Law report No. GLW-7911 · filed November 17, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

ICC Judges Close Afghanistan Situation, Prosecutor Appeals

An ICC pretrial chamber closed the Afghanistan situation covering pre-2021 crimes on November 12, 2026. The prosecutor appealed, saying it never gave closure notice.

By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read860 words

Holding

  1. On November 12, 2026, an ICC pretrial chamber effectively closed the Afghanistan situation covering pre-Taliban-takeover crimes.
  2. The prosecutor appealed on November 13 and sought a stay of the closure.
  3. Four arrest warrants have been issued against senior Taliban officials, including the supreme leader, for gender persecution.
  4. The original investigation, authorized in March 2020, covered crimes in Afghanistan since May 1, 2003.
  5. The chamber acted under a new regulation allowing closure when the prosecution does not anticipate further activity.
ICC: Afghanistan Decision Risks Narrowing Access to Justice
PlateICC: Afghanistan Decision Risks Narrowing Access to Justice — sergeitokmakov / pixabay

An ICC pretrial chamber effectively closed the court's Afghanistan situation covering pre-2021 crimes on November 12, 2026, ending the investigative track that covered alleged crimes by US, Afghan government, and other forces. The prosecutor's office appealed the next day and asked for a stay.

Human Rights Watch says the decision risks blocking justice for victims of grave crimes committed before the Taliban's August 2021 takeover. Only the separate situation concerning Taliban abuses since August 2021 remains open.

What did the chamber actually decide?

The judges relied on a recently adopted ICC regulation. It lets a chamber close situation records when the prosecution has given notice that it "decide[d] not to initiate an investigation or determine[d] that he or she does not anticipate any further investigatory or prosecutory activities" in that situation.

Here's the problem. The chamber acted on its own initiative. The prosecution says it never provided that notice. During earlier proceedings, it had indicated the opposite — that it did not intend to provide one.

The chamber appears to have read the prosecution's statement of three lines of inquiry as a signal it would not pursue the rest of the original investigation. Two of those lines concern Taliban crimes since August 2021. One concerns Islamic State Khorasan Province (ISKP, an ISIS-affiliated group) crimes since 2016.

How did the situation get split in two?

Earlier in 2026, a pretrial chamber decision separated the Afghanistan situation — open since 2020 — into two. One covers Taliban abuses since August 2021. The other covered everything else in the originally authorized investigation. The prosecution has appealed that separation too, and only the Taliban track survives the November 12 closure.

The November 12 decision isn't the chamber's only stated ground. The judges also cited their own observations of "significant limitations to the [p]rosecution's ability to conduct its investigations and secure evidence," and noted the prosecution had not yet filed arrest warrant applications for ISKP crimes.

What was the original investigation supposed to cover?

In March 2020, ICC judges authorized the prosecutor to investigate all alleged crimes within the court's jurisdiction in Afghanistan — an ICC member country — since May 1, 2003. The authorization also covered linked crimes committed on the territory of another member state since July 1, 2002.

The 2017 request to open the investigation cited alleged crimes by US military and CIA forces. These included torture, cruel treatment, outrages upon personal dignity, and rape and other sexual violence "pursuant to a policy approved by the US authorities." For Afghan government forces, the prosecution cited torture, sexual violence, enforced disappearances, and extrajudicial executions. For Taliban forces: attacks on civilians, murder, persecution, and child soldiers.

The investigation was paused while the court weighed the then-Afghan government's deferral request. In 2022, judges concluded the government's own cases covered at best a "very limited fraction" of what an ICC investigation would reach. Investigations resumed that year, focused on the Taliban and ISKP, with alleged crimes by Afghan security forces and US personnel deprioritized.

What happens to victims now?

The closure pathway is slow. The chamber itself suggested the prosecution could request authorization to pursue other lines of inquiry later. The 2017 process took more than two years to resolve.

"Victims of serious international crimes committed by warring parties during Afghanistan's long conflict have faced many roadblocks to justice," said Liz Evenson, international justice director at Human Rights Watch. "The ICC judges' decision threatens to compound barriers to future accountability for US and Afghan government forces."

Four arrest warrants have been issued against senior Taliban officials, including the supreme leader, for gender persecution. In November 2024, six countries made a state referral (a formal request by states for the prosecutor to investigate) seeking investigation of crimes against women and girls since the 2021 takeover. Victims and NGOs have criticized the Taliban-only focus as a double standard and urged expansion.

Does politics hang over this?

Yes. The ICC faces open pressure from Washington. The US government has vowed to dismantle the court "brick by brick" to prevent prosecutions of Americans or Israelis. The Trump administration has sanctioned the court itself, several of its judges and prosecutors, three Palestinian human rights organizations, and a UN human rights expert. Human Rights Watch and three other organizations are challenging those sanctions in US federal court.

The chamber also relied on practical obstacles the prosecution faces in gathering evidence — a constraint that matters when a superpower is sanctioning your investigators and judges.

"The ICC acts as a critical court of last resort when other avenues to justice are closed," Evenson said. "ICC member countries should do all they can to protect the ICC from US attempts to obstruct justice in the cases before it."

The prosecutor's appeal and stay request now sit with the ICC's appeals chamber. That body overturned a 2019 refusal to authorize the Afghanistan investigation, a refusal Human Rights Watch called, at the time, a reward for obstructionist behavior by states. The stakes are procedural and human at once — whether the record on pre-2021 crimes stays open or closes for good.

via hrw.org (Source)

Filed under

  • international-criminal-court
  • afghanistan
  • war-crimes
  • taliban
  • prosecutorial-appeals
Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

333 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »