Law report No. GLW-7010 · filed November 17, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

Supreme Court Revives Texas Border Wall, Citing 'Compelling Interests'

The Supreme Court on November 9 stayed an injunction blocking Texas border wall construction, saying the government is 'exceedingly likely to prevail' on jurisdiction. Justice Jackson dissented.

By Amara Osei4 min read796 words

Holding

  1. On November 9 the Supreme Court granted an emergency stay allowing border wall construction in Texas's Big Bend Sector to resume.
  2. The Court said the government is 'exceedingly likely to prevail' on its argument that the district court lacked jurisdiction.
  3. The injunction had cost the government nearly $500,000 per day, according to a CBP official.
  4. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson would have denied the request; she gave no written reason.
  5. The stay expires automatically if the Court declines review; it lasts until judgment if certiorari is granted.
Supreme Court gives Trump administration a win in Texas border wall case, allows construction to resume: ‘Compelling int
PlateSupreme Court gives Trump administration a win in Texas border wall case, allows construction to resume: ‘Compelling int — wal_172619 / pixabay

By Amara Osei

The Supreme Court on November 9 allowed the Trump administration to resume border wall construction in Texas, granting an emergency stay of a lower court injunction on the ground that the federal government has "compelling interests" in border security and integrity. The unsigned order in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church is an interim win. The underlying merits fight continues.

The stakes are measurable. A U.S. Customs and Border Protection official reported that the injunction was costing the government nearly $500,000 per day — roughly $182 million a year if sustained — costs the official said "cannot be recouped" even if the government ultimately prevails. According to a post widely circulated on the day of the ruling, the project is backed by $46 billion in funding, with crews building 12 miles of barriers per week.

What did the Court actually decide?

Three things, precisely. First, the justices stayed the October 2 preliminary injunction issued by a federal district court, which had blocked the waivers and halted construction in Texas's Big Bend Sector. Second, the Court said the administration was "exceedingly likely to prevail" on its argument that the district court lacked jurisdiction to consider the challengers' claim that Homeland Security officials exceeded their statutory authority. Third, the Court weighed the equities and found the government's interest in proceeding outweighed the environmental, recreational and aesthetic harms alleged by the challengers.

The order is not a final determination that every aspect of the disputed construction project complies with federal law. That sentence appears in the order itself. Practitioners should read it twice.

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented from the grant of the emergency application, indicating she would have denied the administration's request. She offered no written explanation. One sentence. No accompanying reasoning. The remaining justices did not publicly divide.

What is the legal foundation for the waivers?

The dispute turns on Section 102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996. That statute gives the Homeland Security secretary broad authority to construct barriers and roads intended to deter unlawful border crossings. It also permits the secretary to waive legal requirements deemed necessary to expedite construction.

Earlier this year, Homeland Security officials invoked that authority to advance the Big Bend project, waiving a variety of environmental and conservation laws. The challengers — a river guide, an environmental nonprofit, and an organization dedicated to preserving a historic Texas church — argued the secretary exceeded his legal authority. The district court agreed, at least preliminarily, on October 2.

The Supreme Court has now pushed back. Its jurisdictional signal is the operative holding: the government is "exceedingly likely to prevail" on the point that the district court never had authority to hear the claim in the first place. If that view holds, the environmental and conservation waivers may escape district court review entirely — at least through this litigation path.

What does the ruling change for practitioners?

For litigators on both sides, the order reshapes the tactical terrain. The government obtained emergency relief on the shadow docket, without full briefing on the merits, and secured both a stay and a strong jurisdictional signal in one document. Challengers to agency action under Section 102 now face a precedent-laden hurdle: a Supreme Court suggestion that such claims may not be justiciable in district court at all. Defendants invoking statutory waiver authority will cite this order early and often. Plaintiffs' counsel will need alternative forums, alternative theories, or both. Meanwhile, construction proceeds, the alleged harms accumulate, and any ultimate remedial victory may arrive after the bulldozers have finished.

The cost finding matters beyond this case. By crediting the CBP official's $500,000-per-day figure and noting the costs are unrecoverable, the Court treated irretrievable expenditure as a decisive equitable factor. Agencies defending time-sensitive infrastructure projects will take note. So will plaintiffs who must now anticipate that delay arguments cut in the government's favor.

Is the border construction fight over?

No. The stay's mechanics guarantee more litigation. The order allows construction to continue while the administration petitions the Supreme Court for review of the case. If the justices decline to hear it, the stay automatically expires. If they grant certiorari, the stay remains in place until the Court issues its judgment.

That structure gives the administration a strong incentive to seek review promptly, and gives the challengers a strong incentive to argue the case does not warrant it. Either way, the merits question — whether the Homeland Security secretary lawfully exercised his waiver power in the Big Bend Sector — remains undecided by any appellate court.

The verdict, briefly

An emergency stay, a jurisdictional warning, and a solitary dissent: the wall goes up while the law goes on. For now, that is the whole holding.

via wonderwall.com (Source)

Filed under

  • supreme-court
  • texas-border-wall
  • mullin-v-friends-of-the-ruidosa-church
  • emergency-stay
  • environmental-law
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

327 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »