Law report No. GLW-2603 · filed November 6, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
UN Elects Five ICJ Judges, Two With Records in Israel-Linked Proceedings
The UN elected five ICJ judges to terms running through 2036, and Israel's envoy says two have records in proceedings against it as the genocide case continues.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read826 words
Holding
- The UN General Assembly and Security Council elected five ICJ judges on Wednesday to nine-year terms running February 6, 2027, to February 2036.
- Jordan's Mahmoud Hmoud accused Israel of war crimes, 'ethnic cleansing' and 'genocide' in statements starting October 2023.
- Judges Okowa and Akande participated in the advisory opinion proceedings that ended with the ICJ's July 2024 ruling on Israel's presence in the Palestinian territories.
- South Africa has until November 2027 to reply in its genocide case against Israel; Israel may respond by May 2029.
- Article 17 of the ICJ statute restricts judges from cases in which they were previously involved in specified legal capacities.

The UN General Assembly and Security Council elected five judges on Wednesday to nine-year terms at the International Court of Justice, and Israel's ambassador immediately questioned their impartiality. Danny Danon said the résumés of the new judges in The Hague are "troubling and raise questions." The terms begin February 6, 2027, and run to February 2036.
The elected judges are Mahmoud Daifallah Hmoud of Jordan, Dapo Akande of the United Kingdom, François Alabrune of France, Phoebe Okowa of Kenya, and Rena Lee of Singapore. Each candidate needed a majority in both the General Assembly and the Security Council, cast in separate votes.
Two of them already sit on the court. Hmoud has served since May 2025 and Okowa since November 2025, both elected to fill vacant seats; they have now won full terms. The other three join the bench for the first time.
Why does Israel object to the new bench?
The Jordanian judge draws the sharpest criticism. Before joining the court, Hmoud served as Jordan's ambassador to the UN, as legal adviser to the Jordanian Foreign Ministry, and on the UN International Law Commission, which he chaired in 2021. He presented Jordan's positions in the 2004 proceedings on Israel's security barrier and the 2024 proceedings on the legal status of Israel's presence in the West Bank and east Jerusalem.
On October 30, 2023, weeks after the Hamas attacks, Hmoud told the Security Council that its silence allowed Israel to act without accountability, accusing it of harming civilians in Gaza and violating international law. As the war progressed, he described Israel's actions as "ethnic cleansing" and "genocide."
Okowa, a professor of international law at Queen Mary University of London, served on the UN International Law Commission and represented Namibia in February 2024 before the ICJ, in advisory opinion proceedings on the legal consequences of Israel's policies in the Palestinian territories. The court ruled in July 2024 that Israel's continued presence in the Palestinian territories was unlawful.
Akande, an Oxford professor of international law and a member of the International Law Commission, served as legal counsel to Japan in the same advisory opinion proceedings.
"Will a judge who incorrectly determined, one month after the October 7 massacre, that Israel was committing genocide be able to impartially handle the case against it?" Danon asked. "Will a judge who advised in legal proceedings against us act professionally and without bias in the pursuit of justice?" He called the election "another example of the UN's structural bias against the State of Israel."
After the vote, Danon wrote: "Five judges were elected at the UN to the International Court of 'Justice,' which is expected to continue hearing the false case against Israel." He added that electing judges who have taken positions against Israel "casts a heavy shadow over the court's ability to hear our case impartially."
What are the recusal rules?
The ICJ's statute offers a partial answer to the impartiality question. Article 17 restricts judges from participating in cases in which they were previously involved as lawyers, legal advisers, or in other capacities specified in the statute. Judges are also required to act independently rather than as representatives of their countries.
The distinction matters here. Okowa and Akande participated in advisory opinion proceedings on the Palestinian territories, which are separate from South Africa's genocide case against Israel. Their election therefore does not establish that they are barred from the genocide case or determine in advance how they would rule.
How does this affect the genocide case?
South Africa filed its case in December 2023, alleging that Israel's military operations in Gaza violated the Genocide Convention. Israel rejects the allegations and maintains it acted in self-defense. Throughout 2024, the ICJ issued several provisional measures but has not ruled on the genocide allegation.
The timetable stretches well into the new judges' terms. Under a decision issued in May 2026, South Africa has until November 2027 to reply to Israel's arguments, and Israel may respond further by May 2029. The judges elected this week could sit on the panel for the final ruling.
Who are the other two judges?
Alabrune, currently France's ambassador to the Netherlands, was legal adviser to the French Foreign Ministry and represented France in cases involving the Genocide Convention, including proceedings concerning Russia and Ukraine, and Myanmar. Lee, Singapore's ambassador for international law, has a background in maritime law, arbitration, and multilateral negotiations; from 2018 to 2023 she chaired the conference that adopted the UN agreement on protecting biodiversity on the high seas. She is the first Singaporean elected to the ICJ.
The court consists of 15 judges serving nine-year terms, with jurisdiction over disputes between states and the authority to issue advisory opinions to UN bodies. The central question now is whether the judges' prior roles will shape their rulings, or whether their obligation to judge independently will hold.
via GN International Courts (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
319 articles
Also before the court
- ICJ Election Reshapes Bench as ICC Splits Afghanistan Probe
- Britain Returns to World Court as Dapo Akande Wins ICJ Seat
- Israeli Parliament Approves Law Boosting Political Role in Judicial Selection
- Saudi Envoy Calls ICJ Ruling a Historic Precedent
- Knesset Passes Law Tightening Political Grip on Judicial Appointments