Law report No. GLW-9227 · filed November 16, 2026
Criminal JusticeReported case
ICC Chamber Closes Afghanistan Investigation Amid Pending Appeals
ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II closed the existing Afghanistan case on 12 November 2026, ending the inquiry into alleged U.S. war crimes and IS-K offences despite pending Appeals Chamber challenges.
By Amara Osei5 min read999 words
Holding
- On 12 November 2026, ICC Pre-Trial Chamber II closed the existing Situation in Afghanistan.
- The earlier split moved four arrest warrants to Afghanistan II, and two Prosecution appeals remain pending.
- Paragraph 23 said the Prosecution could not effectively conduct further investigative or prosecutorial activities.
- The investigation had run for six years, with only a limited number of arrest-warrant applications.
- On 9 October 2026, the United States designated the ICC and issued four general licences, including a 180-day wind-down.

By Amara Osei
On 12 November 2026, Pre-Trial Chamber II of the International Criminal Court closed the existing Situation in Afghanistan, not the new Afghanistan II, ending the Court’s inquiry into alleged U.S. war crimes and alleged crimes by Islamic State in Khorasan Province.
The Prosecution had not closed its investigation and still awaited the Appeals Chamber’s ruling on two appeals from the chamber’s earlier split of the case.
What did Pre-Trial Chamber II decide?
Issued as the Decision Closing the Situation in Afghanistan, the order invoked inherent judicial powers to safeguard the fairness and legality of proceedings and cited legal certainty, transparency and proper administration (paras. 14, 22). It deemed the Prosecution’s notification sufficient under Regulation 66ter(2) and ordered the existing situation record closed.
In a 6 August 2026 request for clarification and reconsideration, the Prosecution had stated that it “does not anticipate that any regulation 66ter(2)(a) notification would be appropriate until these proceedings have concluded” (para. 43). Its decision to appeal the earlier rulings likewise indicated that it did not regard the investigation as over.
The earlier rulings had opened Situation in Afghanistan II and transferred court records, including four arrest warrants, apparently on the chamber’s own initiative and without submissions. The Prosecution appealed both decisions; the Appeals Chamber had not ruled when the closure order issued.
Takeaway: The chamber treated the file as closed; the Prosecution treated the fight as open.
Why did the chamber close the investigation?
The chamber reasoned that Regulation 66ter prevents records from remaining open indefinitely where the Prosecution cannot pursue an investigation effectively or has no prosecutorial interest in continuing it. It treated notification as a transparency mechanism, not an additional substantive condition (para. 18).
Nevertheless, it concluded that “the Prosecution has not shown to be able to effectively carry out any further investigative or prosecutorial activities in the Situation in Afghanistan” (para. 23).
The chamber cited several practical factors:
- The investigation had run for six years, with only a limited number of arrest-warrant applications.
- Investigators faced significant limitations in conducting work and securing evidence.
- Time had passed since the alleged commission of the crimes.
- The Prosecution had not sought to prosecute alleged IS-K crimes.
On 27 September 2021, then-Prosecutor Karim Khan deprioritised the inquiry into U.S. conduct. PTC II later transferred alleged Taliban crimes since 2021 to Afghanistan II, but the existing situation still covered alleged IS-K crimes since 2016.
Closure therefore, absent reopening, effectively forecloses the U.S.-conduct and IS-K strands and any later reprioritisation within the existing record. The Prosecution also said it remained actively engaged in monitoring and supporting national investigations and prosecutions (para. 43).
Takeaway: Six years and constrained evidence favoured closure; the regulation produced the fight.
Why is the legal basis disputed?
The legal dispute concerns who may close the record and when. The provision governs closure and reopening of case and situation records, and Court judges inserted it less than one month before PTC II split Afghanistan. Its sequence is express:
- The Prosecutor first determines that no further investigative or prosecutorial activity is anticipated.
- The Prosecutor then informs the assigned Pre-Trial Chamber in writing.
- The chamber may close on application or proprio motu; residual matters remain with it unless the Presidency assigns them elsewhere, and reopening remains possible.
The central legal criticism is that the chamber converted a substantive precondition into procedural paperwork. Its reading cannot remove the text’s sequence, and inherent judicial powers do not supply a general licence to act beyond the Statute and Rules. Article 53 offers a familiar parallel: review under Article 53(3) follows a prosecutorial decision under Article 53(2).
Article 42(1) vests authority to conduct investigations, on referral or proprio motu, in the Prosecutor, and the Appeals Chamber has confirmed that allocation (para. 52). The Office of the Prosecutor’s 2021 Situation Completion Policy says work ends only after both investigation and prosecution phases.
That allocation protects prosecutorial independence, and the ruling shifts the balance toward judicial oversight. The Appeals Chamber has twice disagreed with PTC II about scope. Waiting for the pending appeals would also have avoided premature action.
Takeaway: The rule puts the prosecutor first and the chamber second; the ruling reversed the emphasis.
What changes for defence teams and prosecutors?
Closure ends investigative and prosecutorial activity in the existing situation unless the Prosecution reopens it. The four arrest warrants sit in the separate Afghanistan II record, whose division the Appeals Chamber still must review; practitioners cannot treat the new and old records as interchangeable.
Regulation 66ter leaves residual judicial matters with PTC II unless another chamber assumes them and makes reopening without prejudice. The Prosecution’s support for national proceedings continues, and any application to resume ICC work must satisfy the Statute, Rules and Regulations.
Takeaway: One case closed, one divided, and national prosecutions still moving.
Why does the political context matter?
Russia and the United States have imposed sanctions on elected ICC officials and staff, while threats to dismantle the Court have continued. On 9 October 2026, the United States designated the ICC itself and issued four general licences.
One licence provided a 180-day wind-down period for States Parties to demonstrate progress on diplomatic and legal resolutions addressing U.S. concerns. It can be adjusted according to their success or failure.
Timing and procedural irregularities invite concern, but the available material does not establish that political pressure caused the ruling. The strategic argument also cuts both ways: closure may offer short-term relief, yet weak reasoning and an absent statutory foundation could cause greater long-term damage. The sociological effect is hard to predict; the normative effect is contestable.
Implications extend to other situations. The debate now asks which organs may consider strategic considerations, within what limits, and how States Parties, defence teams, victims and civil society can hold them accountable.
Takeaway: No proven political motive, but ample political timing.
via icc-cpi.int (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- ICC Judges Close Afghanistan Situation, Prosecutor Appeals
- ICC Chamber Splits Afghanistan Probe, Sparks Prosecutor Appeal
- ICC Presidency Constitutes Trial Chamber III for Duterte Case
- ICC Concludes Confirmation of Charges Hearing in Duterte Case
- ICC Confirms War Crimes Charges Against Joseph Kony, Still At Large