Law report No. GLW-8602 · filed November 18, 2026
Human RightsReported case
Florida's Terror Designation Forces CAIR-Florida Out of Operation
Florida's 5 November terror designation of CAIR forced the state's largest Muslim civil rights group to suspend operations amid a federal free speech lawsuit.
By Amara Osei5 min read939 words
Holding
- Florida's domestic terrorist designation of CAIR took effect on 5 November under legislation Governor DeSantis approved in July.
- CAIR-Florida, with about 12 staff and eight contractors, suspended operations; a federal court denied its request to operate during litigation and the group has appealed.
- CAIR has never been charged with or convicted of any crime; Texas's similar designation is set to be reversed after Abbott and Paxton lost their seats.
- Private clients face legal costs of roughly $10,000 that CAIR previously absorbed through pro bono services.

On 5 November, Florida's designation of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) as a domestic terrorist organization took effect, and the state's leading Muslim civil rights group promptly stopped operating. CAIR and its Florida chapter have sued Governor Ron DeSantis and other state officials in federal court, alleging violations of free speech and due process. A federal judge this month rejected the chapter's request to operate while litigation continues. The organization has appealed to the US Court of Appeals.
How did Florida acquire this power?
In July, Governor DeSantis approved legislation granting five state officials the authority to designate groups as domestic terrorist organizations. The designation triggers debilitating penalties under state law for the group and its supporters. CAIR says the mere threat of those penalties forces designated groups to shut down.
The state did not stop with CAIR. Florida applied the same designation to the Muslim Brotherhood and to "antifa," a term described loosely as an umbrella for far-left and anarchist anti-fascist groups and individuals. State officials argued in legal filings, without clear evidence, that CAIR has operated as a front for Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood, "all while masquerading as run-of-the-mill civil rights organizations." CAIR denies the claims and has never been charged with or convicted of any crime.
What does the shutdown mean in practice?
CAIR-Florida employed roughly 12 staff members and eight contractors. Its homepage is now pitch black, carrying a note that staff suspended operations because of the "baseless and unconstitutional enforcement" of Florida's law. The chapter can no longer provide pro bono legal services in discrimination and immigration cases, and local attorneys are scrambling to fill the gap.
Edward Ahmed Mitchell, CAIR's national deputy director, said in a statement: "For the first time in over twenty years, Florida Muslims cannot call their community's leading civil rights organization for help if they experience a hate crime at their mosque, illegal discrimination in the workplace, violent bullying in school, or any other acts of bigotry."
Before the designation even took effect, the organization had paused donor outreach, cancelled recurring donations and suspended three annual fundraising galas. A Florida IT company terminated its work relaunching a website tracking Islamophobia. CAIR-Florida's lawyers had already turned away new clients. In a normal year, the chapter would have scheduled post-midterm meetings with elected officials. That did not happen.
Is this legally unprecedented?
Yes, according to Shirin Sinnar, a Stanford University law professor who co-authored an amicus brief for CAIR in a related case. "It's entirely unprecedented for state governments to attempt to shut down organizations by branding them as terror organizations," she said, adding that the move "sends a message to the Muslim American community, as a whole, that this organization, which has defended your civil rights, is no longer able to do that."
Sinnar read the tactic plainly: "The whole point is to establish a precedent with the most disfavored of organizations – the one that few people in the state will rally to defend." The power, once established, can then reach other groups.
CAIR's record includes taking Muslim Americans' grievances over federal no-fly lists to the Supreme Court, where it won. Its Florida chapter fought for prisoners' access to halal meals and for pro-Palestinian students' right to protest.
Has the designation been challenged elsewhere?
Texas offers one counterexample. Governor Greg Abbott, who proclaimed CAIR a terrorist organization last year, and attorney general Ken Paxton, who sued to shut the group down, both lost their seats to Democrats. Incoming Governor Gina Hinojosa told the Washington Post she will reverse Abbott's designation, and Paxton recently dropped his lawsuit. The Muslim Legal Fund of America, representing CAIR in Texas, said "it's pretty clear this case is probably not going to go much further."
Florida offers no such path. Republicans control both legislative chambers and the governorship. Community activist Abdullah Sheikh, who tried to rally opposition before the bill reached DeSantis's desk, said "the legislature has zero incentive to do anything at this point." He called Florida a "cautionary tale for other states." After speaking with board members at more than a dozen central Florida mosques, he reported that leadership now avoids programming beyond prayers: "The mosques now are scared of their own shadow."
Who fills the legal void?
Private attorneys, imperfectly. Jalal Shehadeh, a Palestinian American lawyer on the boards of several legal organizations including the Florida Muslim Bar Association, said "the void left behind by CAIR-Florida's absence is far too large to be filled by the good-hearted local attorneys that are trying to help the community." He anticipates a heavier caseload and noted that private lawyers cannot front the costs CAIR absorbed. "Most often the people that need help are the ones without resources," he said. "These individuals don't have the ability to fork up $10,000 to hire a good attorney."
Salma Khan, whom CAIR assisted with attorneys and advocacy after a harassment video went viral three years ago, asked the obvious question: "Who else is going to be labeled that? What will happen to our community?"
Omar Soboh, a Palestinian American student at the University of Florida who interned at CAIR-Florida this summer, saw his campus panel on Islamophobia cancelled after the designation. He still hopes the courts rule in CAIR's favor. The chill has reached him anyway. "It's made me associate doing work for the Muslim community as being something that is controversial," he said. One designation, and a twenty-year civil rights institution went dark.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
333 articles
Also before the court
- U.S. Court Blocks Enforcement of ICC Sanctions on Advocacy Groups
- Federal Judge Blocks US Sanctions on Rights Groups Aiding ICC
- US Judge Blocks Trump Sanctions on Two ICC-Support Groups
- US Courts Chip Away at ICC Sanctions as First Amendment Claims Mount
- US Judge Blocks Trump Bid to Penalize ICC Probe Aiders