Law report No. GLW-8148 · filed November 17, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

Three Trump Defeats at the High Court — and Three Roads Back

The Supreme Court beat Trump on Cook, birthright citizenship and tariffs in 2025-26, yet new orders, removal processes and refund litigation are pushing all three issues back toward the justices.

By Priya Raman5 min read985 words

Holding

  1. On June (5-4) ruling, the Supreme Court let Fed Governor Lisa Cook stay while challenging her August 2025 firing; a White House committee hearing is set for Dec. 14.
  2. The court struck down Trump's birthright citizenship order in Trump v. Barbara; a second order followed on Aug. 6 and is now enjoined in CASA v. Trump.
  3. In February the court ruled 6-3 in Learning Resources v. Trump that IEEPA tariffs exceeded presidential power; over $100 billion of an estimated $200+ billion paid has been refunded.
  4. On July 23 Trump imposed Section 301 tariffs on 60 trading partners, challenged by 25 states led by Oregon.
  5. A veto override would need 67 Senate votes and 290 House votes, limiting the new Democratic Congress.
What Trump cases might soon return to the Supreme Court?
PlateWhat Trump cases might soon return to the Supreme Court? — LVER / pixabay

The Supreme Court handed President Donald Trump three defeats during the 2025-26 term — on birthright citizenship, sweeping tariffs, and the firing of Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook — yet none of those rulings appears to be the final word. Litigation now unfolding in lower courts, and a fresh White House process against Cook, could return all three issues to the justices within the year.

What happened to Lisa Cook?

In late June, a closely divided court ruled 5-4 that Cook could remain at the Fed while she challenges her dismissal, in Trump v. Cook. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that Trump acted improperly by firing Cook in August 2025 without notifying her of his intent and without giving her a chance to respond to allegations that she committed mortgage fraud in 2021 by listing a Georgia condo and a Michigan house as her primary residence on mortgage applications. Cook, nominated by President Joe Biden to a full 14-year term in 2023, has served on the board since 2022.

The rematch machinery is already moving. On Oct. 7, Trump established a three-person committee of senior administration officials to investigate the allegations, with a White House hearing rescheduled from Nov. 5 to Dec. 14 after Cook could not attend. In an Aug. 26 letter, Cook's attorney, Abbe Lowell, called the allegations "unfounded and untrue" and warned that any dismissal based on them would be "corrosive of the independence that Congress sought to preserve" for the Federal Reserve. On Nov. 6, both sides asked the district court to pause proceedings while they negotiate the committee's process. If the committee recommends removal, further litigation — and a likely Supreme Court return — would follow, testing whether the new process satisfies the court's June opinion.

Congress could amend the Fed's governing statute to define removal "cause" or required procedures. Any such law, however, faces a presidential veto.

What does the second birthright citizenship order do?

On the last day before its summer recess, the court struck down Trump's executive order ending birthright citizenship in Trump v. Barbara, holding it irreconcilable with the 14th Amendment. Roberts wrote that children of parents "unlawfully or temporarily present" in the United States "satisfy both elements of the Citizenship Clause" and "are citizens at birth."

Roughly one month later, Trump signed a second order on Aug. 6. It targets children of foreign embassy employees and staff of international organizations such as the UN and World Bank, exempts children of parents designated "alien enemies," children born through fraudulent "commercial transaction[s] to purchase or access birthright citizenship," and births in territories where citizenship is not conferred by federal statute. The Department of Homeland Security issued an interim final rule implementing it on Sept. 4 — without prior notice and comment.

Challenges are multiplying:

  • In CASA v. Trump, Judge Deborah Boardman granted a preliminary injunction on Sept. 2, writing that the new order "is almost certainly unconstitutional as applied to the certified class." The government argues the plaintiffs lack standing because the order is "prospective only" and their fears rest on "rife speculation."
  • The ACLU filed Nathan v. Trump in Washington, D.C., in September, on behalf of an Australian citizen expecting a child by surrogacy and a European woman expecting a baby in April 2027; Judge Christopher Cooper has scheduled a hearing for Thursday.
  • In Barbara itself, the challengers withdrew motions to add claims after Judge Joseph Laplante suggested on Sept. 10 that the new order be challenged in a separate proceeding.

Notably, Barbara reaffirmed a broad constitutional conception of citizenship, leaving even a veto-proof Democratic Congress little room to legislate.

Will the tariff litigation return to the court?

In February, the court ruled 6-3 in Learning Resources v. Trump that Trump's 2025 tariffs exceeded his powers under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, the 1977 statute governing commerce during foreign-threat emergencies. The court said nothing about refunds on the more than $200 billion in tariffs paid; the government has now refunded over $100 billion — roughly half.

The silence bred litigation. In V.O.S. Selections v. Trump, the government is challenging Judge Richard Eaton's order at the Court of International Trade requiring refunds for importers who never sued and whose duties were liquidated more than 80 days ago. The government calls the order an impermissible universal injunction. On Oct. 8, Eaton certified a class of non-suing importers, which would spare each from filing individually.

The sequel statutes are also in court. Trump imposed temporary surcharges on Feb. 20 under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, capped at 150 days; the CIT struck them down 2-1 in May, and the Federal Circuit paused that ruling until the tariffs expired July 24. One day earlier, Trump imposed tariffs on goods from 60 trading partners — including Canada, Japan, Mexico and the UK — under Section 301, citing forced-labor enforcement failures. Twenty-five states led by Oregon challenge those tariffs as "a pretext to continue its illegal tariff scheme," arguing there is "no rational fit" between forced labor concerns and blanket global tariffs. The CIT heard arguments in the representative case, filed by Learning Resources, on Sept. 30.

Congress holds the tariff power but has delegated it; it could claw authority back, subject again to a veto, which would require 67 Senate votes and 290 House votes to override.

What should practitioners watch?

Cook's Dec. 14 hearing, the Nathan class motion, the Section 301 litigation, and the appeal over the Eaton refund order are the four most probable vehicles back to the justices. The midterm elections gave Democrats both chambers, but without veto-proof majorities their leverage is legislative theater, not law. Each pending case turns on process, standing or statutory scope — not on the merits the court already decided. That gap, not the rulings themselves, is where the next term will be shaped.

via supremecourt.gov (Original)

Filed under

  • supreme-court
  • trump-v-cook
  • federal-reserve
  • birthright-citizenship
  • tariffs
Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

324 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »