Law report No. GLW-8891 · filed November 11, 2026

Courts & TribunalsReported case

Delhi High Court Blocks US Copyright Suit Over Weather Footage

Delhi High Court restrained a US copyright suit against TV Today over 42 videos, calling the California case vexatious and affirming India as the proper forum.

By Sophie Lindqvist4 min read743 words

Holding

  1. Delhi High Court (Justice Tejas Karia) restrained US proceedings against TV Today Network, reported 11 November 2026.
  2. The US suit before the Northern District of California concerns 42 videos and was filed in March.
  3. The court relied on Section 52(1)(a)(iii) fair dealing for brief weather footage extracts.
  4. Anti-suit injunction also blocks any future foreign proceedings on the same subject matter.
Delhi High Court Restrains US Copyright Suit Against TV Today Network Over Weather Footage In News Reports
PlateDelhi High Court Restrains US Copyright Suit Against TV Today Network Over Weather Footage In News Reports — succo / pixabay

The Delhi High Court has restrained a US-based entity and several individuals from pursuing copyright infringement proceedings against TV Today Network before a United States court. Justice Tejas Karia ruled on an interim application that the foreign suit was, prima facie, vexatious and oppressive, because the dispute concerns news videos created and published in India for Indian audiences.

The order, passed on 11 November 2026, bars the defendants, their agents and representatives from continuing the case pending before the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. It also blocks them from instituting any suit, application or proceeding before any court or authority outside India on the same subject matter.

Why did the court act?

The court held that the Delhi High Court is the appropriate forum for the dispute. The copyright claims concern videos scripted, edited, compiled and uploaded from India. TV Today has no business presence in the United States.

The court warned of a real procedural hazard. Allowing the US proceedings to continue would subject TV Today's conduct in India to foreign law while the same dispute awaits adjudication before Indian courts, creating a genuine risk of conflicting decisions.

"The US Suit is, prima facie, vexatious and oppressive: the Plaintiff has no US business, and the Subject Videos were prepared and published in India for Indian audiences," the court observed.

What is the dispute about?

TV Today Network Limited operates news channels including Aaj Tak, Aaj Tak HD, India Today Television and Good News Today. It sought a declaration that its use of certain weather-related footage in news broadcasts did not infringe copyright under the Copyright Act, 1957. It also sought protection against groundless threats under Section 60 of the Act, plus an anti-suit injunction (a court order stopping a party from litigating in another jurisdiction).

The trouble began in March, when the defendants lodged copyright complaints over weather footage used in the broadcaster's YouTube news reports. YouTube then disabled access to certain videos. TV Today filed counter-notifications seeking restoration. Instead of accepting that outcome, the defendants sued in the US District Court in March, alleging copyright infringement, removal of copyright management information and related claims concerning 42 videos.

The broadcaster argued that its videos contained its own narration, reporting, commentary, graphics and editorial content. It also contended that the jurisdiction clause in the counter-notifications was a standard-form condition imposed by YouTube for contesting takedowns, not a negotiated agreement to submit all copyright disputes to US jurisdiction.

What does the ruling mean for fair dealing?

On the infringement allegations, the court leaned on its own precedent. In Associated Broadcasting Company Limited v. Google LLC and Others, the High Court held that weather footage depicting natural events comprises universal, non-imaginative and generic facts. Brief, segmented extracts of such footage, incorporated into news narration and commentary, could amount to fair dealing (the Indian statutory equivalent of fair use) under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act, 1957.

The court noted that the record showed the defendants' recordings were used only for a few seconds in weather reports. They were not presented as independent content or as substitutes for the original recordings.

The defendants did not file a reply or appear, despite being duly served. That absence made the interim assessment one-sided on paper, though the court proceeded on the merits of the application before it.

What is the practical takeaway for practitioners?

The ruling strengthens two tools for Indian media companies facing overseas takedown disputes. First, boilerplate jurisdiction clauses inside platform counter-notification forms will not automatically lock a party into foreign courts; the court treated them as conditions of using YouTube's process, not as a negotiated choice of forum. Second, content creators who script, edit and publish from India can resist parallel US litigation on forum grounds, even where the platform's own procedures route disputes abroad.

The court applied the standard three-part interim test. It found TV Today had established a prima facie case, that the balance of convenience favoured it, and that refusal of interim protection could cause irreparable harm. The application was allowed on that basis.

One caution applies. The court expressly clarified that its observations were prima facie in nature and would not constitute a final opinion on the merits of the suit. The substantive declaration, and any final ruling on the Section 60 groundless-threats claim, remain to be decided.

via livelaw.in (Source)

Filed under

  • delhi-high-court
  • tv-today-network
  • copyright-infringement
  • anti-suit-injunction
  • fair-dealing
Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.

333 articles

Also before the court

« Previous articleNext article »