Law report No. GLW-3350 · filed November 17, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Supreme Court skeptical in Hoffman natural gas pipeline case
A majority of the U.S. Supreme Court appeared ready to reject state-law compensation claims by landowners whose property was taken for an interstate natural gas pipeline.
By Sophie Lindqvist3 min read637 words
Holding
- On Nov. 9, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in Hoffman v. WBI Energy Transmission, No. 25-159.
- No decision had issued, but a majority appeared skeptical of enforcing state compensation law in the dispute.
- Robert J. McNamara argued for the owners as the Institute for Justice’s deputy litigation director.
- The Natural Gas Act permits private condemnation requests but does not specify the law courts must use to value property.
- Justices Clarence Thomas and Chief Justice John Roberts questioned McNamara’s position.
A majority of the U.S. Supreme Court appeared ready on Monday, Nov. 9, 2026, to reject state-law compensation claims by landowners in Hoffman v. WBI Energy Transmission, No. 25-159.
By Sophie Lindqvist
The U.S. Supreme Court had not yet ruled. The case asks whether landowners whose property was taken for an interstate natural gas pipeline can enforce state compensation law. State law gives them broader protection here than federal law does.
What is the compensation dispute?
Hoffman concerns a taking by WBI Energy Transmission under delegated federal authority (a grant of federal power to a private actor). Eminent domain—the compulsory acquisition of private property—lets private companies acting under the Natural Gas Act ask courts to order forced sales without specifying which substantive law must govern valuation. The dispute concerns compensation, not condemnation itself.
Robert J. McNamara represented the owners as deputy litigation director at the Institute for Justice, a national public-interest law firm. He said: “The Natural Gas Act authorizes private companies to ask courts to order the forced sale of private property…” He argued that the statute is silent on the law courts must use to value the land.
Preemption (federal law overriding conflicting state law) requires more than statutory silence on his view.
Why did federal delegation matter?
McNamara conceded that state compensation law would not apply if the United States took the land itself, but the taking here involved a private company exercising delegated federal authority. For comparison, a direct federal taking would bypass state compensation law, while his argument treated WBI’s delegated taking differently.
He also argued that nothing in the statute extends the United States’s sovereign immunity (protection against lawsuits) to private companies. In his view, WBI therefore cannot invoke sovereign immunity against the state-law claim.
That distinction placed the government’s direct taking and a private delegated taking on different legal footings.
What did the justices ask?
Justice Clarence Thomas, normally receptive toward property-rights arguments, questioned whether delegated eminent-domain power carries state compensation rules with it. His question treated WBI as a total proxy for the United States.
Chief Justice John Roberts said: “I don’t understand why this isn’t an easy case.” He asked why a private-sector partner should receive the federal government’s compensation privileges if the government itself could take land without the additional rules imposed by state law.
Roberts also described the private route as more efficient because a developer could obtain land on the same terms as the government and avoid state-required attorneys’ fees (payments for legal work). He said McNamara’s position was easy to avoid.
What did the legal text leave unresolved?
Commentary accompanying the hearing viewed McNamara’s reading as stronger, and argued that federal law should make any proxy grant clear and unambiguous before a private company receives the government’s protections. It said textual silence or uncertainty should not automatically favor the private company over affected owners. It also read the Just Compensation Clause (the constitutional limit requiring compensation for government takings) as cabining eminent-domain power, not loosening it.
That position appeared to hold a minority at the court during arguments. The property owners may therefore be headed for defeat, though the court had not issued a decision.
What could a decision change?
For pipeline counsel and landowners, the practical issue is which compensation rulebook applies when a private pipeline company exercises delegated federal eminent-domain power. A ruling against the owners would point toward the federal government’s compensation treatment, without added state-law protections, including attorneys’ fees. A ruling for them would preserve the relevant state compensation law here.
The case remains pending after the Nov. 9, 2026 argument. The apparent majority favored WBI, making defeat the likely outcome on the present record.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
333 articles
Also before the court
- Suncor v. Boulder: A Structural Preemption Fight at the High Court
- Australian Court Rules on Coal-Mining Climate Impact; Industry Calls It 'a Blow'
- US Supreme Court Rules on Federal Courts' Powers Over Arbitral Awards
- UN's Top Court Says Fossil Fuel Failures Could Trigger Reparations
- Appellate Court Rejects NYC Greenwashing Claims Against Oil Majors