Law report No. GLW-3998 · filed November 13, 2026
Criminal JusticeReported case
ICC Chamber Splits Afghanistan Probe, Sparks Prosecutor Appeal
ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II ordered a separate Afghanistan investigation into Taliban gender persecution, prompting Prosecution appeals over judicial overreach and victims' rights.
By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read811 words
Holding
- Four arrest warrants against Taliban leaders unsealed 5 October 2026; initially sealed 8 July and 9 September 2025.
- Pre-Trial Chamber II ordered a separate investigation on 15 July 2026, acting on its own initiative.
- Prosecution appealed on 11 November 2026; Appeals Chamber submissions due 3 December 2026, response by 17 December 2026.
- Six States Parties — Chile, Costa Rica, Spain, France, Luxembourg and Mexico — made the November 2024 referral.
- Appeals Chamber authorised the original Afghanistan investigation in March 2020, reversing PTC II's April 2019 refusal.

On 5 October 2026, Pre-Trial Chamber II of the International Criminal Court unsealed four arrest warrants against senior Taliban leaders for gender persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1)(h) of the Rome Statute. The warrants were first issued under seal on 8 July and 9 September 2025. In substance, they allege the severe deprivation, 'through decrees and edicts', of girls' and women's rights to education, privacy and family life, and of the freedoms of movement, expression, thought, conscience and religion, along with the targeting of persons for 'expressions of sexuality and/or gender identity'.
But a quieter procedural fight has unfolded alongside the headlines. On 15 July 2026, the same Chamber ordered the Prosecution to open a separate investigation into 'crimes committed against women and girls after the Taliban takeover in 2021'. The Chamber acted on its own initiative, without submissions from the Prosecution or anyone else. That decision, and the Prosecutor's response, now sits before the ICC Appeals Chamber.
Why did the Chamber order a second investigation?
The Prosecutor's original request, filed in November 2017, covered three groups: the Taliban, the Afghan National Security Forces, and US armed forces and the CIA. Pre-Trial Chamber II rejected it in April 2019 — the first and only time a Chamber has refused authorisation under Article 15(4), and on grounds many scholars found doubtful. The Appeals Chamber reversed in March 2020, authorising an investigation covering crimes on Afghan territory since 1 May 2003, plus linked crimes on other States Parties' territory since 1 July 2002.
In September 2021, Prosecutor Karim Khan announced the Office of the Prosecutor would focus on crimes by the Taliban and IS-K and 'deprioritise other aspects of this investigation'. Then, in November 2024, six States Parties — Chile, Costa Rica, Spain, France, Luxembourg and Mexico — referred the situation, asking the Prosecutor to consider crimes against women and girls 'within its investigation into the Situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan'.
The Chamber saw it differently. Citing a 'principle of judicial oversight', it held it bore 'an inherent responsibility to ensure that investigations … remain within the scope authorised by the Court'. In its view, the 2021 Taliban takeover created a 'materially different factual and institutional context', involving 'distinct modes of commission' unrelated to armed conflict. The referral concerned persecution through discriminatory decrees made possible by the Taliban's de facto governmental authority — not insurgent conduct during the armed conflict. The 'proper administration of justice' justified a separate investigation.
What did the Prosecutor say?
On 6 August 2026, the Prosecution sought clarification and reconsideration. The decision had come 'without prior notice or opportunity to address the issues potentially arising from it' and used 'a novel procedure'. The Prosecution pointed out an awkward contradiction: all four existing arrest warrants concern persecution allegedly committed under Taliban policy since 2021 — conduct that, on the Chamber's own logic, falls outside the existing situation. A surrendered suspect could mount a jurisdictional challenge under Article 19(2)(a). Directing a new investigation would also be 'inconsistent with the flexibility afforded the Prosecutor' and would waste the Court's 'limited resources'.
On 3 September 2026, the Chamber dismissed the request in limine, finding 'no explicit statutory basis' for it. It declared the Prosecutor's discretion 'not unfettered' and stated bluntly: 'All acts of the Prosecution … are … always subject to the oversight of the Judiciary'. It disposed of the warrant problem as an 'ancillary matter', affirming the warrants 'were validly issued and remain valid'. The Presidency then assigned the new situation to the same Chamber, over a dissent from Judge Ibáñez Carranza, and on 5 November 2026 the Chamber ordered court records, including the four warrants, transferred to 'Situation in Afghanistan II'.
What does the fight mean in practice?
The Appeals Chamber takes a more permissive view of the existing investigation's scope: it has no end-date and includes later crimes, requiring only a nexus to the armed conflict. Critics note that inherent powers are not 'a form of carte blanche', as scholar Chester Brown puts it, and that resolving complex systemic questions without hearing submissions is unwise. A coalition of civil society groups voiced 'serious concerns about how the ICC's decision to require a separate Afghanistan investigation will impact victims' rights and ability to access justice', warning that separation 'creates complication and uncertainty for victims' and may marginalise pre-2021 crimes already deprioritised.
On 11 November 2026, the Prosecution appealed the 15 July decision, the order to comply, and the transfer order. The Appeals Chamber has invited victims' representatives, the Office of Public Counsel for Victims and the six referring States to file submissions by 3 December 2026, with the Prosecution's response due 17 December 2026. Given the systemic stakes — the boundary between prosecutorial independence and judicial oversight — appellate resolution can't come soon enough.
via icc-cpi.int (Original)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
333 articles
Also before the court
- ICC Judges Close Afghanistan Situation, Prosecutor Appeals
- ICC Chamber Closes Afghanistan Investigation Amid Pending Appeals
- ICC Presidency Constitutes Trial Chamber III for Duterte Case
- ICC Confirms War Crimes Charges Against Joseph Kony, Still At Large
- ICC Concludes Confirmation of Charges Hearing in Duterte Case