Law report No. GLW-2226 · filed November 17, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

India's Supreme Court Strikes ₹425 Crore AI-Citation Penalty in September Roundup

India's Supreme Court quashed a ₹425-crore customs penalty resting on AI-hallucinated citations, tightened arrest safeguards and reshaped SARFAESI, contempt and juvenility law in a packed September.

By Amara Osei4 min read799 words

Holding

  1. The Court on September 1, 2026 set aside a ₹425.27-crore customs penalty resting on AI-generated fake case laws (2026 LiveLaw (SC) 884).
  2. Justices Datta and Nagu quashed Mulla Afroz's NSA detention on September 29 and imposed ₹10 lakh costs on Uttar Pradesh for relying solely on a custodial confession.
  3. Kotak Mahindra Bank ruling (September 2) lets banks invoke SARFAESI for loans acquired from NBFCs outside the Act.
  4. The Court dismissed 271 Union appeals against disability pensions for ex-servicemen on September 15, 2026.
  5. A murder convict was acquitted after 16 years and 7 months in custody for want of complete circumstantial evidence.
Supreme Court Monthly Roundup: September 2026
PlateSupreme Court Monthly Roundup: September 2026 — succo / pixabay

By Amara Osei, Legal Affairs Desk

The Supreme Court of India in September 2026 set aside a ₹425.27-crore customs penalty after finding that the adjudicating authority had relied on judicial precedents that appeared to have been hallucinated by artificial intelligence. A bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu allowed the appeal of diamond trader Vijay Ghanshyam Gadiya on September 1, quashing orders of the Gujarat High Court and the Additional Commissioner of Customs, Surat, who had penalised him under Section 114 of the Customs Act, 1962 for allegedly mis-declaring natural diamonds as lab-grown. The citations did not exist. The Court did not find this persuasive.

What did the criminal bench decide?

In Anil Singh v. State of Bihar (2026 LiveLaw (SC) 875), Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran cautioned that trial courts must proceed with alacrity where the prosecution fails to examine crucial witnesses, setting aside concurrent findings of the Patna High Court. "The Trial Court is not a moot spectator," the bench observed.

The same combination acquitted a former Indian Bank branch manager in a 1991 loan fraud case, holding that "the CBI has failed miserably in not only proving its case but also in framing the case," which the Court called fabricated. A man convicted of murdering a six-year-old in 2007 walked free after 16 years and seven months in custody (Sahab Singh v. State of Haryana, 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 887), the Court finding several links in the circumstantial chain missing.

On September 29, the Court quashed the preventive detention of Mulla Afroz, accused of masterminding the 2024 Sambhal violence, imposing ₹10 lakh costs on Uttar Pradesh. A custodial confession alone, the Court held, cannot sustain the subjective satisfaction required under the National Security Act, 1980.

Which rulings matter to practitioners?

  • Corporate liability. In Sanofi India Ltd. v. CBI (2026 LiveLaw (SC) 904), a company can be prosecuted for mens rea offences without naming individual officers. The bench evolved a three-stage inquiry for attributing a natural person's guilty mind to a corporation.

  • SARFAESI. Banks may invoke the SARFAESI Act, 2002 for loans assigned by NBFCs not covered by the statute when the debt arose, held Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva in Kotak Mahindra Bank v. Trupti Sanjay Mehta (September 2). A separate bench permitted SARFAESI proceedings despite an earlier DRT decree for the same debt.

  • Arbitration. "Arbitration, though rhymes with it, cannot result in an arbitrary measure," the Court held, setting aside a tribunal appointment challenged for bias. An arbitral tribunal cannot award pre-reference interest where a contract bars it, and Section 17 tribunals do not exercise appellate jurisdiction over Section 9 orders.

  • Service law. The Union's 271 appeals against disability pensions for ex-servicemen were dismissed on September 15; the burden lies on the Army to prove disability was not attributable to service. Compulsory retirement of an officer promoted two months earlier was set aside with ₹15 lakh in compensation.

What changed for consumers and employees?

Financiers cannot repossess hypothecated vehicles by force, the Court ruled on September 16, awarding ₹10 lakh to a truck owner whose vehicle was seized at 1 a.m. The RBI was directed to secure genuine compliance with its recovery guidelines, which "have existed only on paper." A widow's family pension must run from the date of her husband's death in 2000, not her tribunal approach in 2014. Pre-regularisation service counts for pension, and a 21-year-old conviction fell because the accused was a juvenile — Section 362 CrPC, the Court held, does not curtail the High Court's inherent power to recall a judgment causing miscarriage of justice.

What questions went to larger benches?

Whether fraudulent intent is necessary under Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 was referred to a larger bench, as was whether a Civil Judge notified as a Commercial Court can hear trademark suits despite Section 134 of the Trade Marks Act. A seven-judge bench reserved judgment on states' power to levy surcharge on sales tax. The Court also urged the Chief Justice to consider a permanent Constitution Bench, calling delayed references "a source of institutional embarrassment."

What about the electoral and regulatory front?

Petitions challenging the 2023 Election Commissioners' appointment law were referred to a Constitution Bench, with Justice Dipankar Datta questioning whether a Prime Minister-nominated minister can "defy his own nominator." The Election Commission must decide the Trinamool Congress symbol dispute within four months. FSSAI revised its stand after judicial questioning and will consider warning labels on foods high in even one nutrient of concern, adopting a Canadian-style red hexagon.

The month's plain lesson: courts read the citations, verify the custody chain, and expect regulators to act on their own rules.

via livelaw.in (Source)

Filed under

  • supreme-court-of-india
  • ai-hallucinated-citations
  • customs-law
  • criminal-justice
  • arbitration
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

327 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »