Law report No. GLW-5089 · filed November 19, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Second Circuit Weighs Whether BNY Mellon Owes Epstein Victims $380 Million
A Jane Doe plaintiff urged the Second Circuit to revive a class action against BNY Mellon for processing nearly $380 million in payments tied to Jeffrey Epstein's sex-trafficking operation.
By Marcus Bennett4 min read726 words
Holding
- A 2025 class action accuses BNY Mellon of processing nearly $380 million in payments to Epstein trafficking victims.
- A lower court dismissed the suit for lack of a sufficient nexus to Epstein's scheme.
- Bank of America settled with Epstein victims for $72.5 million earlier this year; JPMorgan settled for $290 million and Deutsche Bank for $75 million.
- The plaintiff says Epstein sexually abused her at least 100 times between 2011 and 2019.
- The three-judge panel — Wesley, Cabranes and Robinson — took the case under submission after a half-hour hearing.
A Jane Doe plaintiff asked the Second Circuit on Wednesday to revive a class action against The Bank of New York Mellon for processing nearly $380 million in payments tied to Jeffrey Epstein's sex-trafficking operation. The Manhattan-based appeals court heard the case but issued no immediate ruling after a half-hour argument before a three-judge panel.
The suit, filed in 2025, stands apart from the wave of Epstein-related civil claims that ended in nine-figure settlements. Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase and Deutsche Bank each paid Epstein victims hundreds of millions of dollars to resolve parallel cases. A federal judge in Manhattan approved a $72.5 million settlement package from Bank of America earlier this year. BNY Mellon, by contrast, won dismissal from a lower-court judge who found the bank lacked a "sufficient nexus" to Epstein's scheme.
Why is this case different from the settled bank suits?
The distinction is the banking relationship itself. In the JPMorgan and Bank of America cases, the banks served Epstein directly. BNY Mellon acted as a correspondent bank — an intermediary institution that processes transactions on behalf of other banks.
Sigrid McCawley of Boies Schiller Flexner, representing Doe, conceded the difference from the bench. "It is different from the other cases that we had against JP Morgan and Bank of America, where there was a direct banking relationship with Jeffrey Epstein," McCawley told the panel. Her firm has represented numerous Epstein victims, including Virginia Roberts Giuffre, who died by suicide last year.
McCawley argued that BNY Mellon knew — or should have known — about Epstein's crimes. She pointed to obligations such as Know Your Customer rules, which she said put the onus on the bank to conduct due diligence.
U.S. Circuit Judge Richard Wesley, a George W. Bush appointee, pressed back. "Mr. Epstein, or Epstein's entities, weren't their customer," he said. "Their customer was a bank that was doing business with Mr. Epstein."
Wesley noted that the transactions BNY Mellon processed ran through Deutsche Bank, which held Epstein as a customer. He warned that liability on these facts could have "broad-ranging" effects.
"I've seen this on several terrorism cases," Wesley said. "Generally, the correspondent bank has to have knowledge of or information about that banking relationship between customer and respondent bank before the correspondent bank somehow is cast into a responsibility to know."
What does the plaintiff allege BNY Mellon did?
Doe, now a Florida resident, says she met Epstein in 2011 while living in Russia. She alleges Epstein sexually abused her at least 100 times between 2011 and 2019. She claims financial institutions, BNY Mellon among them, perpetuated that abuse by overlooking red flags of his criminality.
Her complaint levels two specific allegations:
- BNY Mellon extended a line of credit to MC2, the sham modeling agency Epstein used to recruit victims of his sex-trafficking venture.
- The bank failed to file required Suspicious Activity Reports despite purportedly knowing of Epstein's crimes.
Doe and other victims won major settlements from other banks on that same theory. The Bank of America settlement resolved claims that the bank "purposely and deliberately" failed to file reports on Epstein's suspicious banking activities until after his jailhouse death in 2019.
How did BNY Mellon respond?
Felicia Ellsworth of WilmerHale argued for the bank that its conduct fell far short of participation in Epstein's schemes. She described the transactions as "arm's length banking transactions" and said they were insufficient to show true involvement.
"This is at least one step, if not two steps removed from the type of direct knowledge that has been found sufficient at [this] stage," Ellsworth told the panel.
BNY Mellon has repeatedly insisted it had no involvement in Epstein's schemes.
What happens next?
U.S. Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes, a Bill Clinton appointee, and U.S. Circuit Judge Beth Robinson, a Joe Biden appointee, rounded out the panel alongside Wesley. The court took the appeal under submission.
For practitioners, the ruling will test how far trafficking-related liability can travel down the payment chain. A reversal would extend duty-of-monitoring exposure to correspondent banks with no direct customer relationship. An affirmance would cabin liability to institutions that banked Epstein himself, drawing a line between the banks that settled and intermediaries further removed from his operation.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
337 articles
Also before the court
- Supreme Court to Decide When Bankruptcy Courts Can Refuse Arbitration
- Court of Appeal Quashes LIBOR Convictions of Five Ex-Barclays Traders
- Block's Proposed $764 Million DOJ Settlement Outstrips Quarterly Profit
- Mediation Fails in Fastcase-Alexi Legal Data Dispute
- Bank of America Faces $1.2 Billion Penalty Over Money Laundering Lapses