Law report No. GLW-7029 · filed November 18, 2026
Human RightsReported case
European Court Orders Turkey to Free Jailed Lawmaker Atalay
Strasbourg ordered Turkey to free jailed lawmaker Can Atalay, awarding him €32,500, after Ankara's criminal courts defied two release orders from the Constitutional Court.
By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read851 words
Holding
- The European Court of Human Rights ruled on Tuesday that Turkey must release jailed lawmaker Can Atalay and seat him in Parliament.
- The court awarded Atalay €32,500 (about $35,700) for nonfinancial harm.
- Atalay received an 18-year sentence from an Istanbul court in April 2022 over the 2013 Gezi Park protests.
- Turkey's Constitutional Court ordered his release in October and December 2023; the Court of Cassation refused to comply.
- Judge Saadet Yüksel of Turkey partially dissented; either party may seek Grand Chamber referral within three months.

The European Court of Human Rights on Tuesday ordered Turkey to release Şerafettin Can Atalay and let him take his parliamentary seat, awarding him €32,500 (about $35,700) for nonfinancial harm. The Strasbourg court found his continued imprisonment unlawful and his exclusion from Parliament unjustified.
Atalay is a lawyer and human rights defender jailed over Turkey's 2013 Gezi Park protests. He won election to Parliament while his appeal was pending. Two Turkish Constitutional Court (the country's top constitutional review body) orders for his release never opened his cell door. So he took his case to Europe.
What did the court decide?
The judges ruled that the rules used to deny Atalay parliamentary immunity (legal protection from prosecution enjoyed by lawmakers) were not sufficiently predictable. They also found that the Court of Cassation, Turkey's highest criminal court, refused to enforce binding constitutional judgments.
"As a result, the applicant remained in detention despite the Constitutional Court's findings of a violation of his right to liberty and security and its orders for their release," the judges wrote.
The court went further on motive. It found the imprisonment served a political purpose: silencing Atalay and stifling pluralism. Its reasoning drew on the criminal court's departure from its own precedents, criminal complaints filed against constitutional judges, and presidential statements backing that defiance.
How did the case get here?
Atalay was a member of Taksim Solidarity, the coalition that coordinated the Gezi protests. Prosecutors cast his organizing, phone calls and public statements as involvement in an attempted overthrow of the government. In April 2022, an Istanbul court sentenced him to 18 years. He was tried alongside activist Osman Kavala, who remains imprisoned on a life sentence despite multiple rulings that he be freed.
Then voters intervened. In May 2023, with his appeal pending, Atalay won a seat representing the Workers Party of Türkiye. He requested release and suspension of proceedings under constitutional protections for lawmakers. The Court of Cassation refused, treating his offense as an exception to immunity, and upheld his conviction in September 2023.
The Constitutional Court ordered his release and suspension in October 2023 and again in December. The criminal court refused to comply and filed criminal complaints against the constitutional judges behind the first judgment. Parliament terminated his mandate in January 2024, sparking a brawl among lawmakers. Atalay applied to Strasbourg that April.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
The judgment endorses the Constitutional Court as an effective domestic remedy (the legal avenue a claimant must exhaust before going to Strasbourg), stopping short of declaring it generally useless for challenging detention. That matters for anyone advising detained clients in Turkey: the route through Ankara remains open, at least for now. The court also required broader general measures to ensure constitutional judgments are implemented — a demand aimed at the institutional standoff, not just one prisoner. Either party can seek referral to the Grand Chamber within three months, though acceptance is not automatic; if no request succeeds, the judgment becomes final, with compliance supervised by the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers.
What are the scholars saying?
Philip Leach, professor of human rights law at Middlesex University, said targeting a rights defender despite his immunity struck at the values the European Convention protects. "This judgment represents another crystal clear marker of the ongoing severe repression of political and democratic rights in Turkey," he said.
Bertil Emrah Oder, professor of constitutional law at Koç University, described one top court disabling another as a distinct instrument of political exclusion. She argued the Strasbourg judges understated the systemic problem by limiting their findings to Atalay's circumstances. "Under the European human rights protection system, Strasbourg can declare, but only domestic authorities can comply," she said.
Necdet Umut Orcan, head of the human rights law department at Marmara University, supported the court's restraint on remedies: bypassing the Constitutional Court would weaken it and deny detainees a faster route. But he warned that repeated defiance by the Court of Cassation, backed by the executive and Parliament, makes the problem harder to treat as exceptional. "Still, I don't think the court can hold this position indefinitely," he said.
Ayşegül Kars Kaynar, associate professor of political science at Turkey's Grand National Assembly, said selectively withholding parliamentary protection entrenches unequal political rights. She criticized the Constitutional Court's failure to resolve Atalay's latest application and doubted the judgment would change his situation.
Constitutional scholar Müzeyyen Gözde Atasayan Bilal said the core issue is enforcement, not protection: "The fundamental challenge is therefore not the absence of judicial protection, but the failure to give effect to binding judicial decisions."
Judge Saadet Yüksel of Turkey dissented on unlawful detention, electoral rights and political purpose, finding the immunity exception predictable and the evidence of ulterior motive insufficient. She agreed, though, that refusing to enforce constitutional judgments violated Atalay's right to challenge his detention.
Atalay's lawyers and the Turkish government did not respond to requests for comment. Turkey has now been told to deliver what his earlier victories never secured: his release and his seat.
via amnesty.org (Original)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
343 articles
Also before the court
- European Court Awards Damages Over Prolonged Detention
- ECtHR Strikes Out 879 Cases Against Russia in Lebedeva Ruling
- Istanbul Court Widens Gaza Flotilla Probe, Targets Turkish Nationals
- European Court Holds Ukraine Liable in Acid Killing of Activist
- European Court of Human Rights Rules for Religious Tolerance in Ukraine