Law report No. GLW-4575 · filed November 15, 2026

Criminal JusticeReported case

Allahabad Ruling Exposes India's Transgender Rape-Law Gap

The Allahabad High Court's 15 October 2026 ruling that "woman" means a female human being exposes a widening gap in India's rewritten criminal law on transgender survivors.

By Amara Osei5 min read913 words

Holding

  1. Allahabad High Court, 15 October 2026: 'woman' in Section 69 BNS covers only a female human being.
  2. Parliament omitted Section 377 IPC when the BNS took effect on 1 July 2024.
  3. Section 18(d) transgender Act carries 6 months–2 years; BNS rape carries a 10-year minimum to life.
  4. Transgender Act amendment narrowing 'transgender person' took force 25 May 2026.
  5. Supreme Court declined to restore Section 377 offences in Pooja Sharma, October 2024.
Recognised By Constitution, Forgotten By Criminal Law? Transgender Protection Gap In India
PlateRecognised By Constitution, Forgotten By Criminal Law? Transgender Protection Gap In India — qimono / pixabay

On 15 October 2026, the Allahabad High Court held that "woman" in Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita covers only a female human being. Justice Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal, in the bail matter Mohd Saakir @ Mohd Sakir v. State of U.P., ruled that a trans woman falls outside the provision even after sex-reassignment surgery. The order was a bail ruling confined to Section 69, not a holding that trans women can never be rape victims under Section 63. It shows the cost of statutory silence all the same: High Courts now give "woman" opposite meanings, and a trans woman's protection depends on where she files her case.

The constitutional architecture points the other way. In National Legal Services Authorities v. Union of India (2014), the Supreme Court upheld the right to self-identified gender and rejected a biological test, holding that gender identity does not depend on surgery. The Madras High Court followed in Arunkumar v. Inspector General of Registration (2019), holding that "bride" under Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act includes a trans woman. In 2025, the Andhra Pradesh High Court reached a similar result in Viswanathan Krishna Murthy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, permitting a trans woman in a heterosexual marriage to invoke the cruelty provision then in Section 498A IPC, now Section 85 BNS. NALSA gives strong grounds to question the reasoning in Mohd Saakir. The split is nonetheless now on the books.

What does Section 63 actually say?

The provision opens: "A man is said to commit 'rape' if he…" It then lists specified acts involving a woman. Section 2(35) defines "woman" as a female human being of any age. Section 2(10) extends the pronoun "he" to male, female and transgender persons, but that drafting rule does not convert "woman" in Section 63 into "person". An adult trans man, or a non-binary adult who does not identify as a woman, has no express route into the definition as a victim. One could argue coverage by treating a trans man as a woman because of his anatomy or sex assigned at birth. That argument protects him only by refusing to recognise him as a man.

What happened to the fallback offence?

Under the Indian Penal Code, Section 377 punished non-consensual sexual acts regardless of the victim's gender. Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018) read it down to decriminalise consensual adult sex while preserving it for non-consensual acts, acts involving minors, and bestiality. The principle was clear: consent, not anatomy, makes the difference. Parliament omitted Section 377 entirely when the BNS took effect on 1 July 2024. The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Home Affairs, in its 246th Report, had warned that the omission would leave non-consensual offences against men and transgender persons unpunished and recommended retention. In Pooja Sharma v. Union of India, petitioners asked the Supreme Court to restore the offences; in October 2024 the Court declined, calling the matter Parliament's domain. Two years on, the gap remains.

Is the transgender statute an answer?

Section 18(d) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 punishes harm or abuse of a transgender person, including sexual abuse, with six months to two years and a fine. Rape under Section 64(1) BNS carries a minimum of ten years' rigorous imprisonment, extendable to life. Section 18(d) lumps sexual abuse together with verbal, emotional and economic abuse. Raping a trans woman and insulting her carry the same maximum punishment. That sentence deserves to be read twice.

The 2026 Amendment Act, in force since 25 May 2026, narrows the definition of "transgender person" under Section 2(k) to listed socio-cultural identities such as kinner and hijra, certain congenital sex variations, and persons compelled to assume a transgender identity. It excludes self-perceived sexual identities. A person shut out of the rape provision for not being a woman may also be shut out of the special statute for not being transgender. The validity of that narrowing is now before the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan Tripathi v. Union of India.

Why does protection stop at eighteen?

Under POCSO 2012, a child is any person below eighteen, and Section 3 defines penetrative sexual assault without limiting victims to girls. On turning eighteen, a survivor outside the category of "woman" loses that coverage and gains nothing equivalent. The break extends beyond charges. Section 397 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita obliges every hospital to give immediate free treatment to victims of listed offences, including rape and penetrative assault under POCSO. Section 18(d) is not on the list.

What would reform look like?

Article 14 permits differential treatment only where the difference serves the law's purpose; gender has no bearing on whether sexual autonomy was violated. Article 15(3) permits special provisions for women, but a power to protect women is not a duty to exclude everyone else. The Justice J.S. Verma Committee recommended in January 2013 that rape law be gender-neutral for victims and gender-specific for perpetrators. Two routes exist: amend Section 63 to define the victim as "another person", or enact a separate offence of penetrative sexual assault on any adult with the same punishments. Courts cannot stretch a criminal offence beyond its words. Parliament must close the gap expressly, with transgender communities at the drafting table. A survivor should not have to surrender recognition of themselves to obtain recognition of the violence.

via livelaw.in (Source)

Filed under

  • transgender-rights
  • rape-law
  • bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita
  • allahabad-high-court
  • gender-neutral-criminal-law
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

327 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »