Law report No. GLW-3294 · filed November 17, 2026

Regulation & EnforcementReported case

European Appeals Centre Overturns 74% of Platform Moderation Decisions

Appeals Centre Europe disagreed with platforms in 74% of reviewed decisions, with an 86% reversal rate on scams and 99% on violent content left online.

By Priya Raman4 min read785 words

Holding

  1. Appeals Centre Europe overturned 74% of reviewed platform decisions between October 2025 and September 2026, up from 59% in its May report.
  2. The centre received nearly 43,000 complaints; scams drew an 86% reversal rate across 940 cases.
  3. Platforms' failure to supply content produced more than 10,000 procedural decisions favouring users.
  4. Google supplied just two pieces of content despite more than 850 requests.
  5. The centre's decisions are nonbinding; users retain the right to go to court.
Scams slip through as Europe’s social media appeals pile up
PlateScams slip through as Europe’s social media appeals pile up — 377053 / pixabay

Europe's independent social media appeals body disagreed with platforms in 74% of the decisions it reviewed between October 2025 and September 2026, according to its latest transparency report. The reversal rate, up from 59% in the centre's May report, covers nearly 5,000 decisions in which reviewers could actually examine the disputed content.

Appeals Centre Europe, based in Dublin, received close to 43,000 complaints during the reporting period from users seeking to recover accounts, restore posts or remove harmful material. The centre opened in November 2024 to give users an alternative to the company that made the original decision or to a courtroom. The EU's Digital Services Act created the right to independent out-of-court dispute settlement as a quicker and cheaper route than litigation.

Its free service covers Facebook, Instagram, Threads, TikTok, YouTube, Google Maps and Pinterest. Reviewers assess whether companies followed their own rules, and the centre uses those findings to track recurring mistakes across platforms.

Where did platforms fail most?

Scams became the centre's busiest policy area between April and September 2026, earning a dedicated section in the new report. Reviewers rejected decisions to leave suspected scams online in 940 cases — an 86% reversal rate. For content left standing, reversals reached 82% for hate speech and 99% for violent or graphic material.

The scam pitches ranged from instant riches to instant romance.

  • A Facebook video used an AI-generated likeness of Moldovan economic expert Veaceslav Ioniță to promise a 2,000% investment return.
  • A YouTube cryptocurrency video directed viewers to copy code from ChatGPT that reviewers said would likely let the scammer steal their funds.
  • A TikTok account featured an AI-generated woman speaking Romanian seeking a committed relationship; reviewers found a wider operation using fabricated characters, with bank account details in the account biography.

Thomas Hughes, CEO of Appeals Centre Europe, said Meta and TikTok had suspended accounts carrying batches of scam posts, including Facebook loan advertisements and TikTok romance videos reported by the nonprofit Vigilia Tech.

What did the report actually say?

"One of the key improvements we want to see from platforms is to tell us whether they have implemented our decisions. We can then pass this information on to users," Hughes said.

The report itself is blunter on the gap. "While this report includes several examples of cases where platforms have implemented our decisions, we are still not receiving consistent data about whether platforms have actioned our decisions," officials wrote.

Missing evidence blocked thousands of complaints from full review. Platforms' failure to supply content produced more than 10,000 procedural decisions favouring users, mostly involving suspended accounts. Those outcomes did not establish whether the original decision was wrong.

Google's record stands out. The company supplied just two pieces of content despite more than 850 requests for material needed to assess disputes where the content was no longer publicly available, the centre reported.

"In recent days, Google have told us that they will share more content related to pending disputes," Hughes said. He said the centre regularly briefs Ireland's media regulator, Coimisiún na Meán — which certified it in September 2024 — on operations and platform cooperation. A promise of more content, though, is not yet content delivered.

Why did the reversal rate rise?

Hughes cautioned against attributing the jump from 59% to 74% to any single factor. The reporting periods of the two reports overlapped. He did note, however, that reviewers had increasingly disagreed with decisions to leave content online, with higher reversal rates involving dangerous organisations and individuals, violent and graphic content and hate speech. One number conceals several moving parts.

Platforms also removed posts that reviewers said should have stayed. Facebook deleted a French user's image of a burst ketchup packet decorated with stick-figure arms and a miniature gun under its suicide and self-harm rules. Meta restored the image after the centre recommended reversing the decision.

What does the process mean for users and platforms?

Since October, users have been able to ask platforms to reconsider when the centre first contacts them, potentially resolving complaints before a full review. Companies must engage in good faith. The centre's decisions remain nonbinding — it can recommend a fix but cannot force one, and users can still go to court.

For practitioners advising platform clients or claimants, the report signals where procedural exposure lies: content preservation duties, evidence-handling in disputes and the reputational cost of an 86% scam reversal rate. For users, the centre offers leverage without a courtroom, but no guarantee of enforcement.

The takeaway in plain words: platforms are losing most arguments when an independent reviewer actually sees the evidence, and the evidence itself is the bottleneck.

via oversightboard.com (Original)

Filed under

  • digital-services-act
  • platform-moderation
  • online-scams
  • social-media
  • appeals-centre-europe
Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

324 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »