Law report No. GLW-4845 · filed November 13, 2026
Antitrust & CompetitionReported case
NYC Defends Mamdani Grocery Plan Against Antitrust Challenge
New York City urged Judge Jennifer Rochon to deny grocers' bid to halt Mamdani's city-run discount supermarkets, calling the five-store, $70 million program 'complementary' to private retailers.
By Grace Kim3 min read685 words
Holding
- The city defended the program before U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon (SDNY) on Thursday; she did not rule on the preliminary injunction from the bench.
- The National Supermarket Association sued in September under Sherman Act Section 2, claiming predatory pricing.
- The city has committed $70 million for five stores with a guaranteed 30% discount on Core Basket staples.
- Mamdani projects $90 monthly savings per family, over $1,000 annually.
- A second, class action challenge by the Multicultural Business Coalition was filed in August in Manhattan Supreme Court.

New York City asked a Manhattan federal judge on Thursday to reject a preliminary injunction against Mayor Zohran Mamdani's municipal grocery store program, telling the court the tax-financed stores cannot antitrust-injure the grocers suing to stop them.
Attorneys for the city argued before U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon of the Southern District of New York, a Joe Biden appointee, that the plaintiffs lack irreparable harm. The coalition of large independent grocers, led by the National Supermarket Association, sued the city in September under Section 2 of the Sherman Act, alleging attempted monopolization and conspiracy to monopolize through predatory pricing. The plaintiffs want the court to halt the city's selection of a private operator to manage daily operations while the litigation proceeds.
Rochon did not rule from the bench.
What did the city tell the court?
The city framed the program as a consumer-welfare measure designed to improve affordability, not to harm consumers or competitors. Daniel Kuo Crandall, a lawyer in the city Law Department's commercial and real estate litigation division, told the court the stores are designed to coexist with private retailers.
"The program is intended to be complementary to existing food retailers, not to replace existing food retailers," Crandall said during oral arguments.
The city also pushed back on the framing of public-sector competition as a threat. "Competition between the public and private sector can still benefit consumers and still be the type of competition that is supposed to be protected by the antitrust laws, and certainly should not be inhibited by any of the antitrust laws," Crandall said.
The city noted the five planned stores will not carry deli counters, butcher counters or other specialty items that private grocers stock, and it will encourage New Yorkers to keep shopping at local retailers for freshly prepared food. An injunction delaying the first two stores, Crandall argued, would instead cause concrete and definite harm to food-insecure and lower-income New Yorkers.
The takeaway: the city's defense rests on consumer benefit and market complementarity, not on denying the stores will compete at all.
What are the plaintiffs claiming?
Richard Lawson, arguing for the plaintiffs from the America First Policy Institute, said the city's mandated discount violates the predatory pricing provisions of federal antitrust law, which exist to protect marketplace competition. The plaintiffs call Mamdani's plan an "unprecedented" risk of anticompetitive monopolization that will drive unsubsidized local grocers out of business.
The National Supermarket Association says roughly 20 existing grocery stores sit close enough to the Hunts Point site in the Bronx to be affected, while 26 existing businesses are in range of the East Harlem location.
What is actually being built?
The numbers behind the dispute are concrete:
- Mamdani announced in July that the "Core Basket" of staples covered by a guaranteed 30% discount will include all fresh produce, meat and seafood, plus 20 other essential items such as cheese, milk and bread.
- The city has committed $70 million in municipal capital funding for construction and fit-out of five stores.
- Mamdani has said families shopping at the city's markets would save an estimated $90 per month on groceries, more than $1,000 annually.
- The first two stores are planned for East Harlem and Hunts Point. The Bronx store, a redevelopment of the former Spofford Juvenile Detention Facility site, is targeted to open first sometime next year, with a goal of no later than the end of 2027.
City-owned grocery stores were a signature promise of Mamdani's historic 2025 mayoral campaign. Mamdani is a self-described democratic socialist.
Is this the only lawsuit?
No. The Multicultural Business Coalition, representing owners of smaller grocery stores and bodega corner stores, filed a class action in August in Manhattan Supreme Court raising similar claims about the plan's effects on competitors.
For antitrust practitioners, the case tests whether a government entity selling subsidized goods at mandated discounts can face Sherman Act Section 2 liability, and what showing of irreparable harm private competitors must make against a municipal program still in its operator-selection phase.
via Courthouse News (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
320 articles
Also before the court
- Appellate Court Rejects NYC Greenwashing Claims Against Oil Majors
- Apple Wins Transfer of Rave Antitrust Suit to California Federal Court
- Passengers Sue Seven Airlines Over Alleged Price-Sharing Pact
- Google Must Face Consumer Antitrust Suit Over Search, US Judge Rules
- Court Dismisses Antitrust Claims Against Google Over Publisher Harm