Law report No. GLW-2324 · filed November 16, 2026
Regulation & EnforcementReported case
ASEAN and China to Back South China Sea Self-Restraint
At Monday's Manila summit, China and ASEAN leaders are expected to pledge South China Sea self-restraint; about 80% of the draft code is agreed, but three issues remain.
By Priya Raman4 min read735 words
Holding
- China and ASEAN leaders were expected to pledge South China Sea self-restraint at Monday's Manila summit.
- About 80% of the draft code's paragraphs were agreed as of Sunday.
- Talks had continued for more than 21 years, with a conclusion targeted this year.
- Three issues remained unresolved: geographic scope, sensitive-term definitions and legal bindingness.
- Negotiations will continue next year under Singapore's ASEAN chairmanship.

About 80% of the paragraphs in a proposed South China Sea code of conduct were already agreed before leaders of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and Chinese Premier Li Qiang met at an annual summit in Manila on Monday, with both sides expected to pledge mutual self-restraint in disputed waters.
The political commitment is narrower than a completed pact.
A draft statement seen by The Associated Press says China and ASEAN leaders will “to exercise self-restraint in the conduct of activities that would complicate or escalate disputes and affect peace and stability.”
Neither side had immediately issued a detailed joint statement, so the wording remained provisional at the time of reporting. Territorial conflicts ranked high on the summit agenda.
What does the pledge cover?
The draft also calls on the parties to welcome progress and maintain an environment conducive to negotiations.
Chinese Premier Li Qiang expressed hope for the early conclusion of a “code of conduct,” according to China’s Xinhua news agency. He said the agreement could help foster peace and stability. Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., who holds ASEAN’s rotational chairmanship, praised progress made this year in negotiations for the regional agreement.
That support carries political weight. It does not resolve the outstanding text.
Nothing final has been signed.
Three questions remain open.
Takeaway: The leaders promise restraint and continued diplomacy, but they have not announced a finished maritime accord.
How far have the negotiations come?
As of Sunday, Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said China and ASEAN had agreed on about 80% of the total paragraphs in the draft, roughly four in five. The figure describes textual agreement, not the practical effect of any code at sea.
Talks about the regional agreement have continued for more than 21 years, or more than two decades. The sides had agreed to conclude negotiations this year, yet three contentious issues remained open.
Singapore takes over ASEAN’s chairmanship next year, when negotiations will continue. The chairmanship change does not by itself settle the disagreements.
Most of the text is agreed.
The hard parts remain.
Takeaway: Negotiators have substantial agreement on wording, but the agreement remains unfinished.
Which legal questions remain unresolved?
Southeast Asian diplomats identified three main sticking points: the geographic scope of the agreement, the definition of sensitive terms, and whether the accord should be legally binding.
The first determines where the code applies. The second raises the question of which language or activities the restraint commitment covers. The third goes to legal force, and to whether the document imposes obligations rather than expressing political expectations.
The reported language sets out no compliance mechanism. It also leaves unanswered how the parties would respond if the restraint commitment came under strain.
The wider stakes explain why the legal questions matter. The South China Sea is a busy waterway and a key global trade route, where China, Taiwan and four ASEAN states—Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam—have been involved in decades-long territorial standoffs. Confrontations between Chinese and Philippine coast guard and naval forces at disputed shoals have escalated in recent years.
The disputes have raised concern that a major conflict could draw in the United States. Washington makes no claim to the waters but has warned that it is obligated to defend the Philippines, a longtime treaty ally, if Filipino forces come under an armed attack.
That warning raises the cost of a major flare-up. It does not convert Monday’s restraint pledge into an operational protocol.
Takeaway: Geographic reach, terminology and legal status will determine whether the pledge changes conduct.
What does the pledge mean for practitioners?
For lawyers advising on maritime and trade disputes, Monday’s statement is a political signal rather than an enforceable settlement. It supplies a restraint commitment, but leaves open the terms that would determine its reach.
The reported text sets out no new compliance duties and no dispute-resolution process. Those points will require attention if the draft becomes a final code and if the parties decide to make it legally binding.
Practitioners should track three items: geographic scope, the treatment of sensitive terms, and whether the final text carries legal obligations. They should also distinguish the leaders’ promise from the separate question of what happens at disputed shoals.
Promises do not enforce themselves.
Takeaway: Counsel should treat the pledge as a political commitment while the binding terms remain unsettled.
via apnews.com (Original)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in International law and legal practice at Global Law Wire.
324 articles
Also before the court
- Marcos Stresses Upholding South China Sea Arbitral Award Ahead of 10th Anniversary
- Manila: 2016 South China Sea Award 'Not Subject to Negotiation'
- Beijing Hits Back at US-Led Coalition Over South China Sea Ruling Anniversary
- China rebukes 'joint hype' as South China Sea arbitration turns 10
- EU and 14 Nations Reaffirm 2016 South China Sea Arbitral Ruling