Law report No. GLW-3085 · filed November 19, 2026

Regulation & EnforcementReported case

Compliance Brain Drain Hits APAC as AI Eats Junior Training

Hong Kong regulators flag compliance itself as a banking knowledge gap as APAC faces a brain drain, with AI threatening to automate away the junior work that once built senior judgment.

By Amara Osei5 min read1,088 words

Holding

  1. The HKMA, HKAB and HKIB surveyed 147 banks in Q1 2025 and in August 2025 named 'new regulatory compliance' among three key banking knowledge gaps.
  2. Rebuilding compliance capability after a senior departure takes 18-36 months, per ICA APAC managing director May May Lim.
  3. The SEC lost about 18% of staff in the fiscal year ended September 2025, per a 2026 GAO report.
  4. 81% of financial institutions across five APAC markets prioritized compliance cost cuts, per a 2024 LexisNexis study.
  5. MLRO roles needing 15-20 years' experience are being filled by candidates with under 10 to cut costs.
Compliance Brain Drain: When the Only Person Who Understands the Rules Walks Out the Door
PlateCompliance Brain Drain: When the Only Person Who Understands the Rules Walks Out the Door — Markus Winkler / unsplash

Eighteen to thirty-six months. That is how long a company needs to rebuild compliance capability after an experienced officer departs, even when it starts early — and Asia-Pacific regulators have begun naming the problem outright.

In August 2025, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, the Hong Kong Association of Banks and the Hong Kong Institute of Bankers published the results of a survey of 147 banks conducted in the first quarter of 2025. Among the three key banking knowledge gaps expected to emerge over the coming years, the regulators identified "new regulatory compliance" itself. Not a technology. Not a product line. The discipline of following the rules.

The picture beyond banking is no cheerlier. A 2026 Government Accountability Office report found the US Securities and Exchange Commission lost about 18% of its staff in the fiscal year ended September 2025, and more than half of the SEC employees the GAO interviewed said departing colleagues had taken unique knowledge or specialized skills with them. A 2024 LexisNexis Risk Solutions study of financial institutions across five APAC markets found 81% prioritizing cuts to compliance costs.

What actually walks out the door?

Formal qualifications can be rebuilt in months, according to May May Lim, managing director of the International Compliance Association APAC. What takes years is judgment: "Knowing how a specific regulator actually behaves in practice, which gray areas get escalated versus handled quietly, and the informal relationships that make enforcement conversations go smoothly."

The regulator relationship does not transfer with the job title. "Regulators in this region often deal with named individuals they trust, and that trust doesn't automatically transfer with the title," Lim said.

Eamonn Cunningham, who spent 30 years building the risk function at Westfield, later Scentre Group, before retiring as chief risk officer in 2016, is the exception that proves the scarcity. "On my retirement, very little knowledge walked out the door with me that had not been previously transferred over or already embedded in the system," he told Corporate Compliance Insights. He built his knowledge into policies, procedures and systems, and ran a one-to-one handover with a manual covering every part of the role, including third-party relationships. Conversations with counterparts across Asia-Pacific, the Americas and Europe suggested his approach was closer to the exception than the rule, with some organizations assuming "the successor will be pretty smart and he or she will just figure it out."

The takeaway: formal credentials are replaceable; embedded judgment rarely is.

Why APAC is more exposed

A 2025 Deloitte APAC report describes rising complexity and continued fragmentation across the region's regulators. Its markets range from Australia, where a royal commission pushed banks to build compliance into daily operations, to economies still establishing compliance departments at all. Singapore's rules on nominee directors and beneficial ownership, effective in 2025, show local regimes getting more detailed, not less.

James A. Fanto, Gerald Baylin Professor of Law and co-director of the Center for the Study of Business Law and Regulation at Brooklyn Law School, tied the risk to market maturity. A departure "shouldn't matter so long as they have junior people in a separate department and train them adequately," he said, adding: "It is definitely well developed in Australia. Again, the more developed it is, the less concern one has with the departure of senior people."

Craig Williams, regional managing partner of Heidrick & Struggles' corporate officers practice for Asia-Pacific and the Middle East, drew the same line. "There are two types of organizations: those that have been through intense regulatory scrutiny, and those that are going to," he said. "The ones with the 'battle scars' understand regulatory intent at a much deeper level." Where scrutiny has not arrived, "judgment often sits with individual leaders rather than being embedded, so key-person risk is much greater."

Cost pressure compounds the problem. An industry association director, speaking anonymously, described staff "double, triple or quadruple hatting" and organizations hiring down: a money laundering reporting officer role typically requiring 15 to 20 years of experience may go to someone with under 10, because they are cheaper.

The takeaway: the thinner the market and the leaner the budget, the greater the exposure.

What does a proper handover look like?

Carrie Leung, CEO of the Hong Kong Institute of Bankers, said in a written statement: "The challenge facing banks is not finding a replacement after a compliance professional leaves, but ensuring that critical knowledge and expertise are institutionalized before any transition occurs." The institute's tools include an enhanced competency framework, endorsed by the HKMA as a benchmark across specialized roles including compliance and anti-money laundering, and a certified banker program.

Lim's advice is procedural: identify a successor early, seat them in live regulatory interactions while the departing officer can still sanity-check their judgment, and document past precedents, regulator relationships and informal understandings rather than leaving them in one head. Start after the departure and the rebuild begins from zero, "with no one left to correct early mistakes or vouch for the successor with the regulator."

The takeaway: succession is a process, not a recruitment brief.

If AI does the junior work, who becomes senior?

Here is the complication few anticipated. AI is absorbing the routine work — reviewing flagged transactions, checking sanctions lists, verifying client funds — that has traditionally trained juniors into seniors. "Working through thousands of them is how people learn what normal looks like in their market, and how to spot the one case that isn't," Lim said. With AI taking that work, "tomorrow's successors may therefore start the 18-month-to-three-year clock with less to build on," while regulators continue to hold named individuals accountable.

Her prescription is deliberate exposure: juniors should check and explain the AI's decisions rather than rubber-stamp them, and join serious calls, such as suspicious activity report decisions, and regulator meetings early. "The organizations that handle this best will be training up a bench before they need to," she said. "Those that don't may find they have automated away their future compliance leaders."

Leung struck an optimistic note: "By freeing compliance practitioners from more routine activities, AI can create greater capacity for continuous and comprehensive learning, enabling them to broaden their knowledge, strengthen professional judgment and progress towards becoming holistic bankers."

Frameworks can be measured and built on a timeline. The trust of a regulator cannot. That is the part still most likely to walk out the door.

By Amara Osei, Global Law Wire

via corporatecomplianceinsights.com (Source)

Filed under

  • regulatory-compliance
  • compliance-succession-planning
  • key-person-risk
  • asia-pacific
  • ai-in-compliance
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

351 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »