Law report No. GLW-7525 · filed November 18, 2026

Regulation & EnforcementReported case

UK regulator finds ministers breaking environmental law over wild bird decline

The OEP has ruled Defra ministers and Natural England are breaking environmental law as wild bird populations hit a record low, with 45% of 132 native species in decline.

By Sophie Lindqvist3 min read649 words

Holding

  1. The OEP ruled on Wednesday that Defra ministers and Natural England are breaking environmental law over wild bird decline.
  2. 45% of 132 native breeding bird species declined over a five-year period; Britain has lost over 73 million wild birds in 50 years.
  3. England has 82 SPAs plus six cross-border and offshore sites.
  4. The government's 30 by 30 commitment requires protecting 30% of land and seas by 2030.
  5. RSPB reported a 47% rise in bird watching over eight years.
UK government ‘breaking the law’ by not stopping decline of wild birds
PlateUK government ‘breaking the law’ by not stopping decline of wild birds — bitnikgao / pixabay

Britain's wild bird populations have fallen to their lowest recorded level — and the UK's environment regulator says the government is breaking the law over it.

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP), the independent environmental regulator for England, ruled on Wednesday that Environment Secretary Angela Eagle, her Defra (Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) ministers, and Natural England are all in breach of environmental law. The breaches concern their failure to slow what the regulator calls a catastrophic decline in wild birds.

The numbers behind the finding are stark. Almost half — 45% — of 132 native breeding species declined over a five-year period. Over the last five decades, Britain has lost more than 73 million wild birds, according to the British Trust for Ornithology. Among the casualties: swifts, turtledoves, tree sparrows, wood warblers and bullfinches.

What exactly has the regulator found?

The OEP identified breaches across two public bodies.

Environment Secretary Angela Eagle breached environmental law by failing to:

  • classify new Special Protection Areas (SPAs — sites where birds and their habitats receive legal protection)
  • extend existing SPAs
  • add new species to the protected list

Natural England, the government's independent nature adviser, breached environmental law by failing to:

  • take the action needed to maintain or restore wild bird populations to appropriate levels
  • ensure birds have sufficient habitat
  • carry out a legally required review of whether sufficient habitat exists

That review matters, the OEP said. It was meant to provide an expert, independent assessment of whether the diversity and area of habitat is enough for wild birds, to identify gaps, and to explain what action would support recovery.

What does the ruling change for practitioners?

For environmental lawyers, the decision puts concrete legal duties back in play. Ministers carry statutory obligations to recover bird populations to healthy levels and to designate SPAs. England currently has 82 SPAs, plus six cross-border and offshore sites. The government is also legally bound by its 30 by 30 commitment — protecting at least 30% of land and seas for nature's recovery by 2030. The OEP's finding of continued delay means expect litigation risk around SPA classification timetables, potential judicial review from conservation NGOs, and pressure on Defra to accelerate designations that have sat unresolved for years.

Who said what?

Helen Venn, chief regulatory officer at the OEP, pointed to continued delays by ministers. "As a nation of bird-lovers, and with birds acting as important indicators for the state of our nature more widely, the latest statistics showing declines in the populations of some of our most treasured species are deeply concerning," Venn said.

"Continued delay has left a significant number of sites for wild bird populations without the levels of protection they need and allowed the scale of the actions needed to deliver a sufficient SPA network to build up," she added.

Beccy Speight, chief executive of the RSPB, demanded urgent action, including new and extended SPAs and targeted measures for species most in need — curlew, bittern and hen harrier. "Successive governments right across the UK have known about these problems for years. The time for navel gazing has long passed; the time for taking action is now, before it is too late," Speight said.

Is public interest rising while bird numbers fall?

Yes, and the contrast is sharp. In May, the RSPB reported a 47% increase in people enjoying bird watching over the past eight years. Yet Defra's latest statistics show no sign of widespread recovery. Both short-term and long-term trends indicate nearly half of all species are declining.

Despite repeated promises from Labour's environment ministers, the trajectory has not turned. The Department for Environment was approached for comment.

The OEP's message is simple: the legal framework already exists. What's missing is delivery — and the regulator has now said, on the record, that the failure amounts to a breach of the law.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Filed under

  • environmental-law
  • wild-bird-conservation
  • special-protection-areas
  • natural-england
  • office-for-environmental-protection
Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

343 articles

Also before the court

« Previous article