Law report No. GLW-3315 · filed November 13, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Calcutta High Court Denies Bail to Alleged ISIS Operative After Three Years in Custody
Calcutta HC denied bail to alleged ISIS recruiter Md. Saddam after 3 years 10 months in custody, finding active extremist role beyond mere possession of literature under UAPA.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read761 words
Holding
- Calcutta High Court denied bail on Nov 13, 2026 in CRA (DB) 324 of 2025 before Justices Banerjee and Sinha Ray
- Appellant had spent over 3 years 10 months in custody with only 3 of 52 witnesses examined
- Charge sheet filed July 4, 2023; charges framed August 14, 2025; discharge application delayed trial further
- Court found communications with persons in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Syria discussing recruiting youths and killing journalists
- Bench held the case had not reached the 'melting point' under K.A. Najeeb because the prosecution showed no intentional delay

A man who has spent more than three years and ten months in custody lost his bail appeal on November 13, 2026, when the Calcutta High Court ruled that the investigation materials showed active participation in extremist activities. A Division Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray dismissed the appeal filed by Md. Saddam, also known as Mohammad Saddam, Saddam Mallik and Abdul Mallick, in Md. Saddam @ Mohammad Saddam @ Saddam Mallik @ Abdul Mallick v. Union of India, CRA (DB) 324 of 2025.
Saddam faced accusations of operating as an active ISIS recruiter. The National Investigation Agency (NIA) alleged he radicalised Muslim youths, circulated violent ISIS propaganda and administered clandestine Telegram groups aimed at sending Indian recruits to Afghanistan and Khorasan for terrorist training. He has remained in custody since his arrest under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA).
What did the Bench actually hold?
The Court drew a sharp line between passive possession and active participation. "The case at hand is not mere possession of literature," the Bench observed, distinguishing the matter from the Supreme Court's rulings in Thwaha Fasal v. Union of India and Vernon v. State of Maharashtra, on which the defence had relied.
The judgment recorded: "There are materials to show that the applicant took an active part in collecting or organizing or instigating youth who would take part in hijarat and jihad for Islamic extremism. He also collected youth isthihad (suicide squad)."
Forensic extraction reports from Saddam's electronic devices revealed Telegram communications, conducted through virtual phone numbers, with persons in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Syria and other foreign jurisdictions. The Court noted these conversations included discussions about killing journalists in India, with encouragement from foreign-based handlers.
The recovered materials also included videos and photographs depicting killings, beheaded bodies and militant training. The Court noted that some videos showed plans to target Prime Minister Narendra Modi and US President Donald Trump.
Why did the delay argument fail?
Senior Advocate Deep Chaim Kabir argued that Saddam's prolonged incarceration — over three years and ten months — entitled him to bail, since only three of 52 charge-sheeted witnesses had been examined. He invoked the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb, which permits constitutional courts to grant bail despite statutory bars where trials drag on unreasonably.
The Bench acknowledged that Section 43D(5) of the UAPA cannot override an accused's fundamental right to a speedy trial under Article 21. But it found the case had not yet reached the "melting point" contemplated in K.A. Najeeb, because the prosecution had not caused the delay.
The timeline proved decisive:
- The NIA filed its charge sheet on July 4, 2023.
- Charges were framed on August 14, 2025.
- Saddam then filed a discharge application, which halted witness examination.
- The rejection of that application was itself challenged before the High Court.
"We do not find any intentional laches from the side of the prosecution to prolong the trial," the Court held, relying on the Supreme Court's decisions in Gulfisha Fatima and Tasleem Ahmed. It also found that 52 witnesses could not be called excessive given the gravity of the allegations and the technical, electronic nature of the evidence.
How did the Court treat the co-accused comparison?
The defence sought parity with Farhan Javed, from whose mobile phone incriminating materials were allegedly recovered, yet who was cited as a prosecution witness rather than an accused. The Bench rejected the argument.
Farhan's statement under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure described how he met Saddam at a mosque near his aunt's house in Howrah, where he had come for higher secondary education. Saddam, who appeared knowledgeable, allegedly sent him incriminating materials marked as confidential and told him to keep them secret.
"In our considered view, the applicant and Farhan do not stand on the same footing," the Bench held, finding that Saddam had exploited his proximity to Farhan to indoctrinate him with extremist ideologies.
What does this mean for UAPA practitioners?
The ruling reinforces a demanding standard for bail applicants under Section 43D(5). Practitioners pursuing delay-based bail must now account carefully for their own procedural conduct. A discharge application that halts witness examination can shift responsibility for the delay onto the defence. Prosecution timelines, when clean, will hold. The NIA also identified one Amina Bint Munnavar, residing in Singapore, as a key radicaliser, and alleged Saddam's connection with Abdul Rakib Qureshi for coordinating extremist activities.
Finding the accusations prima facie true, the Court dismissed the appeal.
via livelaw.in (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
319 articles
Also before the court
- US Indictment Names Mohammed Ali al-Hassani as RAF Fairford Handler
- Ninth Circuit Vacates ISIS Support Conviction of Arizona Man
- Brooklyn Inmate Charged With Directing RAF Fairford Terror Plot
- ICC Convicts Ali Kushayb of War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity in Darfur
- Istanbul Court Widens Gaza Flotilla Probe, Targets Turkish Nationals