Law report No. GLW-8562 · filed November 18, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

NetChoice Sues New York Over Social Media Warning Law

NetChoice sued New York on November 13 over S8827, which from January 1 forces apps with infinite scroll to show unskippable Surgeon General-style mental health warnings to users 17 and under.

By Amara Osei4 min read787 words

Holding

  1. NetChoice filed its complaint against New York's warning law on Friday, November 13.
  2. From January 1, apps with infinite scroll must show users 17 and under a 10-second unskippable warning daily, and 30 seconds after three hours of use.
  3. A federal judge recently blocked Colorado's similar law as likely compelled speech under the First Amendment.
  4. NetChoice is also challenging comparable statutes in California and Minnesota.
  5. Australia's under-16 ban, in force since December, is circumvented by 61% of former account holders aged 12–15, per the Molly Rose Foundation.
New York Wants To Force Social Media Apps To Display Mental Health Warnings. Critics Are Suing.
PlateNew York Wants To Force Social Media Apps To Display Mental Health Warnings. Critics Are Suing. — Pixelkult / pixabay

A trade association sued New York on Friday over a statute that will force social media apps to display unskippable mental health warnings beginning January 1. NetChoice, which represents technology firms, filed the complaint in federal court, arguing that the mandated message compels private speakers to carry the state's opinion in violation of the First Amendment.

The law at issue, Senate bill S8827, requires any platform with an "addictive feed, autoplay, and/or infinite scroll" to interrupt users with a timed warning. The message reads: "The Surgeon General has warned that while social media may have benefits for some young users, excessive use may be associated with significant mental health harms."

How would the warning work in practice?

The mechanics are precise. A user aged 17 or younger sees a 10-second, unskippable warning the first time they open the app each day. After three hours of continuous use, the warning returns for another 30 seconds. Platforms can exempt a user only if they have "reasonably determined that the user is over seventeen years of age."

Three hours of scrolling earns a half-minute lecture. That is the statute's arithmetic.

NetChoice disputes the analogy to conventional product labels. Cigarettes, over-the-counter drugs, and even Lego carry warnings. The complaint, filed November 13, draws a distinction: "Unlike a static warning on a product label, these warnings repeatedly interrupt users and block access to protected speech."

The association advances two further arguments. First, the product burdened here is other people's speech, not a physical good. Second, the warning does not accurately reflect the surgeon general's findings, because research on social media harm remains inconclusive. The group frames the warning as government opinion rather than established fact.

What does the First Amendment claim rest on?

Paul Taske, director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, stated the core position plainly: "The First Amendment forbids New York from forcing private speakers to serve as government mouthpieces, and that includes compelled state-scripted warnings on speech."

The doctrinal battleground is Zauderer v. Office of Disciplinary Counsel (1985). Under that framework, the government may compel disclosures in commercial speech, meaning speech that proposes a sale, if the information is "purely factual and uncontroversial" and serves a legitimate government interest. Disclosures imposed on noncommercial speech face strict scrutiny, requiring the government to prove it used the least restrictive means to serve a compelling interest.

Precedent favors NetChoice, at least provisionally. NetChoice is challenging similar laws in California, Minnesota, and Colorado. In the Colorado case, a federal judge recently blocked the statute after finding that it compels protected speech and likely violates the First Amendment. The judge held that social media content is noncommercial speech and that, although the state had a "laudable goal," it lacked justification for compelling noncommercial expression.

Why are lawmakers acting now?

The legislative impulse draws on a sharp rise in mental illness diagnoses among young people over roughly two decades. New York's law cites figures from 2011 to 2018: suicide rates among girls aged 10 to 14 doubled, and major depressive episodes among girls aged 12 to 17 rose by 52 percent. Those numbers amount to one additional depressive episode for every two girls in the cohort, measured over seven years.

The causal evidence, however, remains contested. Some research links moderate social media use to better health outcomes among teenagers. The science is unsettled. The statutes are not.

Do similar measures work abroad?

Other jurisdictions have gone further. Australia's under-16 ban took effect last December. France passed an under-15 ban in July. Denmark, Spain, the United Kingdom, and others have announced plans to follow.

The Australian record invites caution. Reports from the Molly Rose Foundation found that "three fifths (61%) of 12–15 year-olds who previously held accounts on restricted platforms continue to have access to one or more active accounts," and that "70% of children still using restricted sites say that it was 'easy' to circumvent the ban." Age verification has also created security exposure: last year hackers stole at least 70,000 government ID photos from Discord, images users had supplied during the age authentication process.

What is the takeaway for practitioners?

For platform counsel, the practical calculus is immediate. Compliance systems must be built before January 1, yet the Colorado ruling suggests the New York measure may not survive a preliminary injunction motion. Litigators on both sides should watch whether the court classifies the warning as a Zauderer disclosure or as compelled noncommercial speech. That classification will likely decide the case.

The dispute, in plain terms, is this: the state says it is warning; the industry says it is conscripting. A federal court will choose between the two verbs.

via reason.com (Source)

Filed under

  • netchoice
  • first-amendment
  • social-media-regulation
  • compelled-speech
  • new-york
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

333 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »