Law report No. GLW-8793 · filed November 18, 2026
Human RightsReported case
ICE Seeks to Send Maryland Student to Mexico Despite 2021 CAT Protection
ICE intends to send a detained Maryland student and her mother to Mexico despite a 2021 immigration judge order granting them protection from removal to El Salvador, attorneys say.
By Sophie Lindqvist3 min read654 words
Holding
- ICE arrested Maria Jose Flores Garcia, 19, and her mother on Nov. 5 in Baltimore.
- A Baltimore immigration judge granted both women Convention Against Torture protection in 2021.
- DHS says Flores Garcia received due process on Feb. 23, 2021, with a final removal order.
- ICE intends to send both women to Mexico, where neither has legal status.
- Attorneys say the government began third-country removals of protected individuals in 2025.

By Sophie Lindqvist
Immigration and Customs Enforcement intends to transfer a 19-year-old University of Maryland student and her mother to Mexico, a country where neither woman has legal status, according to their attorneys at Murray Osorio, PLLC. The move tests a protection the family won in 2021.
Who decided what, and when?
An immigration judge in Baltimore granted Maria Jose Flores Garcia and her mother, Mirna Aracely Garcia Cabrera, protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) in 2021 after they sought relief from deportation to El Salvador. The judge's decision barred the government from sending them to El Salvador. The Department of Homeland Security did not appeal and has never moved to terminate that protection, the attorneys said.
Immigration officers arrested both women on Nov. 5 during a routine check-in in Baltimore. They are now held at an immigration detention center in Louisiana. ICE has told both women it intends to send them to Mexico.
Why DHS says the removal is lawful
DHS previously told WUSA9 that Flores Garcia illegally entered the United States and received due process on Feb. 23, 2021. The agency said an immigration judge issued a final order of removal and that she would remain in ICE custody pending removal from the country.
The family's attorneys say the order DHS cited is the same decision that granted CAT protection. Under immigration law, a judge can issue a removal order while also granting protection that blocks the government from carrying it out to a particular country. So the paperwork supports both sides' descriptions. The fight is over what the protection covers.
What does CAT protection actually cover?
The protection is narrower than asylum. It does not provide a path to permanent residency. But it allowed both women to work legally in the United States and build a life in Maryland, according to their legal team.
Here's the mechanism in plain terms. CAT protection works like a one-way lock: it stops the government from turning the key to a named country, El Salvador. DHS argues the lock says nothing about Mexico. The 2021 order, on the attorneys' reading, granted relief from deportation to El Salvador specifically.
The gap matters because the protection names one destination rather than all destinations, and that gap is where the dispute now lives.
Why third-country removals matter here
The legal team says the federal government began using third-country removals in 2025 to send people who hold certain protections to countries where they have no established ties. This case fits that pattern, the attorneys argue. Neither woman has legal status in Mexico.
For practitioners, the case is a warning about the limits of CAT relief. A grant that stops removal to one country may not stop removal everywhere. Clients with CAT-only protection now face a live risk of redirection to a third country, and counsel should treat country-specific bars as incomplete shields until courts clarify the scope.
The case also shows how quickly status can shift. A routine check-in on Nov. 5 turned into detention and a planned transfer. Work authorization and years of stability in Maryland did not prevent custody.
What happens next?
The attorneys are challenging the government's explanation for the continued detention. They raise concerns about where the women could be sent. DHS has not commented beyond its statement that Flores Garcia received due process and remains in custody pending removal.
The core question is unresolved: does a judge's order barring deportation to El Salvador permit removal to Mexico instead? The answer will shape how much protection CAT grants actually deliver.
Under the department's approach, the 2021 order stands, the protection stands, and the destination changes. Under the attorneys' approach, sending the women to a country with no ties defeats the relief the judge granted. That tension between formal compliance and practical effect is what this case now turns on.
via amren.com (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
343 articles