Law report No. GLW-4677 · filed November 19, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Calcutta High Court Turns Down ₹30 Lakh Customs Challenge Over Delay
Calcutta High Court dismissed Sanjib Kumar Chatterjee's challenge to the seizure of ₹30 lakh at Kolkata airport, citing delay and laches, but ordered Customs to hand over a copy of the 2022 order.
By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read827 words
Holding
- Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee of the Calcutta High Court disposed of the writ petition, reported 19 November 2026
- ₹30 lakh in Indian currency was seized at Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport on 22 January 2020
- The show-cause notice issued on 4 September 2020 under Section 124 of the Customs Act, 1962
- The Joint Commissioner of Customs passed the adjudication order on 17 February 2022
- Customs must supply a copy of that order within one week, and the ruling creates no equity for the petitioner

By Sophie Lindqvist
The Calcutta High Court has refused to quash the Customs adjudication (the process by which officials decide whether seized goods are confiscated and a penalty imposed) of ₹30 lakh in cash seized from a traveller at Kolkata's Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport on 22 January 2020.
Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee disposed of the writ petition on the ground that the man who challenged it waited too long to object, in a judgment reported on 19 November 2026.
"It is well-settled that delay and laches defeat equity," Justice Mukherjee said. Laches is the doctrine that bars relief to a party who delayed in asserting a right. The Court added that "the entire chain of events clearly suggests that there has been delay and laches on the part of the petitioner in not raising his objection before the Authority in time."
What did the court decide?
The Court disposed of the writ petition filed by Sanjib Kumar Chatterjee @ Sanjeev Kumar Chatterjee, who sought quashing of the adjudication proceedings and supply of the relevant records. It left those proceedings intact and found no ground to interfere.
Customs told the Court that the adjudication order had already been dispatched to the address in the petitioner's passport on 18 February 2022, and that his allegations of non-supply were baseless.
How the proceedings unfolded
The timeline runs from an airport seizure in 2020 to a petition filed in December 2024.
- 22 January 2020: Customs officers seized ₹30 lakh in Indian currency from the petitioner's bag at the Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport as he travelled from Kolkata to Dhaka. The petition alleged that the cash was concealed inside the bag.
- 4 September 2020: Customs issued a show-cause notice under Section 124 of the Customs Act, 1962, the provision used here to call on a person to explain why seized goods should not be confiscated.
- 19 November 2020: The petitioner submitted his reply to the show-cause notice.
- 5 July 2021: He was directed to attend a hearing on that date.
- 17 February 2022: The Joint Commissioner of Customs passed the adjudication order.
- 18 February 2022: Customs say the order was dispatched to the passport address the day after it was passed.
- 5 December 2023: Customs wrote to the petitioner to say the adjudication order had been dispatched on 18 February 2022.
- 27 February 2024: The petitioner sent a demand for justice seeking a complete copy of the order.
- December 2024: He approached the Calcutta High Court with the writ petition.
Was the adjudication order actually served?
The petitioner's central complaint was procedural. He claimed he received only the first page of the ten-page adjudication order, and that the remaining nine pages never reached him.
Justice Mukherjee held that whether all ten pages had actually been dispatched to him was a disputed question of fact, and such a question could not be determined in the exercise of writ jurisdiction (the court's power to quash an authority's decision on grounds of legality, not to re-examine disputed facts).
The Court also noted that the petitioner had received the Customs communication dated 5 December 2023 and still failed to raise any objection within a reasonable time. After his demand for justice on 27 February 2024, he waited almost ten months before approaching the High Court.
The Bench treated the sequence much like a customer told in December 2023 that a missing parcel had been posted in February 2022, who then waits until December 2024 to complain. By then the objection had hardened into laches.
What did the court still order?
One narrow direction survived. The Court directed the second respondent, the Joint Commissioner of Customs, to furnish a copy of the adjudication order dated 17 February 2022 to the petitioner within one week of receiving the order.
The Bench made clear that furnishing the copy would not create any equity in the petitioner's favour on the question of whether Customs had already served the order. The petitioner gets the document, not the relief he came for.
What does the ruling mean for practitioners?
For customs lawyers and in-house compliance teams, the lesson is about timing rather than service. A person told that an adjudication order has been dispatched must object before the adjudicating authority within a reasonable period, and the High Court will not reopen the point once the delay has hardened into laches.
Where a client disputes service itself, a writ is a poor vehicle: the court will not resolve a disputed question of fact. The practical route is to press the authority for the full record, then escalate promptly. Practitioners should diarise dispatch dates, keep the letter acknowledging dispatch, and record each step taken to seek the order.
The decision leaves the ₹30 lakh adjudication undisturbed and leaves the petitioner with a copy of the order in hand, but no route back to the quashing he sought.
via livelaw.in (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
360 articles
Also before the court
- Bombay High Court Refuses Urgent Document Plea in $15 Billion Suit Against Bank of Baroda
- Karnataka High Court: ED Is 'Not a Super Cop', Cannot File Private Complaints
- Telangana High Court quashes Cyberabad FIR against NRI husband
- MP High Court Rebukes State Over Fabricated Case Name in AI Pleadings
- Karnataka High Court: Acquitted Pakistani Must Stay Detained