Law report No. GLW-7351 · filed November 12, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Supreme Court Hints at Curbing Agency Power to Impose Penalties
Supreme Court argument in DOL v. Sun Valley Orchards signals possible major limits on agency-imposed civil penalties without Article III court review.
By Amara Osei5 min read982 words
Holding
- Supreme Court heard argument in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, an H-2A visa penalty dispute testing Article III limits on agency adjudication.
- Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Barrett, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh all questioned the government's 'public rights' theory at argument.
- Justice Kagan defended the DOL's position, calling the case 'an admissions case' within immigration doctrine.
- The 1978 Bankruptcy Code's initial version was previously invalidated for assigning too much adjudication to non-Article III judges.
- Harris warned a broad ruling could unsettle Medicare, government contracts, and student loan programs.

By Amara Osei
The Supreme Court appears ready to impose major limits on the ability of federal agencies to levy fines through their own internal tribunals, at least absent prompt review in an Article III court. The signal came during yesterday's oral argument in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, a dispute over whether the Department of Labor may adjudicate penalties against farm employers without a federal judge in the room.
What is the constitutional question?
The case turns on the boundary between judicial power, allocated to the courts under Article III, and executive power conferred on the other branches. The Court has long tolerated executive officials resolving disputes in proceedings that resemble federal trials, even though those officials lack the life tenure and salary protections Article III gives federal judges. It has also, on several occasions, struck down schemes that traveled too far down that road. The most famous example remains the Court's invalidation of the original 1978 Bankruptcy Code, which gave undue adjudicative authority to bankruptcy judges outside Article III's protections.
What the Court has never done well is explain precisely how far such delegated adjudication may go. Recent decisions such as Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo and Trump v. Slaughter display a considerable appetite for reining in the administrative state. This case offers another opportunity.
Why does an agricultural visa case matter so much?
The underlying dispute involves the H-2A visa program for temporary foreign agricultural workers. Employers seeking those workers must promise, before the workers are admitted to the United States, to provide certain terms and conditions. When the Department of Labor concluded that an employer had failed to honor its pre-admission promises, it imposed fines or penalties in an administrative proceeding, frequently directing the money to the workers as compensation in the nature of back pay.
The question for the justices: can Article III tolerate that dispute being resolved internally by department employees rather than by federal judges?
The government, through Principal Deputy Solicitor General Sarah Harris, framed the case as squarely within two categories of "public rights" for which non-Article III treatment is permitted — the immigration power and public benefits. Entry, the argument runs, was conditional on the employer's promised treatment, and the right to enter is a benefit resting almost entirely in executive discretion.
Several justices found that reasoning thin.
What did the justices say?
Chief Justice John Roberts noted early that the leading immigration precedent, Oceanic Steam Navigation v. Mellor, "had to do very much with entry, a condition of entry, and loathsome diseases. This strikes me as significantly different. … You're trying to leverage an entry several weeks, months … in the past to the particular condition of work that doesn't seem to have much to do with the actual entry." The government, he said, was attempting to "extend that broad authority beyond the justification for its application." For the chief justice, the specifics "look more like a condition of employment rather than … entry."
Justice Amy Coney Barrett pressed Harris directly: "I think we agree that the aliens could be removed pursuant to our immigration tradition without an Article III court. But the fines, I'm wondering if they're different." She asked why a visa holder who violated a condition would not be "entitled to an Article III court before the alien had to pay that kind of a fine." Justice Neil Gorsuch added that he thought the Court had held long ago that confiscating property from aliens requires an Article III court: "Are … you resisting that?"
Justice Brett Kavanaugh cited a 40-year-old precedent on civil penalties: "In Tull [v. United States], we said … a civil penalty was a type of remedy at common law that could only be enforced in courts of law. … That's a fairly definitive statement in our precedent. What … are we supposed to do with that?"
Did anyone defend the government's position?
Yes, and with vigor. Justice Elena Kagan found the case comfortably within existing doctrine. "Isn't there a condition of entry here? … They wouldn't be admitted unless the employer had promised certain things," she told Harris. To Robert Johnson, the lawyer for the employer — a different Robert Johnson, not the blues singer — she was blunter:
"This is an admissions case. An employer has gone to the government and said: We're going to make various certifications so that you allow us to bring in a boatload of foreign workers. … I feel that at the base of your argument, Mr. Johnson, you're trying to get us to think that the H-2A program is not an immigration program. But it is an immigration program."
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson offered a parallel defense, emphasizing that the Court has approved administrative adjudication of civil penalties in numerous contexts. She repeatedly challenged Johnson to reconcile his argument with those decisions.
What happens next?
The most ominous sign for the government was repeated questioning of Harris about "the best way for you to lose," in Justice Sonia Sotomayor's words. Even the justices most sympathetic to the arrangement spent the argument helping Harris identify the least damaging route to a ruling against her. Harris warned throughout that a broad constitutional ruling against the government would unsettle programs across Medicare, government contracts, and student loans. The warning gained no visible traction.
How the justices will ultimately line up remains unclear. A significant group appeared to view civil penalties as too far removed from the act of entry to fall within the public rights doctrine that protects administrative determinations of admission. Even those justices may not yet know how far they can go — or how far they can go while holding five votes. Expect a late decision and a sharp division.
In plain words: the administrative state's power to fine without a judge may be about to shrink.
via supreme.justia.com (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court to Test Article III Limits in H-2A Labor Dispute
- Supreme Court Divided on Agency Power to Fine: Sun Valley Orchards Case
- Supreme Court to Weigh DOL ALJ Fines in Sun Valley Orchards Case
- Supreme Court Resolves Workplace Arbitration Dispute
- Apple Violated Antitrust Ruling, Federal Judge Finds