Law report No. GLW-5288 · filed November 19, 2026
Regulation & EnforcementReported case
SRA faces Commons scrutiny over ineffective SLAPP regulation
Commons Justice Select Committee witnesses say the SRA has won no censure for misleading pre-action letters or aggressive tactics since the SLAPP debate began.
By Grace Kim4 min read818 words
Holding
- Four witnesses gave evidence at yesterday’s Commons Justice Select Committee hearing.
- Cowper-Coles said the SRA secured no censure for a misleading pre-action letter or aggressive tactic since the SLAPP debate began.
- One investigated case involved a threat that the solicitor’s own barrister likened to blackmail, with no consequences.
- Sarah Russell MP proposed an ethical rule on proportionality of correspondence.
- The SRA’s access to privileged material remains subject to ongoing litigation.

By Grace Kim
At yesterday's UK Commons Justice Select Committee hearing, lawyer Rupert Cowper-Coles said the Solicitors Regulation Authority had won no censure for a misleading pre-action letter or aggressive tactic since the SLAPP debate began. The session addressed so-called strategic litigation against public participation, known as SLAPPs. It was an evidence hearing, not a judicial ruling or an SRA decision.
What did the Commons hearing examine?
The committee took evidence from campaigners and lawyers about the use of legal threats to stop victims of sexual violence from speaking publicly about their experience. Four witnesses appeared. Verity Nevitt co-founded The Gemini Project, a nonprofit organisation working to end sexual violence. Harriet Wistrich is chief executive of Centre for Women’s Justice. Cowper-Coles is a partner at international firm RPC. Jennifer Robinson is a barrister at Doughty Street Chambers.
Takeaway: The session concerned evidence on SLAPP regulation rather than a new legal ruling.
Why did a survivor describe SLAPP exposure as coercive?
Nevitt said she had faced a SLAPP after accusing someone of sexual assault. She told the committee: “When you experience rape or sexual assault, choice is taken from you and being subject to a SLAPP replicates those dynamics.”
She said the legal merit of a strategic claim does not always come into play. Such litigation can exhaust a defendant emotionally and financially long before trial, where the defendant may deploy a defence of truth and public interest. The process can then become a test of whether the defendant can withstand it.
In her account, the defendant must engage in proceedings or settle because of costs. The claim then reverses the roles: the alleged perpetrator appears as the victim of wrongdoing, while the victim-survivor becomes the defendant and aggressor. Nevitt called the result an egregious reversal of reality and the ultimate form of gaslighting.
Takeaway: The committee heard that SLAPP exposure may burden survivors through cost and delay even when the underlying claim has little merit.
What reforms did the witnesses seek?
Cowper-Coles said the SRA had tried to regulate the area more vigilantly, but almost every case had failed and exposed gaps in the law. One investigated matter involved a solicitor taking an action that the solicitor’s own barrister likened to blackmail. The threat proceeded, and there were no consequences.
He then said: “The SRA have, frankly, got a bloody nose from the way they have tried to respond to SLAPPs. Without reform, solicitors at the moment can be part of the problem.”
He proposed a minimum duty of due diligence before litigation. Solicitors should examine the client’s case and underlying truth, then satisfy themselves that instructions for libel proceedings are accurate.
MP Sarah Russell suggested an ethical rule for solicitors and barristers on the proportionality of correspondence. She asked whether such a rule would prove too demanding or unworkable. Cowper-Coles backed procedural reform that would deliver a quicker, more proportionate process and penalise document dumping.
Takeaway: The proposed response combines pre-filing checks, limits on correspondence and proportionate procedure rather than enforcement after complaint alone.
Has the duty to the court closed the gap?
Cowper-Coles also invoked lawyers’ paramount duty to the court and their duty not to take unfair advantage. He said the interpretation of those duties had not led to any censure of even one misleading pre-action letter, aggressive tactic or similar conduct since the SLAPP debate began.
The committee also discussed the SRA’s access to privileged material, a dispute now in ongoing litigation. Cowper-Coles called privilege a fundamental right. He said solicitors need to know their correspondence could be seen by a regulator, because without that awareness bad conduct will flourish.
He asked the Law Commission and Parliament to examine the issue. In his view, if nobody could look behind privilege even in the worst cases, poor conduct would remain uncaptured and systemic breaches of the rules would not come to light.
Takeaway: Existing duties have not produced visible censure, while privilege rules constrain how closely the SRA can test misconduct.
What does this mean for practitioners?
For practitioners, the immediate consequence is uncertainty rather than a new code rule. Cowper-Coles’s model calls for pre-action checks of the client’s case and truth. Russell’s proposal would make correspondence proportionality a subject for an ethical rule. Neither emerged as an adopted reform at the hearing.
The existing duties to the court and against unfair advantage remain the stated legal baseline. Privilege continues to constrain what the SRA can examine, and the dispute over that access remains tied to ongoing litigation. The practical lesson is to test the factual basis and proportionality before acting, while recognising that this reflects the witnesses’ proposals rather than a new binding rule.
Takeaway: The evidence sets out a reform test for lawyers while leaving current regulation and privilege arrangements intact.
via lawgazette.co.uk (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
336 articles