Law report No. GLW-1888 · filed November 17, 2026
Human RightsReported case
UN Human Rights Council Defers US Review to January After Trump Snub
The UN Human Rights Council postponed its review of the US rights record to January after Washington refused to attend, calling the body "irredeemable" and crediting it with none.
By Amara Osei3 min read648 words
Holding
- The UN Human Rights Council postponed the US human rights review until January after the Trump administration refused to participate.
- The United States was set to become the first UN member state ever to fully reject a universal periodic review.
- The council, with 47 members, reviews all 193 UN member states roughly every four to five years.
- A State Department spokesperson said the US gives "no credibility" to the council and called it an "irredeemable body".
- The ACLU has asked the UN human rights chief to present an update on US rights early next year.

The UN Human Rights Council in Geneva has agreed by consensus to postpone its review of the United States' human rights record until January, after the Trump administration refused for a second time to take part. The decision, adopted without a vote, buys the 47-member body time to coax Washington back into a process that every one of the UN's 193 member states is expected to undergo roughly every four to five years.
Without the delay, the United States was set on Tuesday to become the first UN member country ever to reject a universal periodic review outright. That distinction now waits. The precedent does not.
What exactly did the council decide?
The council adopted, without a vote, a decision citing "continued non-cooperation" with its universal periodic review process. The mechanism requires the participation of the country under review; if no national representatives attend, the review cannot proceed. Delegations — sometimes a dozen officials or more — normally present their government's record, face questions and hear recommendations from other national envoys. The process is designed as a sweeping, constructive exercise, akin to holding up a mirror to governments.
The United States skipped its original appointment a year ago. The council rescheduled that review for November 2025, then pushed it to Tuesday, hoping Washington might reconsider. It did not.
What did Washington say?
A State Department spokesperson left little room for interpretation. "(W)e give no credibility to the agency," the spokesperson wrote in an email to The Associated Press.
The spokesperson went further: "This irredeemable body makes a mockery of human rights through consistent failures to uphold its own 'values' as it pushes anti-American rhetoric," while alleging the council's "persistent failure to condemn the most egregious human rights violators."
The Trump administration withdrew the United States from the Human Rights Council last year, accusing it of anti-US and anti-Israel bias and of failing to uphold the values it promotes. The council's supporters defend its mandate to scrutinise the rights records of all UN member states — including the United States, which has drawn criticism over policies such as strong-arm deportations and targeted killings of alleged drug-runners in the Caribbean and Pacific. The administration says those measures protect US workers and keep the country safe.
Who is alarmed, and why?
Critics warn the American walkout invites imitation. Many countries already bristle at intense scrutiny from human rights monitors and could follow suit.
Jamil Dakwar, director of the American Civil Liberties Union's human rights program, was blunt. "The administration is saying to the world, 'we don't care about whether you would review us or not, we're going to continue to violate human rights unabashed'," he said. "And we are saying: 'No, enough is enough. This council should hold the United States accountable.'" He spoke to reporters Monday in Geneva, part of a civil society push to raise awareness of the US rights record.
Dakwar said the ACLU and its allies have asked the UN human rights chief to respond by presenting an update on rights in the United States early next year — a workaround that would put the record before the council regardless of Washington's attendance.
Eric Tistounet, a visiting professor at the Geneva Graduate Institute who served as the council's first secretary, warned of systemic damage. "If the predominant global power — which has always claimed to adhere to the human rights norms — doesn't show up and doesn't even justify why, then you are in big trouble," he said.
What happens next?
The council now has until January. Its options are limited: persuade, wait, or preside over the first full rejection in the review system's history. The credibility question Tistounet raises applies to more than one government. A review system that the strongest state ignores is a system others may quietly decline to fear.
via apnews.com (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- US Skips UN Human Rights Review for Second Time
- U.S. Skips U.N. Human Rights Review for Second Year, a First Among 193 Members
- UN Members Press Tajikistan on Rights Abuses at Geneva Peer Review
- UN Experts Welcome General Assembly Resolution Backing ICJ Climate Opinion
- ICJ Finds UN Rights Council Made 'Significant but Limited' Progress