Law report No. GLW-7891 · filed November 17, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Supreme Court Takes Up Mandatory Detention in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha
The justices will decide whether long-term residents arrested inside the U.S. can seek bond. Nine circuits say yes, two say no, and tens of thousands remain detained meanwhile.
By Amara Osei5 min read1,017 words
Holding
- On Oct. 1 the Supreme Court granted certiorari in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, a statutory bond-hearing dispute.
- Nine of eleven circuits to rule hold that Section 1226(a), not Section 1225(b)(2)(A), governs interior arrests; the 5th and 8th Circuits disagree.
- ICE's detained population hit a reported record of roughly 73,000 in mid-January 2026.
- On Oct. 23 the en banc 5th Circuit held in Sosnava Rodriguez v. Vergara that detainees have no due process right to a bond hearing; seven judges dissented.
- A decision in Rhoney is expected by the end of the term in summer 2027.

On Oct. 1, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, a case that will decide whether noncitizens who entered the country without inspection and were later arrested in the interior may ask a judge for bond while they fight deportation. The statutory question is now before the justices. A constitutional one waits behind it. Together they will determine whether people who have lived in the United States for years, even decades, remain detainable without a hearing.
How did the policy change?
For nearly thirty years after the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, every administration detained noncitizens arrested in the interior under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a), which permits release on bond subject to an immigration judge's review. In July 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement began requiring — for the first time — that anyone who entered without inspection, whether last year or decades ago, be detained under § 1225(b)(2)(A) for the duration of removal proceedings. That provision says immigration judges have no power to grant bond. Two months later, the Board of Immigration Appeals agreed with ICE in Matter of Yajure Hurtado.
The only exit now is discretionary, case-by-case parole for urgent humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit. ICE's overall detained population, including people held on other grounds, hit a reported record of roughly 73,000 in mid-January 2026.
What is the statutory dispute?
Section 1225(a)(1) deems any noncitizen "present in the United States who has not been admitted" an "applicant for admission." The detention command then provides that an alien "seeking admission" whom an officer determines is not "clearly and beyond a doubt entitled to be admitted" "shall be detained." Everyone agrees long-term residents who entered unlawfully are deemed applicants for admission. The fight is over whether that deemed status makes them "seeking admission," and therefore detainable without bond.
Eleven of the twelve circuits — all but the D.C. Circuit — have answered. Nine hold that § 1226, not § 1225(b)(2)(A), governs interior arrests: the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 6th, 7th, 9th, 10th and 11th Circuits. Two read the statute the government's way: the 5th and the 8th.
For the majority, "seeking admission," as the 1st Circuit put it, "means seeking lawful entry." A person who crossed years ago already entered. Judge Joshua Kolar, writing for the 7th Circuit, said the deeming clause does not "conjure a fictional intent to seek admission." Structure helps: the Laken Riley Act of January 2025 expanded § 1226(c)'s mandatory-detention categories to reach certain unlawful entrants — a needless step if § 1225 had always covered them. The majority also notes that five administrations over three decades read the statute their way, and that Congress would not silently have mandated detaining some two million people.
For the 5th and 8th Circuits, ordinary meaning cuts differently. Judge Edith Jones, writing for the 5th Circuit, reasoned that a college applicant does not stop seeking admission once the application is filed. "Years of consistent practice," she wrote, "cannot vindicate an interpretation that is inconsistent with a statute's plain text." Judge Barbara Lagoa, dissenting in the 11th Circuit in a line later adopted by a 1st Circuit dissenter, pressed the point: "If a person whom Congress has deemed an applicant for admission is not seeking admission, it is hard to know what Congress thought it was deeming him to be." Both sides also cite the Court's June decision in Mullin v. Al Otro Lado, which said fears of encouraging illegal entry "cannot defeat the best reading of the text" and called the rule that every word must do work "not an iron rule."
Rhoney itself is the government's challenge to a unanimous 2nd Circuit ruling for a Brazilian man who has lived in the United States more than twenty years, was detained in 2025 under § 1225(b)(2)(A), and whom that court found outside the provision. No argument date is set; proposed merits briefing runs into February, pointing to argument in late winter or spring and a decision by term's end.
What about the constitutional question?
On Oct. 23, the en banc 5th Circuit held in Sosnava Rodriguez v. Vergara that detainees under the mandatory-detention policy have no due process right to a bond hearing. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority: "Because Petitioners have never been admitted to the United States, due process does not entitle them to additional proceedings beyond what Congress has provided before they may be detained pending removal." Seven judges dissented. Judge Leslie Southwick countered that the court "has constructed an impenetrable wall between the Constitution and these long-term residents," each of whom by the record had lived in the country more than a decade.
The 3rd and 6th Circuits have held the opposite: detaining long-present noncitizens under § 1225(b)(2)(A) without a bond hearing violates due process. Geography, at present, makes all the difference. In Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi and the 8th Circuit's seven states, no ordinary path to a bond hearing exists; in Delaware, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, the Virgin Islands, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee, long-term residents can invoke circuit precedent recognizing such a right.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
If the Court affirms in Rhoney, noncitizens arrested in the interior could again seek bond everywhere, as before July 2025. A hearing does not guarantee release, and the burden generally rests on the detainee, but the right to ask would be uniform. If the Court reverses, mandatory detention becomes the statutory rule nationwide — yet the 3rd and 6th Circuit due process rulings would still govern there, and the justices would likely need to take Putra v. Lopez-Campos, the 6th Circuit case raising both questions, which the solicitor general urged them to hear and which they appear to be holding. If detainees win in Rhoney, the constitutional question may never need an answer.
The bottom line: a decision is expected by summer's end of term, and until then tens of thousands of people remain detained.
via congress.gov (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court Stay Clears Third-Country Deportations Without Hearings
- Supreme Court to Review Trump Asylum Suspension at Border
- Supreme Court Takes Up Green Card Fight for Revoked Asylum Holders
- Judge Denies Pseudonyms in Tren de Aragua Habeas Case
- Federal Prosecutors in Washington Will Stop Defending Many Habeas Cases