Law report No. GLW-4962 · filed November 12, 2026
LegislationReported case
Belgium Approves Home Raid Law for Migrant Removals, Critics Cry 'Law of Fear'
Belgian MPs approved a law letting police enter homes without consent to remove undocumented people, taking effect next spring, as 20 rights groups warn of ICE-style raids and no appeal mechanism.
By Amara Osei4 min read881 words
Holding
- Belgium's parliament approved the home-raid immigration law on Friday, with entry into force set for next spring.
- Police may enter homes without consent between 5am and 9pm after a judge-issued warrant, detaining people and searching for identity documents.
- More than 60 protests were held across Belgium before the vote, and 20 rights groups oppose the law.
- Amnesty International says the law provides no appeal mechanism and limits judges' investigative powers.
- The EU's recently approved returns regulation contains similar provisions, and comparable measures exist in the Netherlands and Germany.
Belgium's parliament approved a law last Friday permitting police to enter private homes without consent to remove undocumented people, prompting more than 60 protests nationwide and condemnation from 20 rights organisations. The law takes effect next spring.
The federal legislature, where the ruling right-leaning coalition commands the majority, passed the measure after months of intense debate over plans to ramp up expulsions of people denied the right to stay in the country. The law empowers the Belgian immigration office to ask an investigating judge to authorise entry into residences that may house anyone without papers, including homes where migrants are hosted by friends or family.
Once a warrant is obtained, police may enter between 5am and 9pm, potentially in the presence of children. Once inside, they can detain people and search for identity documents.
What does the new law actually permit?
The mechanics are straightforward. The immigration office applies to an investigating judge for a warrant. The judge authorises it or does not. Police then enter a private residence, detain those found without legal status and search for documents proving identity.
Officials say the measures target a defined group: people denied asylum in Belgium, those who have ignored orders to leave, and individuals deemed a threat to public order or national security. That third category is where the trouble starts.
Critics across the legal profession — NGOs, judges and lawyers' associations — point out that the law is vague on what constitutes a public threat. They cite existing cases where such terms were applied to people who carried out undeclared work, ran a red light or shoplifted. The consequence is practical rather than rhetorical: individual judges will decide, case by case, whether a private home becomes a site of immigration enforcement.
Amnesty International raises two further defects. Judges authorising entry will not hold full investigative powers and will face restrictions on whom they may ask for additional information. The legislation also fails to provide any means for people to appeal or challenge decisions once made. A warrant without appeal is a curious instrument in a constitutional state.
Why are campaigners calling it a 'law of fear'?
Carine Thibaut, director of Amnesty International's French-speaking Belgian section, did not mince words. "It's a law of fear," she said, citing the raids' potential impact on children and on people who have opened their homes to migrants. "It really disseminates fear."
She dismissed the government's framing of the measure as crime-fighting. "They always say it's for criminals," Thibaut said. "We always answer that they already have all the tools to address this problem, because they can do that through the normal justice system."
Amnesty is among 20 rights groups warning that the law conflates lack of legal status with delinquency. Their statement invoked first principles: "The home is inviolable. This constitutional principle should never depend on the administrative status of those who live there."
That sentence is the entire legal argument in compressed form. Belgium's constitution protects the home; the new law makes that protection conditional on paperwork.
Thibaut extended the logic to its endpoint. "It's the beginning of reducing the state of law and the respect for human rights," she said. "This time it is for people without papers; after that, it might be people who are using drugs. That's the way you slowly, slowly dismantle a society based on human rights, on respect for justice and on separation of powers."
Is Belgium following the US model?
The parallels with the United States are drawn by the critics, not the government. Arrests by Immigration and Customs Enforcement have soared under Donald Trump's administration, and campaigners see Belgium moving in the same direction.
Chiara Catelli, an advocacy officer at the Brussels-based Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, known as Picum, rejected the criminality framing outright. "This really has nothing to do with people who have committed crimes," she said. "It's really about wanting to return people, deporting people, which is an administrative procedure."
She added: "We've all seen the devastating consequences of home raids in the US, where they fuel fear and violence and tear families apart. It's deeply alarming that an EU member state is now moving in the same direction."
Could this spread across the EU?
Catelli noted that similar hardline measures already exist in countries such as the Netherlands and Germany. The EU's recently approved returns regulation, designed to ramp up deportations across the bloc, includes comparable provisions — meaning other member states could soon follow Belgium's path.
"We're really afraid that this is the beginning of something that will become more widespread," she said.
What should practitioners take from this?
For immigration and human rights lawyers in Belgium, the law creates a new enforcement frontier inside the home. Judges will field warrant applications without full investigative powers; residents and hosts will lack an appeal route under the legislation as drafted. The tension with Belgium's constitutional guarantee of the inviolable home appears headed for litigation the moment the first raid occurs next spring.
More than 60 protests preceded the vote. Twenty rights groups opposed it. The government passed it anyway. The courts will now have the final word — assuming anyone can get before them.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- UK Government to Examine Domestic Abuse in Hague Child Abduction Cases
- Home Office to Deploy Live Facial Recognition for Immigration Enforcement
- Sweden Enacts 'Good Behaviour' Deportation Law for Immigrants
- European Parliament Approves 'Strictest-Ever' EU Migration Return Law
- Supreme Court Takes Up Mandatory Detention in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha