Law report No. GLW-4926 · filed November 15, 2026
Trade LawReported case
Cato Fires Back at Trump's 50% Canada Tariffs in Trade Court
Cato's amicus brief urges the US Court of International Trade to strike down Trump's 50% Section 338 tariffs on Canada as unlawful and unconstitutional.
By Amara Osei3 min read654 words
Holding
- Amicus brief filed November 13, 2026, at the US Court of International Trade in Gellert Global Corp. v. Trump
- First case challenging Trump's 50% Section 338 tariffs on Canadian imports; complaint filed October 20, 2026
- Liberty Justice Center represents the plaintiff and earlier won Supreme Court invalidation of IEEPA tariffs
- Brief argues Section 338 was superseded, violates the major questions doctrine and the nondelegation doctrine
- Separate Cato amicus brief, with Prof. Michael McConnell, filed September 14, 2026, against Section 301 tariffs

A 50 percent tariff on Canadian imports now faces its first constitutional test, and the Cato Institute wants the US Court of International Trade to strike it down. On November 13, 2026, Cato, joined by its scholar, filed an amicus brief in Gellert Global Corp. v. Trump, the inaugural challenge to the Section 338 duties the Trump administration imposed on goods from Canada. The complaint landed on October 20, 2026. The Liberty Justice Center, a public-interest firm, represents the plaintiff.
This is not the Liberty Justice Center's first encounter with sweeping tariffs. The same firm litigated the challenge to the massive duties Trump imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, a case the Supreme Court resolved earlier this year by invalidating those tariffs. The lawyers, it seems, have developed a taste for repeat engagements.
What does the brief actually argue?
The brief advances three grounds for striking down the Section 338 tariffs, which draw on a provision of the Tariff Act of 1930. First, the statute's own text. Section 338 requires that any retaliatory tariffs respond to discriminatory trade restrictions enacted by foreign trading partners, and that the duties "offset" those foreign barriers. The Trump administration's tariffs, the brief contends, satisfy neither requirement. The brief adds a textual kill shot: later statutes have superseded Section 338, rendering it no longer operative. A dormant ninety-year-old provision, in this reading, cannot carry a continental trade war.
Second, the major questions doctrine. That doctrine requires Congress to "speak clearly" when it assigns to the executive "decisions of vast 'economic and political significance.'" The power claimed here — extraordinary import taxes whenever another country imposes any trade restriction or declines to buy American goods — undeniably raises a major question. At the very least, the brief argues, it is unclear that Section 338 grants such vast authority. Uncertainty, under the doctrine, cuts against the executive.
Third, the nondelegation doctrine. Stripping the statute's qualitative conditions of operative force, the brief argues, hands legislative power to the President without meaningful limits. As the brief puts it, "an extremely high rate ceiling of 50 percent cannot substitute for clear legislative" limits on how and when tariffs may be imposed. A ceiling is not a standard.
Who is behind the filing?
The Cato scholar behind the brief has written previously on the Section 338 tariffs — including an article in The Dispatch arguing they are harmful and illegal, and a paper for the Montreal Economic Institute on the legal battle over Trump's tariffs and its implications for Canada. The scholarly groundwork preceded the litigation. It usually does.
The brief also carries corporate firepower. Daniel Cannistra and colleagues at Crowell & Moring provided pro bono drafting assistance, on what the filing describes as "very short notice." Amicus practice at trade-litigation speed is not for the faint of scheduling.
Is this part of a wider litigation front?
Yes. Cato, together with Professor Michael McConnell, also submitted an amicus brief on September 14, 2026, in separate litigation challenging the administration's Section 301 tariffs. The two filings form part of a coordinated effort to test multiple tariff statutes across multiple dockets.
What should practitioners take from it?
Three points matter for trade lawyers. The case gives the Court of International Trade its first opportunity to rule on whether Section 338 was ever a live delegation after 1930, which could remove a dormant statutory instrument from the executive toolkit. The major-questions argument imports the reasoning that proved fatal to the IEEPA tariffs before the Supreme Court earlier this year, inviting the trade court to extend it. And the nondelegation argument tests whether a numeric rate cap alone can cabin presidential tariff authority.
The takeaway in plain words: the same coalition that helped kill the IEEPA tariffs has now aimed its arguments at a second statute, and the Court of International Trade will decide whether Section 338 survives the encounter.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- Trump's Latest Global Tariffs Drawn Into Trade Court Challenge
- New Federal Court Challenge Targets Trump's Latest Global Tariffs
- Federal Court Strikes Down New Global Tariffs Imposed After Supreme Court Loss
- Forced Labor Tariff Fight Lands at U.S. Court of International Trade
- EU Weighs Response After US Supreme Court Blocks IEEPA Tariffs