Law report No. GLW-5950 · filed November 17, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

EU Court Rejects Kerry's Bid to Save Three Smoke Flavorings

The EU General Court dismissed Kerry's challenge to the refusal to renew three smoke flavorings, placing the burden of proving safety squarely on the applicant until the July 2029 deadline.

By Amara Osei5 min read903 words

Holding

  1. The EU General Court dismissed Kerry's challenge on Wednesday, upholding the Commission's July 2024 refusal to renew three smoke flavorings.
  2. Kerry's three products — SmokEz C-10, SmokEz Enviro-23 and Zesti Smoke Code 10 — may remain on the EU market until July 1, 2029.
  3. Kerry must pay its own costs and the Commission's, and can appeal to the Court of Justice within two months and 10 days.
  4. EFSA's 2023 reassessment of eight flavorings found DNA-damage concerns in six; EU approvals last 10 years.
Smoke flavorings succumb to EU grilling
PlateSmoke flavorings succumb to EU grilling — Andrik Langfield / unsplash

The General Court of the European Union on Wednesday dismissed Kerry's challenge to European Commission decisions refusing renewal of three smoke flavorings and removing them from the EU's authorized list. The Wisconsin- and U.K.-based ingredients supplier must now prepare for the products' exit, with its three primary flavorings permitted on the market only until July 1, 2029.

The ruling, in Kerry Inc. v European Commission, delivers a plain message: a smoky taste is no substitute for proof of safety. The court held that responsibility for demonstrating safety rested with Kerry. Regulators did not have to prove that consumers had already been harmed.

What did the safety assessment find?

Smoke flavorings deliver taste without the smoker. Made from processed wood smoke, they lend a smoky flavor to foods such as cheese, chips and sauces — including foods never traditionally smoked.

The European Food Safety Authority identified two ingredients shown in oral-exposure tests to damage DNA, the genetic material inside cells. It then estimated consumer exposure from food. Those amounts exceeded a reference level for low health concerns. The court found the authority had properly examined both exposure and the ingredients' potential to cause harm.

When EFSA reassessed eight flavorings in 2023, it identified DNA-damage concerns in six and lacked sufficient information to rule out concerns for the remaining two. The Commission refused renewals in July 2024, granting businesses transition periods to adapt recipes and production.

Why did Kerry lose?

Kerry argued that examining ingredients separately misses what happens when they are mixed together, and that regulators overlooked tests of the finished products. The court found EFSA had considered those studies but had explained why they did not resolve its concerns.

The operative language is withering in its economy. The court wrote: "It must be noted that the existence of a scientific debate on the best methodology to be applied is not a sufficient ground to make the methodology used by EFSA in its opinions implausible." Kerry had not demonstrated sufficient scientific agreement that the authority's approach should be abandoned.

The company also argued that restrictions could push manufacturers back toward potentially riskier traditional smoking. The court found Kerry had not demonstrated such a shift would occur. Even if it did, that would not justify approving flavorings whose safety had not been established. Transition periods, the court noted, addressed the economic consequences.

What does the ruling change for practitioners?

Three points matter for food-law practice. First, the burden of proof under EU renewal procedures sits squarely with the applicant; years on the market confer no presumption of safety, since permissions last 10 years and renewal requires evidence updated to scientific advances. Kerry applied in June 2022 and supplied more data the following February, and it was still not enough. Second, challenger companies must bring a validated alternative methodology to displace EFSA's assessment — mere methodological disagreement will not carry the day. Third, the court scrutinized the science closely while leaving regulators considerable freedom on technical questions, a balance that practitioners should note when framing annulment actions. The takeaway: safety proof belongs to the seller, not the regulator.

What do the experts say?

Bernd van der Meulen, director and food law specialist at the European Institute for Food Law, found the ruling convincing. He highlighted the depth of the court's scientific examination despite the deference to regulators. He also welcomed the absence of any reference to the precautionary principle — taking protective action when risks remain uncertain — because he considered the scientific findings and Kerry's burden of proof sufficient.

Natacha Cingotti, campaign strategy lead on consumer protection at foodwatch international, said the organization had welcomed that precautionary approach. She wanted similar caution applied more often to flavorings and additives, arguing that too many substances raising health concerns remain permitted in food.

Alie de Boer, associate professor in nutrition and food information at Maastricht University, saw a possible missed opportunity to compare the risks of alternatives, though she understood the legal reasoning. Considering a company's evidence, she stressed, does not mean accepting its conclusions. The court's acceptance of EFSA's assumption that DNA-damaging substances have no safe exposure threshold made scientific uncertainty especially important, while its rejection of Kerry's alternative method showed how hard it is to challenge established science without a validated approach.

Luca Knuth, an EU law researcher at Maastricht University and Kiel University, considered the approach defensible on public documents and a brief reading of the judgment. Regulators' scientific freedom, he stressed, still requires meaningful court scrutiny. Choices about handling uncertainty need clear, scientifically sound explanations.

What happens next?

The Commission defended its position, saying the judgment confirmed the basis for its July 2024 refusal to renew approvals for eight smoke flavorings, including Kerry's three — SmokEz C-10, SmokEz Enviro-23 and Zesti Smoke Code 10.

Kerry expressed disappointment but stood by its science. It maintained that extensive data supported safe use and would review the judgment alongside its concerns about the assessment. To customers, however, the message was blunt: keep preparing for removal. "Our focus is on supporting customers through this transition," Kerry said.

The court ordered Kerry to pay its own costs and the Commission's. The company can appeal to the Court of Justice within two months and 10 days of notification, but only on legal grounds. The refusals stand, and the clock runs to July 1, 2029.

via efsa.europa.eu (Original)

Filed under

  • eu-general-court
  • efsa
  • food-safety
  • smoke-flavorings
  • kerry
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

327 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »