Law report No. GLW-2960 · filed November 17, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Ecuadorian Fishermen Sue US Over Caribbean Drone Strike and Detention
Eighteen Ecuadorian fishermen sued the U.S. government in Pennsylvania federal court over drone strikes that sank their boat and led to days of detention in El Salvador.
By Marcus Bennett3 min read660 words
Holding
- 18 Ecuadorian fishermen sued the U.S. government on Monday in Pennsylvania federal court.
- Two armed U.S. drones struck the La Negra Francesca Duarte II on March 17 during Operation Southern Spear.
- The Ecuadorian Navy had inspected and cleared the vessel one day before the strike.
- Two crewmen were burned, one down to the bone; 17 men were zip-tied and hooded.
- The crew seeks damages and an injunction against similar boat attacks in the Caribbean and Pacific.

Eighteen Ecuadorian fishermen sued the U.S. government on Monday in Pennsylvania federal court, alleging American drone strikes sank their boat, burned two crewmen, and led to days of imprisonment in El Salvador.
The crew of the La Negra Francesca Duarte II filed the complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The suit names assault, battery, false imprisonment, conversion, and intentional infliction of emotional distress as claims. It seeks pecuniary damages to be determined at trial plus injunctive relief ordering the United States to cease similar boat attacks in the Caribbean and Pacific.
What happened on March 17?
According to the complaint, the 18-man crew was returning to port on March 17, ending a weekslong fishing trip, when two armed U.S. drones exploded on the ship. The attacks formed part of the Trump administration's Operation Southern Spear, a campaign of drone strikes in the Caribbean and Pacific conducted with the stated aim of countering "narco-terrorists."
The crew says none of the men aboard had engaged in any illicit activity. One day before the strikes, the Ecuadorian Navy had inspected the ship and crew for three hours and cleared them of any misconduct, according to the complaint.
"Basically, you have these innocent people who are out fishing — these poor fishermen — who were attacked by the U.S. without cause, without warrant, without trial," attorney Daniel Kovalik, representing the fishermen, told Courthouse News.
Two shipmates, Jordy Alexander Flores Lucas and Leonel Alberto Pilay Barahona, caught fire in the blast. The complaint says the explosion torched their legs, arms, and backs, and that Lucas' leg burned down to the bone.
How did the detention unfold?
With their boat sinking, the crew abandoned ship in emergency boats and paddled toward a blue vessel on the horizon. Sailors in military camouflage and U.S. Coast Guard life vests greeted them — several aiming long rifles at the shipwrecked men, the complaint states.
Lucas received medical attention below deck. Sailors zip-tied the hands of the remaining 17 crew members and placed plastic hoods over their heads, according to the filing. The next day, the crew says, U.S. sailors transferred the men to a Salvadoran ship, where they were forcibly held in "deplorable conditions" for days.
The complaint states the operative legal point plainly: "The United States' agents, officers, and personnel authorized and directed the strike even though plaintiffs were not directly participating in hostilities against the United States at the time of the strike, nor were they members of an organized armed group engaged in an armed conflict with the United States, nor was the boat they were aboard a lawful military target."
What does the case turn on?
The U.S. government has offered no evidence that the crew had any involvement in the illicit drug trade. Even if such evidence existed, Kovalik argued, drone strikes amounting to extrajudicial killings would still violate the law.
"There's no difference between what the U.S. is doing in these boat strikes, and if a cop went up to a guy in the middle of the street and said, 'Hey, you're a drug dealer,' and then blew his brains out," Kovalik said.
"We're a country that claims to respect due process — you're innocent until proven guilty," he added. "This completely destroys all that, and I think people should be utterly outraged."
Kovalik went further, calling the campaign terrorism. He said innocent fishermen now fear using the waters because of the strikes. "This just isn't how a civilized nation should be acting," he said.
For practitioners, the case tests whether foreign civilians caught in U.S. counter-narcotics drone operations can recover damages in domestic courts for strike-related injuries and subsequent detention. The outcome may shape the legal exposure of similar operations under Operation Southern Spear.
The U.S. Department of Defense declined to comment, citing a policy against discussing ongoing litigation.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
319 articles
Also before the court
- Ecuadorian Courts Dismantle US High-Seas Drug Case, Freeing 110 Crew
- Helsinki Court Jails Russian Captain for Baltic Cable Sabotage
- Eight Impeachment Articles Filed Against Hegseth Over Boat Strikes and Speech
- Judge Denies Pseudonyms in Tren de Aragua Habeas Case
- U.S. Forces Disable Cargo Ship Defying Iran Naval Blockade