Law report No. GLW-2977 · filed November 17, 2026
Antitrust & CompetitionReported case
EU adviser urges do-over of Google's €1.5 billion antitrust win
An Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the EU says the General Court wrongly dissected Google's AdSense contracts one by one, urging a do-over of the €1.5 billion fine.
By Grace Kim4 min read847 words
Holding
- Advocate General Juliane Kokott recommended on Thursday that the CJEU overturn the 2024 judgment annulling the €1.5 billion ($1.66 billion) fine on Google and Alphabet.
- The General Court had largely accepted evidence of Google's market strength, the restrictions' reach and their deterrent effect on publishers considering rivals.
- Kokott said the Commission did not appeal the rejection of its findings for 2016, so any restored fine must shrink.
- The Commission imposed the fine in March 2019 for conduct dating to 2006; the General Court annulled it in September 2024.
- The CJEU upheld a €4.125 billion Android fine in July, and Meta's €797.72 million Marketplace penalty remains under challenge at the General Court.
By Grace Kim
The Court of Justice of the European Union should undo Google's €1.5 billion ($1.66 billion) antitrust escape, Advocate General Juliane Kokott said on Thursday. Kokott recommended that the court overturn the 2024 judgment that annulled the European Commission's penalty against Google and its parent Alphabet, and send the case back to the General Court.
Her reasoning is narrow. The General Court, she wrote, demanded too much scrutiny of individual contracts without properly weighing the evidence together.
What is the Commission asking the CJEU to overturn?
The Commission wants the CJEU to overturn the General Court's 2024 ruling that scrapped the fine. Regulators said contracts for Google's AdSense for Search service kept competing advertising services out.
A search on another website could still make money for Google. AdSense for Search placed ads alongside that site's search results, with advertisers generally paying when someone clicked. Google then split the revenue with the site's publisher.
Publishers accepting Google's ads also accepted restrictions. Earlier contracts barred competing services from covered websites. Replacement terms introduced in March 2009 reserved prominent space for Google's ads and required Google's approval before publishers changed how search ads, including rivals' ads, appeared.
That is the theory of harm the General Court found unproven. Kokott said the lower tribunal had demanded too much.
Why did Kokott say the General Court demanded too much?\n
Two reasons.
First, the General Court faulted regulators for adding successive contract periods together without sufficiently examining whether publishers could switch suppliers between renewals or exercise rights to leave early.
Second, and central to her recommendation, the General Court largely accepted evidence of Google's market strength, the restrictions' reach and their deterrent effect on publishers weighing rivals — and never explained how examining contract duration more closely could have changed that assessment.
Repeated renewals and unused exit rights also mattered, Kokott said. Regulators could assess how the agreements worked collectively without dissecting every contract.
Takeaway: The opinion says the case turned on contract-by-contract analysis the tribunal did not need, while the market-strength findings Google lost in 2024 still stand.
Why does Google think it should win?
Google maintains that competitors could pitch for business when contracts expired but lost because their services were inferior.
Kokott asked: "In that respect, the question also raised by the commission in these proceedings does indeed arise: why was it actually necessary, from Google's perspective, despite the allegedly superior quality of its offering, to introduce those clauses and to continue to apply them on a graduated basis for years?"
Competing advertising services needed access to publishers' websites to reach users beyond Google's search engine. Building a rival business required substantial investment, while Google benefited from an established network of advertisers and publishers.
A Google spokesperson said the company was reviewing Thursday's opinion. "The General Court rightly annulled the original decision, finding that the EC had not demonstrated that our contracts restricted competition," the spokesperson said. The European Commission declined to comment.
What does a win for the Commission actually restore?\n
Not the original fine, on Kokott's reading.
The Commission did not appeal the rejection of its findings for 2016, which is now final. Any restored fine must therefore shrink, Kokott concluded, even if Google's broader victory is overturned.
Kokott's opinion is nonbinding. If the CJEU follows it, the General Court would resolve Google's remaining challenges, including objections to the penalty itself.
What should dominant companies take from this?\n
Vuk Leković, founder of Leković Legal, a competition lawyer and former case handler at the Serbian Competition Authority, found Kokott's reasoning persuasive. Regulators, he said, would still have to examine competitive effects, but without a forensic review of every contract.
"For dominant companies, the lesson I would draw for clients is that short contract terms and termination rights are not a safe harbor if, in practice, customers keep renewing," he said.
Leković cautioned that Google continued to argue the Commission was seeking a fresh assessment of facts, beyond the appeal court's role. A Commission victory, he stressed, would not automatically restore the original fine.
How the case unfolded
- Conduct at issue dated to 2006; Google removed or amended the restrictions in September 2016.
- Complaints reached European regulators in 2010, followed by others from Microsoft, Expedia and more companies.
- The Commission imposed the fine in March 2019.
- The General Court annulled the decision in September 2024.
- On Thursday, Kokott recommended overturning that judgment.
The wider European enforcement picture
- In July, the Court of Justice upheld a €4.125 billion Android fine over restrictions promoting Google Search and Chrome on mobile devices.
- Meta is challenging a €797.72 million penalty over linking Marketplace to Facebook and imposing unfair conditions on rival classified ad services. That challenge remains pending before the General Court.
Takeaway: Europe keeps testing how big tech steers business toward its own services, and the AdSense opinion shows appellate judges taking a hard look at how antitrust market-power findings get proved.
via eur-lex.europa.eu (Original)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
320 articles
Also before the court
- Google Seeks EU Top Court Backing for $1.7 Billion Antitrust Fine Reversal
- Google Asks EU Court to Uphold Annulment of €1.49 Billion Fine
- Google Loses Final Appeal Against EU's €4.1 Billion Android Fine
- European Commission Fines Google €2.95 Billion Over Ad Tech Abuses
- Google Escapes Ad Tech Breakup in Third Big Tech Antitrust Loss