Law report No. GLW-3099 · filed November 13, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Orissa High Court Denies Custody to Filipino Mother, Orders Daily Video Access
Orissa High Court denied a Filipino mother custody of her Indian daughter, now with paternal grandparents in Jajpur, but ordered daily video calls and in-person visits on her trips to India.
By Amara Osei4 min read802 words
Holding
- Orissa High Court ruled on 13 November 2026 in [2026 LiveLaw (Ori) 126], denying custody to the Filipino mother.
- The child, born November 26, 2023 in Bengaluru, is an Indian citizen holding an Indian passport issued in 2026.
- Bench of Chief Justice Harish Tandon and Justice Chittaranjan Dash relied on Vivek Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of U.P., 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 185.
- Court ordered daily video calls and in-person access during the mother's visits to India.
- Mother works as a kindergarten teacher in Hanoi, Vietnam, and has other children living in the Philippines.

The Orissa High Court has refused custody of a two-year-old Indian girl to her Filipino mother and, in the same breath, ordered that the mother may speak with the child by video call every single day. The ruling, reported on 13 November 2026 and cited as [2026 LiveLaw (Ori) 126], leaves the child with her paternal grandparents in Jajpur, Odisha.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Harish Tandon and Justice Chittaranjan Dash decided the matter as a habeas corpus petition filed by the mother, who sought custody of her daughter. The Bench declined. It granted visiting rights instead, plus daily video interaction, calibrated to the child's routine.
What did the Court decide?
The child is an Indian citizen, born on November 26, 2023 in Bengaluru, and now holds an Indian passport granted earlier this year. The mother is a Philippine citizen who lives and works as a kindergarten teacher in Hanoi, Vietnam. The parents were never married; they lived together in a long-standing live-in relationship that later soured.
The mother left India after authorities denied her an extension of visa. Her daughter remained behind, in the care of the father's parents in Jajpur. The mother alleged that the child receives inadequate care because the father lives in Bengaluru and travels abroad frequently.
The Court weighed the child's circumstances and found for continuity. It observed:
"Undisputedly, the petitioner has other children from the first marriage and the children are staying in Philippines and, therefore, it would not be conducive for the development of the child to stay in another country when she is admittedly the citizen of this country. In Indian society, the grandparents also play a very important role in overall development of a child and it is commonly said that 'they love the grandchild more than their own children'."
That last aphorism did the rhetorical work. The Bench meant it.
On what legal basis?
The Court relied on a line of precedents, including the Supreme Court's decision in Vivek Kumar Chaturvedi & Anr. v. State of U.P. & Ors., 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 185, to hold that a habeas corpus petition is not confined to the bare question of detention. The Court also acts as parens patriae and must decide according to the best interest of the child.
The Bench framed the welfare test in deliberately broad terms:
"It is, thus, no gain saying that the welfare principles are not restricted solely on the physical comfort and/or material advantages but founded upon a variety of factors, viz., general, psychological, spiritual and emotional welfare and above all, what would be the best for a healthy growth, development and education of the child so that she may be prepared to face the vagaries of life as a matured adult."
Applying that standard, the Court noted three facts against transfer of custody: the child is an Indian citizen cared for by her grandparents in India; the mother works in Vietnam; and the mother has other children from an earlier relationship living in the Philippines. Nobody, the Bench reasoned, would mind the child while the mother discharges her professional duties abroad.
What does the ruling order in practice?
On the evidence, the Court found no sign of distress. It held:
"The photographs annexed to the writ petition do not reveal that the child is facing any psychological problem rather appears to be happy in all respects…However, we direct the opposite parties to permit the petitioner to interact with the child every day on video call depending upon the daily routine of the said child and ensuring that neither it causes any discomfort to her nor would disrupt the sleep order. Further, as and when the petitioner visits India, she will be permitted to spend time with the child."
The operative directions are three: daily video calls fitted around the child's routine and sleep, in-person time whenever the mother travels to India, and continued residence with the grandparents. The photographs, in the Court's view, showed a happy child.
For practitioners, the judgment confirms that habeas corpus remains a workable vehicle for cross-border custody disputes in India, but that welfare, not parental entitlement, drives the outcome. Citizenship, stability of care and the practical availability of the petitioner all counted against this mother.
Counsel for the petitioner included Mr. Rajat Kumar Panda, Mr. Pravasha Pujaree Parida, Ms. Kajal Dalal, Ms. Adyasha Das and Mr. Dhananjaya Panda. The State was represented by Ms. Aishwarya Dash, Additional Standing Counsel; Mr. Gautam Mukherji, Senior Advocate, led the private opposite parties' team with Mr. Sreejit Mohanty, Mr. Supralik Acharya, Mr. Sandipan Mohanty and Mr. Sanjivan Mohanty.
The plain takeaway: an Indian court will keep an Indian child in India when the alternative is a household abroad with no daytime carer.
via livelaw.in (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
327 articles
Also before the court
- Gauhati High Court: PAN, voter ID alone cannot prove citizenship
- Gauhati High Court rejects claim over missing family linkage
- Telangana High Court quashes Cyberabad FIR against NRI husband
- Allahabad Ruling Exposes India's Transgender Rape-Law Gap
- Gauhati High Court rejects citizenship claim based on ancestor records