive had illegally usurped Congress's power to impose taxes. That decision relied heavily on the Supreme Court's recent tariff ruling in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 607 U.S. 229 (2026), a case Cato helped litigate. A second federal district court later invalidated the fee on separate grounds.
Who wrote the brief?
Deno Hemonas and Philip Wilkinson of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Rosati worked on the filing pro bono. Stanford Law School Professor Michael McConnell, a former federal judge, also joined the effort. McConnell is one of the nation's leading experts on executive power, a prominent conservative originalist, and served as lead counsel in the Supreme Court phase of the IEEPA tariff case. The brief blends academic firepower with experienced appellate practitioners.
What does the brief argue?
The core argument tracks the Supreme Court's tariff jurisprudence. As the Court emphasized in Learning Resources, "the Framers gave Congress alone access to the pockets of the people." The brief quotes Alexander Hamilton calling the tax power "the most important of the authorities proposed to be conferred upon the Union."
The filing presses four main points:
- The exaction is a tax. Its "defining feature" is that it raises revenue, the brief says, citing Learning Resources, 607 U.S. at 241. It is neither a fee covering program costs nor a penalty.
- "Restrict" does not mean "tax." The brief argues the case asks whether the same President may "accomplish by a different label what Learning Resources forbade" — imposing a tax of his own devising on entry of noncitizens while calling it a "restriction." The government, the brief notes, can identify no statute in which the words "restrict" or "restriction" confer tax authority.
- The INA's fee structure forecloses the claim. The Immigration and Nationality Act contains express, detailed provisions for fees and payments, setting each amount and specifying how funds are collected and spent. Congress does not "hide elephants in mouseholes," the brief argues, quoting Whitman v. American Trucking Ass'ns, 531 U.S. 457, 468 (2001).
- Historical practice cuts against the government. In more than a century, no President has used Section 212(f) or Section 215(a) of the INA to raise revenue, a point the government does not dispute. Under Learning Resources, that absence is "strong evidence" the power does not exist.
Do the major questions and nondelegation doctrines matter here?
They do. The brief contends the government's statutory reading violates the major questions doctrine, which requires Congress to speak clearly when delegating power over a major economic or political issue to the executive. The power to impose unlimited taxes on any visa holders or immigrants entering the United States is, the brief argues, undoubtedly a major one. And if the court were to find that Congress somehow granted such sweeping authority, the brief adds, the grant would violate the constitutional nondelegation doctrine constraining delegations of legislative power.
What is at stake for practitioners?
For immigration counsel, the case tests whether executive immigration authority can double as a revenue instrument. Employers and universities face a fee that would price most H-1B sponsorship out of reach. A First Circuit affirmance, building on two district court losses and the Supreme Court's tariff precedent, would entrench the principle that only Congress may tax entry. The takeaway: the fee's fate now turns on whether labeling a tax a "restriction" can survive the logic of Learning Resources.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
320 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court to Weigh DOL ALJ Fines in Sun Valley Orchards Case
- After SCOTUS Tariffs Ruling, Refund Fight and New Trade Actions Loom
- Cato Fires Back at Trump's 50% Canada Tariffs in Trade Court
- Supreme Court Denies Review in DEI, Research Funding and Gun Cases
- Supreme Court to Review Trump's Asylum Suspension at Border