Law report No. GLW-7707 · filed November 20, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Ninth Circuit hears challenge to immigration knock-and-talk arrests
A three-judge Ninth Circuit panel took under submission the challenge to ICE’s Los Angeles knock-and-talk policy after a 2025 ruling required a judicial warrant for arrests at homes.
By Amara Osei5 min read975 words
Holding
- A three-judge Ninth Circuit panel heard arguments on Thursday and took the appeal under submission.
- A 2025 lower-court ruling vacated ICE’s Los Angeles knock-and-talk policy and required a judicial warrant for arrests at homes.
- The government traced its asserted immigration-arrest authority to 1797.
- Judges Milan Smith Jr., Danielle Forrest and Johnnie Rawlinson formed the three-judge panel.

By Amara Osei
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit took under submission on Thursday the government’s challenge to a 2025 ruling that vacated the Los Angeles Immigration and Customs Enforcement field office’s “knock-and-talk” arrest policy. The court has not yet decided the appeal.
The argument, reported from Pasadena, California, asks whether an immigration officer carrying an administrative warrant may enter a person’s property when the officer already intends to arrest the resident after the person answers the door. A lower court ruled in 2025 that this sequence requires a judicial warrant. The government wants that result reversed.
The distinction is neat. Intent is not.
What did the 2025 ruling require?
After a lawsuit by immigrant groups, the lower court held that the government had no license to arrest during a knock-and-talk operation: an officer knocks, the resident identifies himself, and the officer arrests him. The court required a judicial warrant and vacated the policy used by the Los Angeles field office.
That ruling supplied the rule the appeal contests. The government relies on administrative warrants; the immigrant groups argue that forced entry to make an arrest offends the Fourth Amendment. The panel heard arguments Thursday and took the case under submission.
Takeaway: The lower court said an arrest at the door requires a judicial warrant.
What did the Ninth Circuit ask?
The judges focused on the moment an officer steps onto the property and on the officer’s purpose once the resident opens the door. U.S. Circuit Judge Milan Smith Jr., appointed by President George W. Bush, said the law was clear: officers cannot use knock-and-talk when their express purpose is arrest. Judge Smith put it plainly: “They can go with a warrant, but they can’t use knock-and-talk.”
U.S. Circuit Judge Danielle Forrest, appointed by President Donald Trump, said an officer could approach a home only for the same reason any member of the public could approach it. Otherwise, she said, the officer has no license to enter.
Forrest also asked whether an approach aimed only at gathering information falls within an implied license that avoids a Fourth Amendment violation. She examined a record containing declarations from noncitizens represented by the immigrant groups. The declarations described officers arriving at homes and arresting residents.
If the government’s evidence showed arrest intent, Forrest said, the information-gathering distinction did not resolve the case.
Takeaway: Arrest intent appeared to be the panel’s central dividing line.
What was the government’s case?
Deputy Assistant Attorney General Drew Ensign argued that the asserted authority has existed since 1797 and that special rules apply in certain circumstances, including immigration. Administrative warrants, he said, are issued by a non-neutral party and can result in arrest. “Administrative warrants are constitutionally permissible,” Ensign said.
The government also relies on consent: officers may solicit consent to enter property to enforce immigration law without violating the Fourth Amendment. The argument therefore joins two questions, whether an administrative warrant can support an arrest at a home and whether consent cures an improper entry.
Takeaway: The government says administrative warrants and consent can support the practice.
What did the immigrant groups argue?
Attorney Jeremy Kreisberg said forced entry into a home was a central Fourth Amendment concern. The government must obtain a judicial warrant to enter a home and arrest someone, he argued. Referring to the vacatur, Kreisberg said the government was trying to restore its policy without sound reasoning.
Kreisberg also addressed standing, the plaintiffs’ legal ability to sue. He said the government possessed the addresses of people the immigrant groups had assisted. “They know we’re here without authorization. They know where we live,” Kreisberg said, adding that authorities would target them.
A resident’s decision not to answer the door, Kreisberg said, cannot cure the violation when an officer enters the property intending to arrest. The constitutional problem occurs at the entry, not only if the resident chooses to respond.
Ensign disputed standing. The immigrant groups needed to identify people facing harm and had no standing, he argued. The claim concerned past injury, not a threat of future, imminent harm, and was particularly unlikely to recur.
Takeaway: The challengers linked the warrant issue to evidence of future targeting.
How did the panel test standing?
Forrest asked the advocates to define future injury, including whether plaintiffs had to identify specific people. Kreisberg said they had done so and stressed that the government already possessed the addresses. He asked why those addresses were not enough.
Forrest then described the government’s position as a suggestion that the people could simply refuse to answer the door. Kreisberg rejected that framing.
Forrest framed the government’s position as a declaration that it wanted to use the practice and regarded it as official policy. Her formulation captured the dispute over intent: officials need not announce an arrest plan at the doorstep if their policy and the surrounding facts establish the purpose of the visit.
U.S. Circuit Judge Johnnie Rawlinson, appointed by President Bill Clinton, completed the panel. No decision followed Thursday’s argument.
Takeaway: Standing may matter as much as the warrant question.
What should practitioners watch?
For immigration counsel, the arguments identify the factual distinctions at issue: whether the officer entered with an arrest purpose already formed, whether an administrative or judicial warrant existed, and whether the resident consented to entry.
Declarations and address evidence also matter because the panel asked whether the immigrant groups can show a concrete and imminent risk rather than only past encounters. Oral questions do not decide the appeal. Practitioners should await the opinion before treating Thursday’s exchanges as a new appellate rule.
Takeaway: The forthcoming opinion, not the oral argument, will supply the appellate rule.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
351 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court Takes Up Mandatory Detention in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha
- Supreme Court Lifts Big Bend Wall Injunction, Citing No 'Major Questions' Claim
- Supreme Court to Review Trump's Border 'Invasion' Proclamation
- Supreme Court to Review Trump's Asylum Suspension at Border
- Supreme Court to Review Trump Asylum Suspension at Border