Law report No. GLW-7937 · filed November 14, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Trump Asylum Suspension Showdown
The Supreme Court on Nov. 13, 2026 agreed to hear Mullin v. RAICES, testing Trump's power to suspend asylum for illegal border crossers. Arguments expected next spring.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read722 words
Holding
- The Supreme Court granted review in Mullin v. RAICES, No. 26-239, on Nov. 13, 2026.
- The case challenges Trump's Jan. 20, 2025 proclamation suspending entry and asylum access at the southern border.
- A divided D.C. Circuit panel struck down key parts of the policy but kept its ruling on hold, so the restrictions remain in effect.
- The justices took two questions and declined a third on class-action compliance; oral argument is expected in spring 2027.
- Challengers are 13 individuals and three immigration nonprofits.

By Marcus Bennett
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed on Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, to hear Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, No. 26-239 — one of the most consequential immigration cases of President Trump's second term. The case tests whether the president can suspend asylum for migrants who cross the southern border illegally.
The Court's order grants review without deciding the merits. SCOTUSblog confirmed the move on Friday: "The Supreme Court on Friday added two cases to this term's oral argument docket." Oral arguments are expected next spring.
What did the lower courts decide?
The dispute began with President Trump's Jan. 20, 2025 proclamation. It declared an invasion at the southern border and suspended entry for covered noncitizens. Administration guidance also blocked those entrants from using asylum and related protections to stay, calling instead for rapid removal without the procedures that normally accompany an asylum claim.
A federal district judge struck down key parts of that policy. A divided D.C. Circuit panel largely agreed, holding that the proclamation could not bypass removal procedures and protections Congress had written into federal law.
The appeals court kept its ruling on hold while the administration sought Supreme Court review. As a result, the asylum restrictions remain in effect nationwide while the case moves forward.
What questions will the justices decide?
The Court accepted two issues for review:
- Whether the Jan. 20, 2025 proclamation and its implementing guidance are lawful.
- Whether the lower court had authority to issue broad, class-wide relief.
The justices declined a third question. The government had asked them to review whether the certified class itself complies with the rules governing class actions. That petition goes unanswered for now.
The government's petition argues the class is overbroad. It says the class includes people still overseas with no imminent plan to enter the United States. Those individuals, the administration argues, have suffered no injury and should not receive relief premised on a future decision to cross the border illegally.
What is the administration's legal foundation?
The proclamation rests on both constitutional authority and federal immigration statutes. It invokes:
- Section 1182(f) of Title 8, which lets a president suspend entry of aliens or classes of aliens deemed detrimental to U.S. interests.
- Section 1185(a)(1) of Title 8, which authorizes presidential rules and restrictions governing entry.
The order also cites the federal government's constitutional duty to protect the states against invasion. It describes a system overwhelmed by illegal crossings, unable to reliably screen entrants for criminal, national security and public health risks, and points to the power of cartels and transnational criminal organizations near the border.
Solicitor General John Sauer argues that suspending illegal entry and cutting off asylum for those who violate the suspension are central pieces of the president's response. He contends the president acted within both inherent executive authority and power Congress has delegated.
Who is challenging the policy?
The challengers are 13 individuals and three immigration nonprofits. They argue the president cannot replace the asylum and withholding procedures Congress created with a separate removal system of his own design.
What does this mean for practitioners?
The second granted question may matter most. It reaches the power of lower courts to block immigration enforcement on a large scale, and its consequences could extend well beyond this asylum policy. If the justices side with the government, nationwide or class-wide injunctions in immigration cases face a tighter leash. If they affirm the D.C. Circuit, the asylum statute's congressionally designed procedures will bind any future president seeking to sidestep them by proclamation.
What happens at the border in the meantime?
The policy stays in place. The administration says its enforcement program has sharply reduced pressure at the border. The Department of Homeland Security posted on Nov. 13 that "migrant apprehensions at the U.S. Mexico border have PLUMMETED." Asked Friday about reports of another caravan moving north, DHS posted: "Not going to happen. Under President Trump, the border remains secure and this caravan will NEVER enter our country."
The stakes extend past one proclamation. The case gives the Supreme Court a direct opportunity to define how far a president may go when Congress has already granted sweeping authority over entry into the United States.
via 100percentfedup.com (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
319 articles