Law report No. GLW-8675 · filed November 20, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Fifth Circuit lifts block on Mississippi social media age-check law
A unanimous Fifth Circuit panel lifted a second injunction against Mississippi’s social media age-verification law, faulting the record for nine platforms and remanding the First Amendment case.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read729 words
Holding
- November 19, 2026: A unanimous three-judge Fifth Circuit panel lifted the second preliminary injunction.
- Nine platforms: The injunction covered Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Reddit, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth.
- 2024 and age 16: Mississippi enacted the Act after the suicide of Walker Montgomery, 16, who was targeted in an online sextortion scheme.
- Two injunction rounds: NetChoice obtained a facial injunction in 2024, then an as-applied injunction covering nine platforms.
- Two circuits, two results: The 11th Circuit vacated Georgia’s injunction, while a divided Sixth Circuit revived Ohio’s parental-consent requirement.

A unanimous three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit lifted a second preliminary injunction against Mississippi’s social media age-check law on November 19, 2026. The ruling in NetChoice v. Mississippi remanded the case to a Mississippi federal court and left the statute’s First Amendment validity unresolved.
Walker Montgomery was 16 when he died by suicide after being targeted in an online sextortion scheme. Mississippi lawmakers enacted the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act in 2024. The law bears his name.
The Act requires covered interactive platforms to make commercially reasonable efforts to verify users’ ages. It requires parental consent before known minors may hold accounts. Platforms also must adopt strategies to mitigate listed harms.
The statute limits the collection and use of minors’ data. Parents and the attorney general may enforce it.
What did the Fifth Circuit decide?
U.S. Circuit Judge Cory T. Wilson, a Donald Trump appointee, wrote for the unanimous panel. NetChoice, a trade association representing major internet companies, had not supplied a sufficiently detailed record of unconstitutionality. The panel required proof tied to each member’s websites and features.
General declarations that the law would burden platforms fell short of the particularized evidence needed to craft a narrowly tailored injunction.
“Because the district court did not perform the fact-intensive analysis necessary to substantiate why the Act is unconstitutional as applied to each member website, and because it did not tailor injunctive relief to each member website, it erred in issuing the second injunction.”
The lower court had barred enforcement altogether as to nine NetChoice member platforms: Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Reddit, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth. The panel said that complete bar lacked the record and tailoring required for as-applied relief.
Wilson’s summary was blunt: “Simply put, the district court had too little to go on” when it entered the second injunction.
“Because the injunction was not narrowly tailored as applied to those sites, the relief entered by the district court was at least premature, if not unwarranted.”
Why did the court send the case back?
The Fifth Circuit remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in Moody v. NetChoice and the panel’s earlier guidance in the case. Whether the statute ultimately violates the First Amendment remains an open question.
NetChoice first obtained a facial preliminary injunction from a Mississippi federal judge in 2024. After the Supreme Court decided Moody, the Fifth Circuit vacated that order and remanded. On remand, NetChoice shifted to an as-applied challenge.
The lower court again blocked the law for nine platforms. The Fifth Circuit stayed that second injunction pending appeal. The Supreme Court left the stay in place.
How did the parties react?
In a social media post on November 19, 2026, Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch wrote that the law asks social media companies “to make reasonable changes that a responsible corporate citizen should embrace.” She called the unanimous result “an important victory in our fight to keep our children safe in the digital age.”
NetChoice Litigation Center director Paul Taske said in a news release that the association was disappointed, but “nothing in the ruling holds that [the act] is constitutional.” He cited Justice Kavanaugh’s assessment that NetChoice was likely to win on the merits.
Taske said the association was “assessing all options to best preserve access to lawful speech in Mississippi.” He described the ruling as “about procedure and paperwork,” not a decision on whether Mississippi can require residents to hand over identification before accessing speech online.
What changes for legal practitioners?
The immediate change is procedural: the panel lifted the complete enforcement bar for the nine platforms but did not hold the statute constitutional. Litigants need evidence tied to each challenged website and feature, plus relief tailored to each platform, rather than generalized burden claims. The district court must conduct that analysis under Moody and Fifth Circuit guidance.
Where does this fit?
NetChoice is challenging state laws requiring age checks or parental consent for minors on social media, and outcomes remain mixed. Courts have blocked similar measures in several states, while appellate panels have grown more skeptical of broad injunctions after Moody. The 11th Circuit recently vacated an injunction against Georgia’s comparable law. A divided Sixth Circuit revived Ohio’s parental-consent requirement.
via x.com (Original)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
337 articles
Also before the court
- California Enacts Sweeping Package of Children's Online Safety Laws
- Meta, Google and TikTok Sue California Over Child-Safety Law AB 1709
- NetChoice Sues New York Over Social Media Warning Law
- Australia Passes World-First Law Banning Children From Social Media
- Turkish Parliament Passes Bill Restricting Social Media for Under-15s