Law report No. GLW-7318 · filed November 20, 2026

Regulation & EnforcementReported case

US Sells First Pacific Deep-Sea Mining Leases for $6M Despite Court Loss

The US sold its first Pacific deep-sea mining leases off American Samoa for $6m to a sole bidder, defying a Hawaii court ruling that voided the sale's environmental clearance under the Endangered Species Act.

By Marcus Bennett4 min read850 words

Holding

  1. On Thursday the US sold two deep-sea mining leases covering 12.7m hectares off American Samoa for $3m each to sole bidder Wetstone US Ventures.
  2. Judge Jill Otake ruled this week that NMFS violated the Endangered Species Act by failing to consider effects on listed species.
  3. A second sale of 27.9m hectares between the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively set for 16 December.
  4. Opponents gathered more than 76,000 public comments; Earthjustice vows to seek voiding of the leases.
  5. The leases run at least 20 years and cover preliminary exploration such as bathymetric and geophysical mapping.
‘The Pacific is not for sale’: outcry after US holds first deep sea mining lease sale near American Samoa
Plate‘The Pacific is not for sale’: outcry after US holds first deep sea mining lease sale near American Samoa — Franziska_Stier / pixabay

The United States sold its first-ever Pacific deep-sea mining leases on Thursday for a combined $6 million, three days after a federal judge in Hawaii voided the environmental clearance underpinning the sale. Two seabed tracts covering 12.7 million hectares (31.5 million acres) off American Samoa went for $3 million each to Wetstone US Ventures, the sole bidder, according to a spokesperson for the Marine Minerals Administration (MMA).

The live-streamed auction ran from California. It covered two areas of the Pacific archipelago marked for mineral exploration. The buyer gains permission for preliminary activities only: bathymetric and geophysical mapping, among other data collection.

The prize beneath the water is golf ball-sized metallic nodules. Miners tout them as a source of rare earths and minerals needed for electric vehicles, renewable energy and defence systems.

What did the government say?

Interior Secretary Doug Burgum framed the sale as a milestone. "This is the first time the United States has held an offshore critical minerals lease sale in the Pacific and a historic step for America's energy and mineral security," he said in a statement.

MMA director Mike Olsen opened the auction by saying the federal action aligns with the Trump administration's agenda "to advance the responsible development of America's offshore critical mineral resources."

"As we look to America's next 250 years, we want future generations to inherit a nation that can build and innovate here at home, on the lands and in the waters that we've stewarded," Olsen said.

What did the court decide?

The legal foundation of the sale was already cracked. Judge Jill Otake of the federal district court in Hawaii ruled this week that the National Marine Fisheries Service had violated the Endangered Species Act. "NMFS failed to even attempt to consider the potential effects on ESA-listed species," Otake wrote.

Earthjustice, which filed the petition, says the ruling rendered Thursday's auction unlawful. "We will use the full extent of the law to vigorously push for the leases to be voided," Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton said in a statement.

Opponents moved fast. On the eve of the auction, the American Samoan youth and environment nonprofit Finafinau asked the district court of Hawaii for an injunction to halt the sale. The bid failed. The lawsuit accused the Trump administration of barrelling toward the sale "without sufficient information to comprehensively evaluate the impacts of issuing the first-ever commercial deep-sea mining leases."

Finafinau's court filing pulls no punches. "Despite venturing into largely uncharted territory, MMA recklessly accelerated environmental review," it states. "With this lease sale, the federal government has rushed to open the ocean floor to commercial mining for the first time, despite its limited understanding of the significant environmental consequences."

How did Pacific leaders respond?

Local anger has been building for months. Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka, founder of Finafinau, catalogued the record before the gavel fell. "More than 76,000 public comments, repeated calls for meaningful consultation, and now a federal court ruling that the government violated the Endangered Species Act," she said. "Yet here we are, watching our ocean being auctioned to the highest bidder."

Guam Senator William Parkinson demanded cancellation. "You don't get to sell off our ocean first and ask whether it's legal later," he said. "Washington needs to understand that the Pacific is not for sale."

Parkinson said the federal court decision "exposes the arrogance and recklessness of an administration that treats our ocean as a corporate commodity and Pacific Islanders as expendable."

Who supports the sale?

Not everyone in the territory objects. American Samoa Governor Pulaali'i Nikolao Pula has previously said the deep-sea mining auctions could "unlock scientific knowledge" and "create economic opportunities" for the territory.

John Wasko, executive director of the American Samoa Development Council, a nonprofit that endorses deep-sea mining in American Samoa, called the emerging industry the answer to climate change. "Everybody wants unlimited renewable energy," he said. "Nobody wants to admit their part in planet Earth's atmospheric destruction."

What happens next?

Practitioners should watch two tracks. First, the litigation: Earthjustice and Finafinau are pursuing nullification of the leases, and the Hawaii court's Endangered Species Act ruling gives them a live legal theory that the sale proceeded without lawful environmental clearance. Second, the expansion: a second lease sale covering 27.9 million hectares (69 million acres) of seabed between the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively scheduled for 16 December, and it is locked in a similar pending lawsuit in the federal court of Hawaii.

Taryn Kiekow Heimer, director of Ocean Energy at the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), warned that the American Samoa sale will now become the template for subsequent applications from mining companies. "These leases last at least 20 years. The Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam are next in line," Heimer said. "If this goes through, the administration will have shown it can open the deep sea over the objections of the people who live closest to it."

For now, the leases stand. The legal battle continues.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Filed under

  • deep-sea-mining
  • american-samoa
  • critical-minerals
  • endangered-species-act
  • environmental-litigation
Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

338 articles

Also before the court

« Previous article