Law report No. GLW-5909 · filed November 19, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
MP High Court Rebukes State Over Fabricated Case Name in AI Pleadings
On November 17, the Madhya Pradesh High Court found the State cited a nonexistent Supreme Court judgment and directed pre-filing verification of every legal proposition and citation.
By Amara Osei4 min read737 words
Holding
- November 17, 2026: The Madhya Pradesh High Court found the State’s cited Supreme Court judgment did not exist.
- The purported authority was State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, cited as [2008 5 SCC 230].
- The matched reference concerned suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal, not the named Supreme Court case.
- Justice Vivek Kumar Singh labeled the State’s AI-assisted drafting practice reckless and actively misleading the court.
- Drafting counsel must verify every legal proposition and citation before affidavits are sworn and filed.

By Amara Osei
On November 17, 2026, the Madhya Pradesh High Court in India found that the State respondents had cited a nonexistent Supreme Court judgment in a police officer’s dismissal writ, after using artificial intelligence tools to draft pleadings without verifying the authority. The bench then cautioned the respondents and the State machinery against reckless practices it said actively misled the court.
The bench of Justice Vivek Kumar Singh was considering a writ petition filed by a Madhya Pradesh police officer who challenged his dismissal from service without a departmental inquiry. The order is reported at [2026 LiveLaw (MP) 466].
What did the court decide?
Justice Singh said the State relied heavily on a purported Supreme Court judgment, State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, cited as [2008 5 SCC 230]. The court found that no judgment bearing that case name existed.
The authority did not survive the first citation check. According to the bench, the reference corresponded instead to a case concerning suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal; it did not correspond to the named Supreme Court judgment.
The fault was not confined to an unexplained error. The court said the respondents had used artificial intelligence tools to draft their pleadings, stating:
“It is glaringly apparent that the respondents have blindly resorted to the use of Artificial Intelligence tools to draft their pleadings, resulting in the incorporation of a fabricated case name crosswired with an unrelated citation.”
The court recalled that pleadings before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents. It said casually inserting fictitious case law without the basic professional duty of cross-checking citations wastes precious judicial time and borders on misleading the court.
The respondents and the State machinery were strictly cautioned against what the bench called reckless practices. AI-assisted drafting, in other words, did not excuse unverified advocacy before the bench.
In plain terms, the State relied on a Supreme Court authority the court said does not exist.
What made the cited authority defective?
The purported case paired a fabricated name with [2008 5 SCC 230], a reporter reference the court said belonged to a different criminal appeal concerning suspension of sentence. The mismatch between the named precedent and the cited authority exposed the pleading.
The order did not treat the problem as a dispute over the meaning of a real Supreme Court ruling. Rather, the State put before the High Court a case name the court could not locate, paired with an unrelated reporter citation.
Justice Singh tied that failure to the use of artificial intelligence in drafting. His criticism focused on the absence of verification after the pleading reached the court, not on a general judicial objection to legal technology.
The distinction matters. The court faulted the filing counsel and State machinery for presenting the material; the remedy it specified focused on the Advocate General’s office and its drafting counsel.
A real citation number does not rescue an invented case name.
What must happen before affidavits are filed?
The court stated its expectation in terms that leave little room for decorative checking:
“The office of the Advocate General is expected to ensure that all legal propositions and citations are meticulously verified by the drafting counsel before they are sworn on affidavit and placed on the record of this Court.”
For practitioners in this matter, the practical consequence is a pre-filing verification checkpoint: match each case name with its reporter reference, confirm that the authority supports the proposition, and complete those checks before an affidavit is sworn.
The order also assigns oversight to the Advocate General’s office. Drafting counsel must perform the checks, while the office must ensure that the checks occur before documents enter the High Court’s record. Artificial intelligence may produce words, but it cannot carry the professional responsibility.
The result is a filing standard with teeth: an AI-drafted case name cannot enter an affidavit unchecked, even when a government lawyer swears the document. The court also warned that such practices waste judicial time.
In plain terms, counsel must check every proposition and citation before an affidavit enters the record.
Who represented the parties?
Advocate Nityanand Mishra appeared for the petitioner, and Government Advocate Swati Aseem George appeared for the State. The decision was reported on November 19, 2026, at 1:26 p.m. IST.
Both sides had counsel of record, but the State’s filing drew the rebuke.
via livelaw.in (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
351 articles
Also before the court
- Telangana High Court quashes Cyberabad FIR against NRI husband
- Supreme Court: Section 37 Courts Cannot Reassess Arbitral Facts
- Forged High Court Orders Triggered Blocking of 129 Websites
- India's Supreme Court Strikes ₹425 Crore AI-Citation Penalty in September Roundup
- Civil Justice Council Sets Up Working Group on AI and 'Fake' Citations