Law report No. GLW-3711 · filed November 18, 2026
Courts & TribunalsReported case
Court of Appeal opens door to challenge over Mariana dam litigation control
Court of Appeal grants a claimant committee permission to appeal on all grounds over who controls the Mariana dam litigation, involving 442,000 claimants.
By Grace Kim4 min read713 words
Holding
- Court of Appeal granted permission to appeal on all grounds on the day of a half-day hearing
- The claimant committee represents around 442,000 claimants in the Mariana dam litigation
- Mr Justice Waksman's October High Court judgment had ruled for Pogust Goodhead
- The appeal will be expedited and is likely to be heard near the beginning of next term
- The phase 2 quantum trial remains listed for next April

The Court of Appeal has granted permission to appeal on all grounds in the fight over control of the Mariana dam disaster litigation. Lord Justice Fraser and Lord Justice Meade ruled today that the challenge to Mr Justice Waksman's October High Court judgment has a 'reasonable prospect of success'.
Who decided, and what exactly?
Two Court of Appeal judges, sitting in London, delivered the ruling orally after a half-day hearing. They granted permission to appeal on all three grounds advanced by a claimant committee. The committee, 16 members strong, represents around 442,000 claimants in the litigation over Brazil's worst environmental disaster. Thirteen of those 16 members pursued the appeal after the High Court ruled in October that the committee lacked authority to remove class action firm Pogust Goodhead from the claim.
The appeal itself has no fixed date. The court indicated it will be expedited, with a hearing likely near the beginning of next term.
What is the dispute about?
At stake is who controls the ongoing Mariana dam litigation: Pogust Goodhead, now renamed PGMBM, or rival firm Bailey Glasser International (BGI). The committee voted to terminate Pogust Goodhead's role. Mr Justice Waksman found in October that the committee did not have the authority to do so, ruling for Pogust Goodhead in its battle with BGI.
The committee's concerns centred on Pogust Goodhead's main funder, Gramercy. Sa'ad Hossain KC, appearing for the committee members, told the court the committee was worried about Gramercy 'and its control over' the firm. He also cited 'the dismissal of certain barristers and solicitors from the claim'. 'Those were concerns that led to the cure notice being sent and, eventually, termination,' Hossain said.
What are the three grounds of appeal?
The committee argues:
- Mr Justice Waksman was wrong to reason that the committee lacked the requisite authority;
- the committee had authority to terminate both the collective conditional fee agreement and the litigation management agreement, and the judge erred in concluding it lacked that authority 'as a matter of construction';
- the committee had authority to instruct BGI, and the judge erred in finding it lacked the authority to do so.
What did each side argue?
In oral submissions, Hossain pressed the consumer-protection point directly: 'Clearly it is more favourable to the consumer to have an effective right of informed termination rather than an ineffective one.'
In written submissions, he went further. He argued that the result of Mr Justice Waksman's decision is that the collective conditional fee agreement clients are, 'as a matter of commercial reality', locked in to using Pogust Goodhead, with no effective means of changing solicitor even when the committee, 'as the only body appointed to act on their behalf in the Mariana litigation and vis-à-vis PG, genuinely considers that there is cause to do so'. Such an outcome, he submitted, is 'contrary to the language and scheme of the agreements granting authority to the committee'.
Alan Maclean, for Pogust Goodhead, defended the October ruling. 'The client care letter is entirely in keeping with the structure of the CFA,' he told the court. He argued the committee does not have 'an ultimate power to change the agreement'. In written submissions, he urged that permission be refused 'because…each of the proposed grounds of appeal is hopeless', adding that 'the judge was plainly right for the reasons set out in his carefully reasoned and detailed judgment'.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
For now, nothing is decided on the merits. But the grant of permission on all grounds signals that the Court of Appeal sees real force in the committee's construction arguments. Funders and firms running collective conditional fee agreements should watch closely. The appeal will test whether representative committees can effectively switch solicitors mid-claim, and what 'informed termination' means for mass claimants in practice. A finding for the committee could reshape exit rights across funded group litigation.
Is the main trial affected?
No. The substantive hearing, the phase 2 trial dealing with quantum, is unaffected by these proceedings. That trial remains listed for next April.
The bottom line: control of one of the UK's largest group actions will now be settled by the Court of Appeal, on an expedited basis.
via lawgazette.co.uk (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
325 articles
Also before the court
- Pogust Goodhead wins control of Mariana dam litigation
- BHP Loses Bid to Overturn Interest Payment Order in Brazil Dam Case
- MOFCOM Responds to WTO Appeal Arbitration Ruling in China-EU Trade Dispute
- Elder Fails in Appeal Bid Over Genocide Claim Against King Charles
- EU Appeals WTO Ruling in Indonesia Steel Dispute