Law report No. GLW-2575 · filed November 19, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
EU Court Adviser: Paying With Data Makes 'Free' Facebook Ads Misleading
Advocate General Laila Medina told the CJEU that Facebook users 'pay' with personal data, making the 2015 'Facebook is and remains free' slogan potentially misleading under EU unfair advertising rules.
By Amara Osei3 min read678 words
Holding
- Advocate General Laila Medina issued her CJEU opinion on Thursday, November 2026, in the German consumer federation's case against Meta Platforms Ireland.
- The slogan at issue — 'Facebook is and remains free' — appeared on the German-language sign-up page in February 2015.
- Germany's Federal Court of Justice referred the case to the CJEU in September 2025 after two Berlin courts ruled for Facebook.
- Medina held that granting commercial data-use permission constitutes payment under EU unfair advertising rules.
- The opinion also bears on a paused German case over whether Lidl's rewards app disclosed its data cost to shoppers.

Facebook users pay for their "free" accounts with personal data, and advertising that omits this can be misleading under EU unfair advertising rules. That is the opinion of Advocate General Laila Medina, delivered Thursday at the Court of Justice of the European Union in Case C-63/25 (Federation of German Consumer Organizations v Meta Platforms Ireland). The opinion is advisory, cannot be appealed, and the full court will now give the binding answer.
The dispute dates to February 2015, when Facebook's German-language sign-up page told users: "Facebook is and remains free." The Federation of German Consumer Organizations sued Meta Platforms Ireland to stop the slogan reaching German consumers. Before litigating, the federation asked Facebook to sign a formal pledge to abandon the phrase. The company refused. Two Berlin courts sided with Facebook, the first holding that the unfair advertising rule applied only where consumers faced a financial burden. In September 2025, Germany's Federal Court of Justice put the case on hold and referred the question to Luxembourg: did users pay by surrendering their data for commercial use?
Medina concluded they did.
What does the opinion actually say?
Facebook required users to share data and grant commercial-use permission before they could sign up. That permission funded a business built on detailed profiles and targeted advertising. In Medina's view, the permission itself carried economic value even though users retained ownership of their information. Her reading would still permit the word "free" where a company uses data solely to provide the service or meet a legal obligation.
Some versions of the EU directive pointed to payment in money; others left room for other forms of consideration. Medina looked at what consumers could actually see. A cash price sits on the screen. A data price does not.
"That person is unlikely to be aware of the economic value of what he or she is giving, or of the extent of the advertising to which the disclosure of those data may give rise," she wrote.
Once a "free" offer falls under the ban, she added, there is no need to prove that any particular user was misled. Privacy law governs how companies handle data; consumer law governs what they tell customers. Ad-funded services remain lawful.
How have the parties and commentators responded?
Meta argues "free" means no monetary charge and that EU privacy law already protects users. Treating personal data as payment, the company says, would turn a fundamental right into a commodity and unfairly restrict ad-supported services. "We respectfully disagree with the advocate general and await the European court's decision," a Meta spokesperson said.
Federation executive director Ramona Pop welcomed the opinion as encouraging for consumers who trade data for everyday services. Facebook had already dropped the slogan, she noted, but the stakes reach further. Germany's top court has also paused a federation case over whether discounter Lidl made the cost of its rewards app clear enough to shoppers.
Academic reaction was split. Andreas Kotsios, a senior lecturer in EU law at Uppsala University, questioned whether users perceive data as something they spend. "Following the same logic, one could argue that the time spent watching advertisements also constitutes a similar cost," he said. "After all, time is money!" He expects the judges to follow Medina, but worries that treating data as payment could hand companies a rationale for exploiting it as an asset.
Donato Maria Matera, a lecturer in IT law at LUM Giuseppe Degennaro University in Italy, noted that Italian regulators and courts already take a similar approach. "It is particularly important that this transparency should be ensured from the very earliest stages of commercial communication," he said. What people see before clicking Sign Up can shape whether they click at all.
What happens next?
The EU judges will deliver the binding ruling on what counts as payment. Germany's Federal Court of Justice will then decide whether Meta may revive its old promise. One sentence at the sign-up screen may yet cost the company more than it saved.
via vzbv.de (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
351 articles
Also before the court
- CJEU Platform Liability Ruling Draws Free Expression Warnings
- Meta Loses Court Battle Over Compensation to Italian Publishers
- French Parliament adopts law requiring platforms to pay publishers
- EU Court of Justice Confirms Platforms Must Pay for Press Content
- European Appeals Centre Overturns 74% of Platform Moderation Decisions