Law report No. GLW-8463 · filed November 20, 2026
Trade LawReported case
Importer Hit With $40M Loss Sues to Strike Down 50% Canada Tariffs
Gellert Global Group, down an estimated $40 million, leads a Court of International Trade challenge to Trump's 50% Canada dairy tariffs built on a 1930 law unused since the Depression.
By Amara Osei3 min read691 words
Holding
- Gellert Global Group reports an estimated $40 million loss from 50 percent tariffs on Canadian dairy.
- The suit in the U.S. Court of International Trade challenges tariffs imposed under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, unused since the Great Depression.
- U.S. dairy exports to Canada rose 67 percent between 2021 and 2024 under the USMCA.
- Half of the cheese Gellert imports from Canada is made with U.S. milk processed in Ontario.
- The Liberty Justice Center previously won a Supreme Court case overturning Trump's emergency tariffs.

A 50 percent tariff on Canadian dairy imports has cost one New Jersey importer an estimated $40 million, and the company now wants the U.S. Court of International Trade to strike the levies down. Gellert Global Group, a food importer and distributor employing 700 people, filed suit as lead plaintiff, represented by the Liberty Justice Center — the same nonprofit firm that persuaded the Supreme Court to overturn President Donald Trump's earlier "emergency" tariffs this year.
The suit attacks the administration's reliance on Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, a provision untouched since the Great Depression. The plaintiffs advance five grounds for striking the tariffs, arguing that even if the statute survives, the administration failed to follow its procedural requirements.
What did the White House actually decide?
Earlier this year, President Trump escalated the trade war with Canada by imposing sweeping new tariffs on dairy products, with some items banned outright by presidential decree. The White House framed the move as retaliation against Canadian protectionism, saying the barriers would "make America wealthier and stronger, offsetting the burden and disadvantage" of tariffs Canada already charges on American dairy crossing the border.
That framing assumes American and Canadian dairy are separate, competing products. Tom Gellert, co-CEO of Gellert Global Group, says the assumption fails on the facts.
"Half of the cheese that we import from Canada to the U.S. is made with U.S. milk," Gellert said. That milk comes from farms in New York, Wisconsin, the Dakotas and elsewhere, then travels to processing plants in Ontario for conversion into cheese. The tariff, in effect, taxes American milk returning home in Canadian form.
Is Canada really gouging American dairy?
President Trump has claimed otherwise: "So we want to sell milk into Canada, and they throw a 270 percent price increase on the milk." Gellert calls that wildly misleading. The high Canadian tariffs apply only after American imports exceed quotas set under the United States–Canada–Mexico Agreement — the deal Trump negotiated in his first term.
"I don't think it's an intellectually honest debate on the Canadian trade restrictions," Gellert said.
Canada ranks as the second-largest export market for American dairy, behind only Mexico. Exports to Canada climbed 67 percent between 2021 and 2024, largely because of the USMCA. The trade war now jeopardizes that growth and, by one House lawmaker's account, has crushed the cross-border supply chains that firms like Gellert depend upon.
The economics are straightforward, per Gellert: "We can't continue to pay 50 percent tariffs because we just can't afford to be giving money to the Treasury Department versus investing in the business." He describes the cross-border model as now "unsustainable."
Why do the legal arguments look shaky?
Section 338 has gathered dust for nearly a century. Philip Zelikow, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, argues the law is defunct because later legislation superseded it. Other critics contend the administration's use of Section 338 unlawfully expands executive power and violates the "major questions" doctrine — the very doctrine that helped sink Trump's earlier tariffs at the Supreme Court.
The pattern is familiar. A court already found one tariff scheme unlawful. The government has now reached for an older, rustier instrument.
What does the case mean for practitioners?
For trade counsel, the litigation tees up three live issues: whether Section 338 was impliedly repealed by subsequent statutes; whether its procedures were followed; and whether major questions review applies to sector-specific tariff proclamations. Companies importing under tariffed lines should track the case's procedural posture at the Court of International Trade, given the Liberty Justice Center's winning record on IEEPA tariffs and the prospect of refunds or injunctions if the challenge succeeds.
Gellert has lobbied Congress and the administration without result. "We just want cooler heads to prevail in these trade negotiations," he said. "And, you know, we like to see the government operate in ways that are consistent with the law."
The takeaway: a Depression-era statute now carries a modern trade war, and a court will decide whether it can bear the weight.
via reason.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
351 articles
Also before the court
- Cato Fires Back at Trump's 50% Canada Tariffs in Trade Court
- Federal Court Strikes Down New Global Tariffs Imposed After Supreme Court Loss
- Trump's Latest Global Tariffs Drawn Into Trade Court Challenge
- Trade Court Rules Trump's 10% Global Tariff Illegal
- EU Weighs Response After US Supreme Court Blocks IEEPA Tariffs