Law report No. GLW-5845 · filed November 16, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

Ecuadorian Courts Dismantle US High-Seas Drug Case, Freeing 110 Crew

Ecuadorian judges acquitted 40 fishermen after US forces sank eight vessels and detained 160 crew; 70 percent of detainees are now free and uncharged.

By Amara Osei3 min read605 words

Holding

  1. US forces intercepted and destroyed 8 Ecuadorian fishing vessels between August 28 and September 16.
  2. Courts acquitted 40 crew members: 32 on October 7 and 8 more on October 29.
  3. 110 of 160 detainees — 70 percent — are now free and without charges.
  4. A Manta judge called the prosecution a 'chain of successive presumptions.'
  5. Neither Ecuador nor the US has disclosed the operations' legal basis.
Ecuadorian Courts Expose Flaws in US High-Seas Arrests
PlateEcuadorian Courts Expose Flaws in US High-Seas Arrests — Royce Fonseca / unsplash

Ecuadorian judges have now acquitted 40 fishermen and freed 110 of 160 crew members detained by the US military during high-seas interdictions, exposing what courts describe as prosecutions built on assumption rather than evidence.

Between August 28 and September 16, US forces intercepted and destroyed eight Ecuadorian fishing vessels, alleging they operated as floating refueling stations for drug-trafficking boats. The Americans detained 140 of the 160 crew members and transferred them to Ecuadorian authorities, who charged 90 with "unlawful association." That figure now looks unsustainable. The scoreboard reads differently in court.

On October 29, a judge in Manta acquitted eight fishermen from the vessel Don Rufo. Human Rights Watch, which reviewed the judgment, reported that the prosecution's own witnesses — including Ecuadorian police and Navy officials — testified that no illicit items were recovered and that they knew of no prior investigation linking the fishermen to organized crime. The evidence, in short, was absent. The judge said the prosecution rested on a "chain of successive presumptions," admonished the prosecutor for pursuing an unsupported case, and closed it.

What did the earlier ruling decide?

The Manta judgment follows an October 7 decision acquitting another 32 crew members from the vessels Conquista II and María Candelaria. That judge found no evidence supporting the unlawful association charge and admonished prosecutors for pursuing the case without even minimal evidence.

Two courts. Two admonitions. Zero recovered contraband on the record.

How many detainees remain held?

The arithmetic is stark. Of the 160 crew members detained by the US military:

  • 14 were never brought before Ecuadorian authorities at all;
  • 56 were released without charge by a judge;
  • 40 have been acquitted;
  • 50 remain awaiting trial.

That leaves 110 people — 70 percent of everyone seized — free and without charges. Roughly seven in ten detainees, in other words, should not have been charged or transferred in the first place, at least on the evidence Ecuadorian courts have seen.

What legal basis governed the operations?

Neither Ecuador nor the United States has publicly disclosed it. The two governments have not revealed the criteria used to intercept the vessels, the basis for destroying them, or the evidence linking the boats to drug trafficking. Family members waited for news at the harbor captaincy in Manta on September 3, after the US military intercepted and sank one vessel — a scene of anxious relatives standing in for a transparency regime that does not exist.

The legal void is the story. Vessels destroyed, 160 people seized, 90 charged, and no published legal framework for any of it.

What are the consequences for oversight and practitioners?

Human Rights Watch has called on the US Congress to ensure oversight over these and other US security operations in and near Ecuador. The organization reports that people have been detained without evidence and, in some cases, tortured by Ecuadorian personnel. For defense counsel, the acquittals supply a template: demand the evidentiary record from the moment of interdiction, test the chain of custody from US transfer to Ecuadorian charge, and press for the undisclosed legal basis of the operation itself.

For prosecutors, the admonitions from two benches within three weeks signal that unlawful association charges resting on association-by-geography will not survive judicial scrutiny. For policymakers, the cases pose a harder question. Organized crime in Ecuador is a serious threat, as Human Rights Watch notes, and it should be addressed with an effective, rights-respecting security and justice policy — not with human rights violations.

The bottom line: courts in Manta have done in weeks what the intercepting governments declined to do in months — tested the evidence. Most of it did not exist.

via hrw.org (Source)

Filed under

  • ecuador
  • unlawful-association
  • high-seas-interdictions
  • drug-trafficking
  • human-rights-watch
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

327 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »