Law report No. GLW-1391 · filed November 19, 2026
ArbitrationReported case
Supreme Court: Section 37 Courts Cannot Reassess Arbitral Facts
The Supreme Court on 18 November 2026 held that arbitral tribunals are the final arbiters of facts, barring Section 37 courts from independently reassessing a case's merits.
By Priya Raman2 min read435 words
Holding
- Judgment reported as 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1170, decided 18 November 2026.
- Court: Supreme Court of India, in Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited.
- Holding: the arbitral tribunal is the final arbiter of facts; a Section 37 court cannot make an independent assessment of the merits.
- The ruling construes appeals under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

The Supreme Court of India, in a judgment reported as 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1170 and delivered on 18 November 2026, has held that the arbitral tribunal is the final arbiter of facts, and that a court hearing an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 cannot make an independent assessment of the merits. The ruling came in Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited, a dispute between the Rajasthan state power generation utility and a coal mining company.
What did the Court decide?
The operative proposition is short. The tribunal decides the facts; those findings stand unless a ground for interference is independently made out. A Section 37 appellate court does not sit as a second forum of fact-finding.
That position is now stated in this ruling with the tribunal described as the final arbiter of facts. Section 37 governs appeals against orders refusing to set aside, or remit, an arbitral award. The Court confirmed that such an appeal is not a vehicle for re-weighing evidence the tribunal already weighed.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
The practical consequence is severe for losing parties. A party that ran its case on the evidence before the tribunal, and lost on the facts, cannot repair that loss before the Section 37 court. The appellate court examines whether the legal grounds for interference exist. It does not reopen the factual record.
For the Rajasthan utility, that means the tribunal's findings in the dispute with Parsa Kente Collieries survive the challenge mounted at the appellate stage. For counsel generally, the decision sharpens an old lesson: the arbitral hearing is the whole evidentiary game. There is no second innings dressed as an appeal.
Three points follow for practice:
- Draft pleadings and lead evidence on the assumption that no civil court will re-examine the tribunal's factual findings on appeal under Section 37.
- Frame Section 37 arguments around error of law and the recognised statutory grounds, not dissatisfaction with the tribunal's view of the evidence.
- Treat the record closed once the tribunal rules; supplementary factual material has no obvious home at the appellate stage.
A caveat belongs here. The full text of the judgment sits behind LiveLaw's subscriber paywall, and this report rests on the published holding and case details. The Court's exact reasoning, any concurring observations, and the precise scope it gave to "independent assessment" await confirmation from the certified judgment. Practitioners should verify the operative paragraphs before citing the decision.
Takeaway: under Section 37, argue error of law, not displeasure with the facts.
via livelaw.in (Source)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
346 articles
Also before the court
- When Can a Court Rewrite an Arbitral Award? Not on Section 34
- Supreme Court: Arbitral Awards Enforceable Like Decrees Even During Challenge
- MP High Court Rebukes State Over Fabricated Case Name in AI Pleadings
- India's Supreme Court Reiterates: Arbitrators Cannot Rewrite Contracts
- Supreme Court: Contractual Bar Cannot Block Pre-Award Interest