Law report No. GLW-7521 · filed November 12, 2026
ArbitrationReported case
Argentina Tells Itlos UK Behaves Like 17th-Century Power in Falklands Oil Case
Argentina urges Itlos in Hamburg to halt UK drilling at Sea Lion, 130 miles north of the Falklands, as the UK denies the tribunal any jurisdiction over sovereignty.
By Priya Raman4 min read816 words
Holding
- Argentina asked Itlos in Hamburg to suspend UK drilling at Sea Lion, about 130 miles north of the Falklands, due to start March next year.
- The UK says Itlos lacks jurisdiction over sovereignty and that extraction would not begin until 2028, defeating any urgency claim.
- Argentina's team says drilling could double the islands' GDP; the UK says suspension would have 'disastrous consequences' for islanders and companies.
- A panel of 20 judges is hearing the case; the 1982 conflict lasted 74 days and killed 649 Argentine and 255 British personnel plus three islanders.

Argentina has asked the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (Itlos), sitting in Hamburg, to order the United Kingdom to suspend oil drilling in the North Basin of the Falkland Islands pending full arbitration — and its lead counsel opened the hearing by accusing Britain of acting like a colonial power from four centuries ago.
Marcelo Kohen, representing Argentina before the panel of 20 judges, told the tribunal on the second day of hearings that the UK should not be permitted to treat the waters around the islands as a Dominium maris Britannici, the historic doctrine under which the British crown claimed sovereignty over expansive stretches of ocean. His point was pointed. The doctrine belongs to another age.
“The fact that the parties dispute sovereignty does not turn the areas surrounding the Malvinas into some kind of Dominium maris Britannici,” Kohen said. “We are not in the 17th century … We are in an era where we should put an end to the last vestiges of colonialism.”
What does Argentina want the tribunal to do?
Argentina seeks an interim ruling that would halt drilling in the North Basin while arbitration over the oilfield proceeds. The Sea Lion field lies roughly 130 miles north of the Falkland Islands, a British overseas territory over which Argentina has maintained a longstanding sovereignty claim. The archipelago — some 700 islands in the south Atlantic, known in Argentina as the Malvinas — remains the object of that unresolved dispute.
Kohen argued that the contested status of the islands does not render the surrounding waters a “legal black hole” in which the UK may do as it wishes with natural resources. Hydrocarbon exploitation, he said, would place the islands among the “highest ranks of wealth just below the principality of Monaco” while depriving Argentina of its rights to those resources.
Argentina's team framed the request as urgent, citing what they called irreparable damage to the country's rights if drilling proceeds. That urgency claim has a date attached: drilling is due to start in March next year. The UK contests the premise entirely.
How has the UK responded?
Ellie Reeves, attorney general for England and Wales, told the tribunal's judges on Tuesday that Argentina was pursuing its sovereignty ambitions through the back door of an interim application. Suspension, she claimed, would kill the Sea Lion project, with “disastrous consequences” for the Falkland Islanders and the companies involved.
The UK also raised a threshold objection: Itlos, which adjudicates maritime matters, lacks jurisdiction to wade into questions of sovereignty. On urgency, the UK argued none exists. Oil extraction would not begin until 2028, by which time an Itlos arbitration panel would have reached a conclusion on the oilfield's future. The UK will offer further submissions on Wednesday.
Kohen, switching from French to English, accused the UK of ignoring the “elephant in the room” — or, in his phrase, the “whale in the bathtub”. The UN, he noted, regards the Falkland Islands as a non-self-governing territory and called in 1976 for both sides to refrain from unilateral decisions that would change the situation before the sovereignty dispute is settled.
What is really at stake?
Drilling at Sea Lion could double the GDP of the islands, according to Argentina's legal team — a figure that explains both the urgency of Buenos Aires' application and the vigour of London's resistance. The money is real. So is the legal fence between the two positions.
Mario Oyarzábal, a legal adviser to Argentina's ministry of foreign affairs, told the panel in closing remarks that Argentina rejected the UK's attempt to cast the proceedings as litigation of the sovereignty dispute itself. “The question before this tribunal is a much narrower one: whether, while the underlying dispute remains unresolved, the UK may unilaterally authorise or carry out new drilling for the exploitation of hydrocarbons in the disputed maritime area,” he said.
The political backdrop
Argentina's president, Javier Milei, shared a photograph of the legal team in Hamburg among his cabinet, describing it as “tremendous” and adding: “we are working on the Falklands issue like no one else in history.” He has called the reclaiming of the Falklands a “national cause”, most recently in a speech at the UN general assembly.
The history is grim and exact. Argentina invaded the islands in 1982 on the orders of the dictator Gen Leopoldo Galtieri. The 74-day conflict ended with Argentine surrender and cost 649 Argentine military lives, 255 British military lives and three Falkland Islanders.
For practitioners, the case turns on two questions, not one: whether Itlos accepts jurisdiction despite the sovereignty carve-out the UK invokes, and, if so, whether the tribunal finds the 2028 extraction timeline insufficient to defeat Argentina's urgency claim. Neither question is settled. The tribunal has said nothing on the merits.
In plain words: two states are fighting over oil, jurisdiction first.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
324 articles