Law report No. GLW-3634 · filed November 17, 2026

ArbitrationReported case

SDNY Judge Ho Denies Russia's Bid to Move $1B Award Fight to DC

Judge Dale Ho denied Russia's motion to transfer Oschadbank's $1 billion arbitral award enforcement suit, holding venue was proper in the SDNY and the DDC was not a permissible transferee forum.

By Grace Kim4 min read805 words

Holding

  1. Judge Dale Ho of the SDNY denied Russia's transfer motion in JSC Oschadbank v. Russian Federation, a suit to enforce an award exceeding $1 billion.
  2. The award stems from Russia's 2014 annexation of Crimea, when Oschadbank claims Russia seized over $1 billion in assets.
  3. The ruling rests on a DC Circuit–Second Circuit split over the FSIA arbitral award exception, 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(6).
  4. The court held that removal under 28 U.S.C. § 1441, not § 1391, governs venue for cases removed from state court.
Venue Transfer and FSIA Circuit Splits
PlateVenue Transfer and FSIA Circuit Splits — crystal710 / pixabay

Judge Dale Ho of the Southern District of New York has denied Russia's motion to transfer a suit by Ukraine's state-owned Oschadbank seeking enforcement of an arbitral award worth over $1 billion. The decision, issued in JSC Oschadbank v. Russian Federation, rejected transfer under both 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) and § 1406, and it turns on a live circuit split over the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act.

What is the case about?

Oschadbank is wholly owned by the Ukrainian state. It claims Russia seized more than $1 billion of its assets when Russia annexed Crimea in 2014. A tribunal administered by the Permanent Court of Arbitration issued an award against Russia exceeding $1 billion in damages. Russia sought annulment in French court and lost. Oschadbank maintains the resulting French judgment effectively confirms the award.

The bank then pursued two parallel enforcement tracks in the United States:

  • A suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, invoking the FSIA's arbitral award exception, 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(6).
  • A separate suit in New York state court, seeking recognition of the French judgment under New York's Uniform Foreign Country Money Judgments Act.

The dual filing was strategic. The DC Circuit reads the FSIA's arbitral award exception as covering only arbitral awards, not foreign judgments recognizing them. The Second Circuit reads the exception more broadly to encompass such foreign judgments. Russia removed the state case to the SDNY and moved to transfer it to the DDC.

Why was venue proper in the SDNY?

The first question in any transfer motion is whether venue is proper in the filing court. Russia argued that 28 U.S.C. § 1391(f), which governs venue for actions against foreign states, permits venue only in the DDC. Judge Ho disagreed.

When a case is removed from state court, § 1391 is displaced by the removal statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1441. Section 1441(a) directs removal "to the district court of the United States for the district and division embracing the place where such action is pending." Section 1441(d) confirms that this directive applies when a foreign state removes an action against it. Judge Ho also noted that § 1391 by its terms governs actions "brought in the district courts of the United States"—language that does not reach cases filed in state court. Venue was therefore proper in the SDNY, and the § 1406 transfer request failed.

The takeaway: a foreign state that removes a state court case to federal court cannot then argue the general venue statute channels the case to another district.

What does the ruling change for § 1404(a)?

The second question is whether the case "might have been brought" in the transferee court—here, the DDC. That inquiry became difficult because of the FSIA circuit split.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1330(a), subject-matter jurisdiction over a foreign sovereign exists only if an FSIA exception applies. Once an exception applies, personal jurisdiction follows under § 1330(b). Had Oschadbank filed in the DDC, that court would have been bound by DC Circuit precedent holding the FSIA arbitral award exception inapplicable to a foreign judgment. It would have dismissed for lack of both subject-matter and personal jurisdiction.

Judge Ho held the DDC was therefore not a district where the suit "might have been brought," and he denied the § 1404(a) motion on that ground. The ruling sits at the intersection of transfer doctrine and the Van Dusen v. Barrack (1964) and Ferens v. John Deere Co. (1990) line of cases. Those decisions hold that diversity-based transfers carry the transferor's state law with them. Most courts agree that federal-question transfers work differently: the transferee court may follow its own circuit precedent because, in theory, all circuits apply the same federal law.

But here the difference in circuit precedent would have determined whether jurisdiction existed at all. The court declined to transfer the case to what Judge Ho's ruling effectively treats as its certain death in the DDC.

The takeaway for practitioners: where a circuit split on a jurisdictional statute means the transferee court would lack jurisdiction, the "might have been brought" requirement of § 1404(a) blocks the transfer outright, without any need to weigh convenience.

What are the open questions?

The opinion leaves room for debate. A simpler route, as commentary on the decision notes, would have been for the court to exercise its § 1404(a) discretion and decline transfer as not "in the interest of justice," regardless of whether transfer was theoretically available. Arguments exist on both sides of the jurisdictional holding. For enforcement counsel, the decision confirms a practical rule: file where your circuit's FSIA precedent favors you, and a foreign sovereign's removal plus transfer motion will not strip that choice away.

via tlblog.org (Source)

Filed under

  • arbitral-award-enforcement
  • foreign-sovereign-immunities-act
  • foreign-judgments
  • case-transfer
  • ukraine-russia
Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

320 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »