Law report No. GLW-6965 · filed November 11, 2026
ArbitrationReported case
Ninth Circuit rejects SpaceX bid to arbitrate eight retaliation claims
The Ninth Circuit held that the EFAA requires only a complaint describing conduct asserted to support a sexual-harassment claim, letting eight fired SpaceX employees pursue retaliation claims in court.
By Amara Osei3 min read661 words
Holding
- Eight former SpaceX employees can pursue wrongful-retaliation claims in court after the Ninth Circuit rejected arbitration on Tuesday.
- A 2-1 Ninth Circuit panel upheld the previous year’s ruling by a Los Angeles trial judge applying the 2021 EFAA.
- The eight employees were fired in 2022 after an open letter about Elon Musk’s social-media posts.
- Their complaint was filed two years before the ruling in Los Angeles County Superior Court, then removed to federal court in Los Angeles.
- The EFAA requires only a complaint describing conduct asserted to support a sexual-harassment claim.

By Amara Osei
Eight former SpaceX employees won the right to pursue wrongful-retaliation claims in open court when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rejected the company’s arbitration bid on Tuesday in Pasadena, California.
The 2-1 ruling in Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX upheld the prior-year ruling of a Los Angeles trial judge, who had found the 2021 Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act applicable to the employees’ claims.
What did the Ninth Circuit decide?
The panel held that the statute, known as the EFAA, requires only that a complaint describe conduct asserted to be the basis for a sexual-harassment claim. It rejected SpaceX’s appellate argument that the statute demands enough detail to survive a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim.
Friedland, writing for the panel, said: “Congress could have easily drafted the EFAA to require courts to send sexual harassment disputes to arbitration only when the complaint ‘fails to state a claim upon which relief may be granted’ or ‘fails to state facts which, if true, would constitute sexual harassment.’”
Her reasoning was textual. Congress could have adopted either formulation, so its failure to do so strongly indicated that it did not intend to import the federal pleading standard into the EFAA, the Barack Obama appointee said.
Anne Shaver, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said: “We are delighted with the Ninth Circuit’s ruling.” She called the decision well reasoned and said it vindicated the eight clients’ right to proceed in open court on their sexual-harassment claims against Musk and SpaceX, while clarifying the EFAA pleading standard for all victims.
For arbitration disputes, alleging conduct said to support a harassment claim suffices; surviving dismissal comes later.
What brought eight employees into court?
SpaceX fired the eight employees in 2022 after they sent an open letter to management about Elon Musk’s lewd social-media posts. They said those posts normalized and encouraged sexual banter, sexual harassment and gender discrimination at the company, then headquartered in Hawthorne, California.
The plaintiffs allege Musk ordered their dismissal soon after the letter circulated. Their complaint, first filed about two years ago in Los Angeles County Superior Court and later removed to federal court in Los Angeles, stated:
“Musk knowingly and purposefully created an unwelcome hostile work environment based upon his conduct of interjecting into the workplace vile sexual photographs, memes, and commentary that demeaned women and/or the LGBTQ+ community.”
One post cited in the complaint proposed a Texas university similar to MIT, to be called “TITS,” where “Ds [women’s bra size] would get degrees.” It included an altered image of a rocket rendered to resemble a giant penis.
These allegations still require proof; the Ninth Circuit decided only the arbitration question.
Why did the panel divide?
U.S. Circuit Judge Danielle Forrest, a Donald Trump appointee, joined Friedland in rejecting SpaceX’s appeal. U.S. Circuit Judge Eric Tung, also a Trump appointee, dissented and said the panel should have reversed the trial judge.
Tung said the majority opened the door to disgruntled employees raising frivolous sexual-harassment disputes to escape arbitration agreements. He wrote: “Under the majority’s test, a plaintiff can escape an arbitration agreement if his complaint so much as purports to allege a sexual harassment dispute.”
His second sentence was less diplomatic: “In other words, the majority accepts a plaintiff’s bare legal assertion, no matter how mistaken.” SpaceX representatives did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The disagreement concerns pleading rigor, not the eight employees’ underlying allegations.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
For practitioners, the ruling supplies a modest pleading threshold for resisting arbitration under the EFAA: describe conduct asserted to support a sexual-harassment claim. For eight plaintiffs, that means litigation proceeds without arbitration of the retaliation claims. The decision resolves a procedural gateway, not liability.
Arbitration stops here; the underlying dispute continues in court.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court Resolves Workplace Arbitration Dispute
- Supreme Court: Federal Courts Keep Power Over Arbitration Awards
- Supreme Court Narrows Alien Tort Statute in Cisco Falun Gong Case
- Supreme Court Upholds Federal Power to Confirm Arbitration Awards
- Losing the Right to an Arbitration Stay: What Triggers Forfeiture?